International Livestock Research Institute Training course report Epi on Safari June 2013 i © 2013 International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI) This publication is copyrighted by the International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI). It is licensed for use under the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License. To view this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/. Unless otherwise noted, you are free to copy, duplicate, or reproduce, and distribute, display, or transmit any part of this publication or portions thereof without permission, and to make translations, adaptations, or other derivative works under the following conditions: ATTRIBUTION. The work must be attributed, but not in any way that suggests endorsement by ILRI or the author(s) NON-COMMERCIAL. This work may not be used for commercial purposes. SHARE ALIKE. If this work is altered, transformed, or built upon, the resulting work must be distributed only under the same or similar license to this one. NOTICE For any reuse or distribution, the license terms of this work must be made clear to others. Any of the above conditions can be waived if permission is obtained from the copyright holder. Nothing in this license impairs or restricts the author’s moral rights. Fair dealing and other rights are in no way affected by the above. The parts used must not misrepresent the meaning of the publication. ILRI would appreciate being sent a copy of any materials in which text, photos etc. have been used. Compiled and formatted by Tezira Lore Citation ILRI (International Livestock Research Institute). 2013. Epi on Safari: A training course report. Nairobi, Kenya: ILRI. ii Contents Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 1 Objectives ........................................................................................................................................................... 1 Training summary ............................................................................................................. 2 Allocation of priority research areas ................................................................................................................... 2 Indicators used to determine A4NH budget allocated to scientists’ research programs .................................... 4 Annex 1: Program ............................................................................................................. 5 Annex 2: List of participants ............................................................................................. 6 Annex 3: Training materials .............................................................................................. 7 1 Introduction The Epi on Safari training course was held from 24 April to 3 May 2013 at the Serena Mountain Lodge, Mount Kenya National Park, Nyeri. The course was designed for a small group of newly recruited postdoctoral fellows and graduate students attached to the Food Safety and Zoonoses program of the International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI). The course program is provided in Annex 1 and the list of participants in Annex 2. Objectives The main objectives of the course were to:  introduce the postdoctoral scientists to epidemiology research at ILRI;  identify areas for targeted capacity strengthening through discussion and practical; and  get input on epidemiological real world datasets we are working on. The main speaker was Prof Ian Dohoo, professor emeritus from the University of Prince Edward Island, Canada. In addition, Prof Brian Perry was present as an invited guest speaker. Prof Perry is an honorary professor of the University of Edinburgh; visiting professor at the University of Oxford and honorary professor of the University of Pretoria. 2 Training summary The training materials and presentations are provided in Annex 3. Allocation of priority research areas On the evening of Monday 29 April 2013, the team held a meeting to discuss the allocation of various research projects to the postdoctoral fellows. Table 1 below gives a summary of what was agreed upon. Table 1: Datasets for analysis and peer-reviewed publication Dataset Postdoc Avian influenza in Nigeria, Bangladesh and Egypt Cristobal GET Dairy Johanna Uptake of Newcastle disease vaccine in Tanzania and Kenya Johanna Cysticercosis prevalence Cristobal Cysticercosis risk factors Silvia Cost effectiveness analysis of participatory disease surveillance in Kenya Cristobal Validation of participatory epidemiology Pablo & Barbara Risk factors for bloody diarrhoea in children in Cambodia Silvia Prevalence of pig diseases and zoonoses in Laos Silvia Leptospirosis in South Vietnam Barbara Slaughterhouse in Vietnam Barbara It was also agreed that the postdocs would take a major role in supporting various projects. These were allocated as shown in Table 2 below. Table 2: Research for a postdoc to take a major role in supporting Project Postdoc Rapid integrated assessment Silvia and others Rift Valley fever projects Cristobal Mycotoxins in the feed-dairy chain in Kenya (MyDairy) Johanna EcoZD outputs Silvia/Barbara Safe Food, Fair Food project – Tanzania and Ethiopia Barbara/Cristobal (economics)/Silvia/Pablo (Hung, Kohei, Delia, Eric, Johanna) PigRisk Barbara/Cristobal/ Pablo (Hung, Kohei, Delia, Eric, Johanna) Multiple pathogen survey in dairy cattle in Tanzania Barbara & Silvia Disease, poverty and the environment: Costs and benefits of One Health Johanna/Cristobal 3 Specific postdocs were assigned to be the contact points for country value chains. These are indicated in Table 3 below. Table 3: Country value chains for a postdoc to be the contact point Country value chain Contact point Ethiopia Barbara Tanzania Barbara Uganda Kristina Senegal Sylvia India Johanna Vietnam Cristobal Nicaragua Cristobal 4 Indicators used to determine A4NH budget allocated to scientists’ research programs Indicator Author or co-author of a peer reviewed paper / book chapter (ISI or other recognized journal) Author or co-author of an oral presentation/poster at a scientific conference, symposium or major workshop Author or co-author of guide/manual/training course/methodology/set of tools or instruments which can be used by external people Be a member of editorial or other board Organize or co-organize a big meeting or major event (e.g. workshop with 30-70 external participants; symposium at ISVEE) Document involvement in development, testing or release of tools/decision-support/diagnostic which can be used by external people Run or maintain a platform or database Maintain a website/blog/network Write an article/brief/technical paper/blog post Supervise graduate students at ILRI Lead a training course Have a high level policy engagement (national, regional or global level) Write a successful proposal Be a project principal investigator or coordinator Number of outputs All time on A4NH (%) Time funded by A4NH; A4NH should fund no more than 50% of any scientist’s time Time project funded Only outputs in Mahider, websites, reported to A4NH or in the Markets, Gender & Livelihoods Theme publication list included. The number of outputs produced will influence the amount of A4NH budget you receive for your science agenda. Food Safety and Zoonoses should put all planned and achieved outputs in work plans, key result areas and performance evaluations Other outputs valued but not included in this metric include:  be a reviewer for a journal;  give a training module or session in a course led by others;  lower level policy engagement (municipal, provincial etc.);  organize a small meeting;  write an unsuccessful proposal;  submit a peer-reviewed paper;  be a member of a project team;  support interns;  present at a meeting; and  be a trainer on a course organized by someone else. 5 Annex 1: Program 0900 to 1300 hours 1400 to 1700 hours 1830 to 1930 hours Thurs 25 Apr Participatory epidemiology Fri 26 Apr Survey planning Bias Presentations: Research background and interests Postdoctoral fellows Sat 27 Apr ILRI administrative procedures Sun 28 Apr FREE DAY Mon 29 Apr Missing data Ian Dohoo Causal diagrams Project allocation Tue 30 Apr Presentations: Research background and interests Postdoctoral fellows Publications: Writing a thesis chapter or journal article Ian Dohoo Livestock & Fish Tom Randolph Research Methods Group Jane Poole Wed 1 May Model validation/multinomial models Ian Dohoo Guest presentation Brian Perry Grand explorations Thurs 2 May Flexible Bush walk Systematic literature review 1700 to 1800 hours: ‘Cow Killer’ Fri 3 May Impact assessment Ian Dohoo Leave after lunch 6 Annex 2: List of participants No. Name Designation Sex (M/F) 1 Prof Ian Dohoo (Main Speaker) Professor emeritus (epidemiology), Department of Health Management, Atlantic Veterinary College, University of Prince Edward Island, Charlottetown, Canada M 2 Prof Brian Perry (invited guest speaker) Honorary Professor, College of Medicine and Veterinary Medicine, University of Edinburgh, UK; Visiting Professor of Tropical Veterinary Medicine, Nuffield Department of Clinical Medicine, University of Oxford, UK; and Honorary Professor, Department of Veterinary Tropical Diseases, University of Pretoria, South Africa M 3 Bernard Bett Veterinary epidemiologist, Food Safety and Zoonoses Team, ILRI Kenya M* 4 Delia Grace Program Leader, Food Safety and Zoonoses and Theme Leader, Agriculture Associated Diseases, A4NH, ILRI Kenya F 5 Fred Unger Poultry Health Specialist / Epidemiologist, ILRI Thailand M 6 Hung Nguyen Joint scientist of Swiss TPH (Basel, Switzerland) and ILRI (Nairobi, Kenya) M* 7 Jane Poole Statistician and head of the Research Methods Group, ILRI Kenya F 8 Jeffrey Gilbert Project coordinator, Ecosystem approaches to the better management of zoonotic emerging infectious diseases in the Southeast Asia region (EcoZd project), ILRI Laos M 9 Tom Randolph Director, CGIAR Research Program on Livestock and Fish, ILRI Kenya M 10 Barbara Szonyi Postdoctoral fellow F 11 Cristobal Verdugo Postdoctoral fellow, ILRI Kenya M* 12 Johanna Lindahl Postdoctoral fellow, ILRI Kenya F 13 Natalie Carter PhD candidate (Epidemiology), University of Guelph; graduate fellow, ILRI Uganda F 14 Pablo Alarcon Postdoctoral research fellow, Veterinary Epidemiology, Economics and Public Health group, Royal Veterinary College. Visiting scientist, ILRI M 15 Sylvia Alonso Postdoctoral fellow, ILRI Kenya F 16 Rosekellen Njiru Senior administrative assistant, Food Safety and Zoonoses program, ILRI Kenya F* *Developing country             !  "##  ##   $ # %  #&#    % % ' ( #  )   "##            !  "# (*+   )% )     # #  ) $  #          %   ) ' )  )  $  )  ,  -   $   )  % $     )  $  )   $  )     ).#     / # "#       # #  )#.#   )#.#   )#     #    000      #   # "# )1#  $! # # #  2     !&3   .#       4+#5 6   )57 #     # #  # # #   (*+ $ ( '8 *+  9&&:::/     /$&   &  *";"(+) ) 5  4  $$#)    7  # #) $ :5 ( '8 *+ ++8 < 2+( *+ ;+("*+";  +=" !      "%1  "#   > ( '8 *+ /  +=" ( )>  .#  $  ( )>       ( )>    2 ) $4 5 $7   ) ( '8 *+ / ( 8+ #)# : ( #  2  ) ;#%   > ) "#  )      )    ( '8 *+ / *";     ? >% "  )  (*+ $ #         $#   #  ) )#   ,#   )> ) - (*+@ + )                 )    & #%     & )#     )  )    $ #%   ) (*+@ +    ) )# )    , )# -      )  )        #  )   #  )  #    ) >  )  .# )  )      .# $  )           # ) )%     )    (*+       )% #  #  )    )$      $      $   %%  #%   ##    AB    (*+         ) )   ) # # )   % :   )  )    )$#      ) %%%  $  )  #  $                             !     "#  $%&                                                               !           "              #                #       $  %&              %                 & !     !        '() *(+' %   &           ,  ,               %-.  !             &                      !                       /       0                  /       %          &  !       % &        1                        +         #                 #        %   ) !   & 1       2  /          %   3    &  /                 0             &                          /          %       &       ! '()  )        -#              3 %           !    #     &                     -            !   %     !   &                           -       %&   !/          !        -                %&  /                              )                  / !                 !      4                - !  3                "        !   3                  5            #   (              /                  %         &    6 7"7 )+6     6+1 )7 "+6   8                          !          .  %    &  8                       %      8     & 1       9   /            (                /     !         - !                            %  &       /       7                              /             /      7        .                     /           ,  ,  7                                /         8      '(    8  :  ;   )         $                    <                                     )  7        ) =       $    ,     -     %  &    ! )    #                                 4         $             -          >     7   -    %                 % " ?  , &?           1       @  A 1  6 7   ,  7 '            >          $      7          >                     !     !                ,            '        033    3  3BC92:39CCC3   '          033    3 33 3   3    %6 0>           &  >         $  1 -+7             $    1       D        %                !     "#  $%&  '      $         #    ..                                $                )      = $         !  $     %     &    !           %  E E&       %      &  8              &*      !     !      + ,  ,     %        &     , ,  ,    ( %        &       %      !         &                    2  - ,  ,    (          !    !   #    !   )/=8              . ,  ,    (          +                          #           !            )      )/=8  )   .      $     +                      / ,  ,                    +         )  /=    8 %)/=8&    .      $         E   E               -                              #                   9 0  "                     $            - !                                  -           F       )          5     %      &  )                       G              %  GB   B&  ,     #  0   #     %  GBGC@&      %  GBGCHC92I&         <<,,//                      !    ,     #           #  % &(       $             %       &  $  % "   ? , & #                      %  .     &              @      # (%   ;                                                 ;      J   ;        ;                                                   % $       &         .           !         '                   '        !                                 ;  )6<     J   ;           $             !        ;                                 D         1                  !     "#  $%&   #                      .        8  #                %    $  &                                           ? 7<,                    #         %     &       % &                                     2  '  $   3                                           A     .  )      !                    '          % D9D9K  &                           6         5           1        9       )        9          )     6          '  #   2 ( '  $                  3                         7     .    8   %      ?   .           & %   ,                   $  ,  5     /         %            > L  &  +                   %    &  F       3             5 6              <    G@9G          ;              ?               2    )     '      !              8               %E        E&            %   J&A           -             %-   J& '  #   9   '  $        7                  $          4/    4  -5                       7   5            /   $ %    &   4  E8          .     E%  $             &  E+             .     E                      E+             .      E               /       @ 4    / M     $  N            / M        N K9  .  !                            2    /     .           "    M          M           M       /         !                   !% &    !        :  .    '  033    3O  33   3 3('    7 033   3 3  3CCCC9D3  !   )P    "   >  %  ' 8  &    ' " %  ' 8  & '  #   @                                                                  Q !Q !                                "                               #                   $        %                  &    '     (                        Q !Q Q  )               $             '  %    *(                    +   + "  ,              " '&     ( ' (   '( -   '+ !  . ( / " '     ( ' ( -   '+ Q  0 ( '(        Q !Q 1                       /   &     2& 3     2  3       &                  *   ! 4  *                      *  $                      ,           5               4 '     6 (      Q !Q 7                                      $             4        4          5   5            5   $5                        Q !Q 8  ,                            $       98     8    :   !       %            !       8          2 3            8   ***  2 3                !""!##$##%%!&'%!!$&!#( '''##$##%%(%%%#"!#(  ) * +),- .  /0 .1#2    !''!&#&&"$(&!!$""!&!!% "#"%&#&&"$(&#%#((''& 3 ./0 .1&2    !&#'$"'##%%$'""($#(!(%#$$ %"('!##%%$'$&("'#'$(%      Q !Q ;        5     6                       2 3%                     <8=  '    (  >$ :  8       '  8 (         $     8     !  8 /,/  44 5 /,6 / /11& 4 ,6   /5  745)  / 1&745)   )/1## 745)   8/1## 4 / 1## 3/. 1!                 !!%#((('&$!#!('&%!&$"%( (#((('&$#%('&%$"%(       Q !Q ?         &          '   4   5(  6                @             >$ : '       8   (         '!! (    !      /,6 /,/11& 4 ,6   /5  745)  / 1&745)   )/1## 745)   8/1## 4 / 1## 3/. 1!                 !'!#(("(!(#&"$#$%'( "'#(("(!(&"$$%'(       Q !Q A             %       :              6                  '                  (         5       '   5(          6                         $  6            4          Q !Q B  >$        !B1  C 1 ?  /,/ 9/ 0 .2  44 5 /,6 / &11& 4 ,6   /5  745)  / 1(745)   )/1## 745)   8/1## 4 / 1## 3/. 1!%                 !&%#((&#&%"$!$$!'&!(!" %(#((&#&%"%$$'(!(!"   :       >     *           $   5  Q8  C Q8  /,6 / (11& 4 ,6   /5  745)  / 1(745)   )/1## 745)   8/1## 4 / 1## 3/. 1!%                 !!(#((("(!"%"&&!%'%# %#((("(!&!"&&'#&'%#   :                          ' (      Q !Q !       $                                  D    6    ' (            :    :  E!     :  $        %     //9           3::     !&%#((&#&%&##&% %(#((&#&%&##&%      !               '        (      Q !Q !!               2   3 '   (                         '(       ' $ (                        5    '    (  /:             '*   FC  G                   (  >$  '  1%7  ?( /,/  44 5 /,6 4/11& 4 ,6   /5  745)  / 1&745)   )/1&"$$ 745)   8/1" 4 / 1&"$$ 3/. 1(                 &($#%%&#$!!#!#&'"%!#&" !%$(&(&#$!!#&#%$!%"$   :       >%        'H!1??(      Q !Q !Q              4              H    '(       H     '(         C                 '  (                    '   (    '   (      !     '  (     !    '  (     Q  Q      H I           6       @@ '   (           5 F $         '  4  5    (       F $                     Q !Q !1  >$     1   !?8     /,6 5/11& 4 ,6   /5  745)  / 1&745)   )/1#& 745)   8/1" 4 / 1#& 3/. 1(                 !""&""$&"#&#%&(''$$(!! ''%''"&"#&#%##$#!'&&(''$%   :    >          Q !Q !7                         F 2   3                    '  (    C -   6    6             ! "#$  %  #   & $ '()       2   3     5                       @                   %            4          Q !Q !8    :  *   +  ,-- & (!   ." / &" " 0  & $ 123)(1232   &   ,-, & #  4 (!   #  5%6 7#! !"    8"    9 &%: + $ 22(',  " + ,-- 5 " ;  ;# "(! "" "" "#  4    4 <#(("#< $  #" "   7 =   # $ '                  6       4      '        (                5       @    : :CC  * **C CD *                6   C     2     3      Q !Q !; ;/5 5< / ;5. 4  =< / ;    / &( /5    6> (><#(>< -;<// 54   ;- 4  . /  .4/./5 5< / .9?  ; <<, < / . ### ; </? //+//455/+  5& ; )@/   5    5/+<4   )/ 4/ . ###9 ;/5  5/5 ;.   545) 0#&2 <5/ ; 6<5  545) /.  9/A/ A/ . /5/+ /<5 // ""##& .  1 4 502 ;/ <  .   545)  <   545) /     ; ,<&/##  / ./ /10 B1##2 ;  5    ; /A/4 ,/A< 0<///2 /,/ ;<4/<A/ A 55 /   5<  /,6 / /11& ;/,/5/5 ;0//45<  5,< // . +/$2 ;  5 ,&#<  ;<// <  5? ; 54 )<  /  / ) */ &# .) *1 00 &2- ;/<$<  <) * / ) * ),) *6./,/10 11$2 ) /,/A/,/5  5/50 ,<.2A ) * ;  5    /,6 /,/11& ;/  /5 ;      ; / /&($/ "9#$" ./ ;/5&"/ "#$ ./ /  . // ""##( ), .6.  1 4 502 /  .    ), .6.1  ./ &10 .11#CB1&"2 / &1&0 .11&CB1"#$2  ;  5    ; / /<  /,</       Q !Q !? /,/ 9/ 0 .2 /,6 / &11& ;  ,/5  4  ; 54<   /)+ ./ / ;?   (# ./ (#/ ;. / / (#+<< 4   ./ / /  . // ""##" ), .6.  1 4 502 /  .    ), .6./ (10 B1(#2 ;  5    /,/ 9/ 0 .2 /,6 / (11& ;   /5/  )4/+< ,  /   ;< )), / 0+.</2 ; /.)/  /  /5+<      ; 54/5 <///5 .// / /,/ /,6 / &11& ; 54/5*./    4 /,/ 9/ 0 .2 /,6 / &11& //9  ;;; +++/ . .< ;4/ /5 ;  5,< /"/ // ""## . 1&00 4 5022 / &-"   ;</.  <<  / 545) /6!9" $ .4/1011!11"11$2 ; /<  /,<+/< 5 ,/5.4 /,/ /,6 4/11& ;  . /9 /54< . /501&!2 ;54/./5 ;  5,/5&'$  /< <"// )  // ""##' .  1 4 502 /   ),6.&'$1 B1&'$ .5/1011!11"11$2C&'$11& &'$ ; 54<54/./5/0/4  ,/ 2 /,6 5/11&      Q !Q !A                                                          ! "" #  ! "  $  # "# "          # % &  %  '     &       '    & &&     ! (!  #  ! " (!   ) *+ ) *#+               !""#$ % &!"'# ( ! )"##$"%   "''' ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *+ , - .%&*.*/0#1+2 3 4 )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 66*  *"#""'"'$0"7'")07$#7$ 8*7$"0'##$"#""7''"$'70"$07 )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 6*  *'0#7$'"#'00)#"#$7$ 8*)7"#$""#")$'''')$'#)0' )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 9   666 ! :  :            #                   #      !"#  $                 (##  (##  (# ( # ! "#  ) %                 !""#$ % &!"'# ( ! )"##$"%   "''' ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  * , - .%&*.*/0#1+2 3 4 )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 66*  *"$0#"$7777"7'"$$"00"""' )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 6*  *'0$#7$#''"#'00###7$7"$"7 )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 9   666 ! :  :  %      +  *  *;  '    666"66* 76*    *<  )))))))))))5))))))))))))))))))))))5)))))))))) 666*$''*$ 66*0"#*" 6*"0*$ )))))))))))5))))))))))))))))))))))5)))))))))) < *77*   %  , -  %     . * /#+ / */#+ .  /   %  , -  %    &  . *!/"#+ / */"#+ . !/   %  ,   *  + . * /+ / *!/+ . * 0+ / *0!+ . (!     (   =   8>  2 '?( ! )777$ 2 ?( ! )7$"'## 2 "?( ! )7'#"7 2 7?( ! )7'#"7$ 2 ?( ! )7'#"""         !"'"#$7 % &!"''''' ( ! )7'#"""%   "' ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *+ , - .%&*.*/0#1+2 3 4 )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 66*  *000"$$#770''''700''$"7  ( *)"$7$""70)"''')#'$"#$)'#'$$$#   = *7#$'0'#7'''''$7#0$$'7  *)"")'"'''')"$"$'$)"#''0$"  8> *)'"0'0''77$7$)$#'''')'"#7)'#7 8*0'##""7'"$'0''''#'#070$7 )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 6*  *#7"$$"77"'''$#77"""  ( *)'#$"#"#0)""'''#)"''7")"#70$   = *70'#"'""#0''''077'$$$'$7  *)'0"77#0#)'''')#0")$#$"#7#  8> *)'#$$00''$7'#)"'''')'#'7"7)'777'# 8*#$"""$00"''''##00'#" )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 9   666 ! :  :     /664 ' "/64 ' !""$"0 % &!"''''7        ( && & 1.    *)  2  + . (   *)  2  + .  0 ( . (  )  2  . (  )  2  . *( +  . (   ) ) @- : 76 A     =  @ @:  !              B?C3 C C 8  B @           (   =   8>     !3   D "    EF/664E3 F'#@/64E3 F 7 EF5 G @         (   =   8>   )# 2 '?( ! )777$ 2 ?( ! )7077 2 "?( ! )70 2 7?( ! )77 2 ?( ! )777         !"#0' % &!"''''' ( ! )777%   "'77' /664 )#/64 ' "/664 ( )#/64 ( ' 7/664  = )#/64  = ' /664 )#/64 ' #/664 8> )#/64 8> ' ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *+ , - .%&*.*/0#1+2 3 4 )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 66*  *'##"'#770'''''""'#"7$  ( *)7'0#'0#7#)7"''')007)0#   = *"770$'$'"$#70''''0"70"7####0  *)#0##7'00$)#"#'''')7#$7)7"##77  8> *)'""#''"")""'''')'"7'#)''7 8*"#7''00$7''''$770'$00 )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 6*  *$"'0#$$70''''""#7  ( *)$'000'"')7"''')0"7$)"7$00'   = *0"'#770''''"7#  *)'70'007$)#"#'''')""0)$#'$$  8> *)'#'0''##$")""'''')'#$$$)'7'7 8*707$0'#0"##'''''$#$7" )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 9   666 ! :  :                 @ <  3         (   =   8>    :             ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *  62+H2+ )))))))))))))5))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *)777$")77"$0#"'7  *)777$")7'#""""#'7#7'7$ ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))     ( ! )    !"#7 6: ?    % &!"'"          ' &     ,   %    ) *+ . && & &   %    % % 3   4 %     ) *#+ . && & &   %  #  % % 3   4 %         #    ) *+ ) *#+               ((( %  %     ) )  *+ # *+ *+ 5 6  6  & '   ( & (    (  &        ( $  &) (     *+ # *+ *+ 5 6  6  (     1 ' ,&  ' &   78 9  ' 9        !"##0 % &!"''''' ( ! )7#7%   "'7' ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *+ , - .%&*.*/0#1+2 3 4 )))))))))))))5))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *00'77""0$'"'''''#77$'7  ( *)7"$""'#0)7'0'''")#770)0$###   = *"7$$'$"'''''""'#70#  *)#$0"'$)#"$'''')'0$)7#$0"  8> *)'"##77''7''0#)#$'''')'7$#)'0# )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 8 *)0$"#'#6 =:   8 "*)$#7''$ ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *%   =9 3 )))))))))))))5))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 666*% 5I8 '77$ 66*% 8 I5I8 "'#$ 6*% 8 "I5''0# * $  '   **  :  :666:66:6: :   @  !   3  3     !   # 3         (   =   8> J#      (   =   8>  66 "#0$7# ""66 #$#"7"7" 77666 70$7#'7$'' 66   "$#7'7 ##666 #'707##   :666:66:6J#   :666:66:6 )0007#7"##"0#'#"0$# "")0'#7$7#7$"#0#7$'#'0" 77)"$0$#0#'77 )0$""$$##0'$#'7'## ##)070'07''$#7"7##'7" &+$&  '  & **  @   ! 3  :  :     >> = :666:66:6 = !5JJJ > :666 =JJJ > :66 =JJJ > :6 =JJJ     "7 >  B666B  "B66B  7B6BJJJ !                         &  &   && &         '                    (   =   8>               (   =   8>               ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *  62+H2+ )))))))))))))5))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *)777$")7'#""""#'7#7'7$  *)777$")7#70$0'#$  1  $    %         (   =   8>    6::  ( ! )   : :   =    :    ? !"# % &!"'  :     %     %   &  3      -      A) =   =&=&"  0#'07#7$  ( )7'0"0$07)0$"   = 7"""7$#'#  )#700#)'$  8> )'"$7)'"00## 8##7#000770 H  <  %    6:  K   *!":&!"  )))))))))))))5)))))))))))))))))))))))))) 6*'$# )))))))))))))5))))))))))))))))))))))))))  *'''  ( *'#'   = *#7'"$  *''7'  8> *'$'"# )))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 6      : 3  3   !  ! :     : !  3                    !    " #$ #      %  % & '%   (    ' # #  #)     #  )     )      & '%   %    #  #  #  %       # ( #    #     %  %    % # #     & '%   ( #  ) %   )'   *+,*+  !   !    )'   *-+,-  $.   / %     /     ##  (      #  %    *' ' +#'    '  #'  (  )   '# ' 012  #      (3 #'  (   .# %  % .* %# % +  4      # %  * '%  +   4  5   #  %    # ' #   %   )   #6,.#   #    #    %    #  %    3%' % 4   % 3  %      ' ##  #1)     '    '      #   ($78  )  #9  %  %   %    ( #% )  #     *     ' )   +  (    #   ( )    % ' # (     ! # )      %  :    ( '#%  )%' %  ( #%      #  #   :1$#'*  '  #'+  !  ; ( ) %   #% )   # #'      )% 3 %   ! # )    '  %  $.%   (   #  ' % 999)'  < 8 $$ # # #  =' #    :    %  #%  #  ' %  #% )   #   (   # ( %    #'   : )     #  )   %   % '  )' %  '   #  )    (    #     *>?>@? #+  )' %3   ##7 #        '     #  )    # ( # #  ) 3                        !"# $!%!&'(' " )*  +&'(( ! , -  )%  &'(' "      "*.  % /0" &''& *%"+  1 23  "/    "3043&'(&5 3  * (       /     " //    "  // /  "   , 67   8  /   / ,        67   /   /         * &  / /""   ( "(/ ""/    "/3 "     &/ "  " 9&/  "& 3" "&"   "&  / "    ""  /""   * :     * ;                                                     /             /"/8/   / /      * <     *!%=   // /     /     /  *%= // / / / , //  /"     $ /  /  >  6   ?7 *2%=  2*% // / /  / , //  /"    "   >  6  ?7  * @                   "  *!%"//    *%*2%" / A  "   "    /  /   A  " ""/       " "    "  "  /   /*% / B/  / "    /*2%  B "/ /  "  "   * C *        "    "> / /   ""     D ,  > "  /   *% /  ,      " E,,8 E* "     &'('/  + *F  >       "  * G          ,    ,  "/  /   /       333 ""A  /  3  6"> 7  //  /        /   "   /"  " / ""/  " "  /               " "/    *!*!"/   * H  A/          / /       <('   /  "  /         /     ,/ 3333"   * ('       "   / /   333    /    /  /    /  // /  /        A/    /    /   /"    "      ?  (&/   / ( , /  3   * (( "        /    "   3    /  "  /         >" " / /    /    /         "   """    /         "    / "   !1 ,  * (&           "6 7   &;<;&;';  ,&'I   + F/  " * 333 *!%    >    *%    > A"  A" 2*%    >  >   &            >A"  "   "           * (:      2     "   " A"           *!% '3&': '3&(' '3&'G E '3'(H '3'&( '3'(G *% '3&': '3(H@ '3(H& E '3'(H '3'&( '3'(G 2*% '3&': '3&<< '3&<: E '3'(H '3'&: '3'&' 2 &;'; (H'( &;'; *!% E "   E "   *%  "//"  :I K '3;(: '3;H@ '3;;@ '3;(< I/ (H3H@@ G3':< '3:@: E '3&(& '3&:& '3&'H '3&'G A" K '3;G' '3:'H '3;C; '3;@< I/ :<3<;H (3(;@ :3'&( E '3&;< '3:H: '3&;G '3&;@  K '3((< '3(:; '3(&< '3(&C I/ (@3 K '3;(: '3<(' '3;H' '3;@( I/ &:3:'@ (G3<:G ((3;H@ E '3&(& '3&:; '3&'& '3&'< A" K '3;G' '3CC& '3;@H '3;C< I/ @'3H&H &3::; '3H K '3;(: '3;:H '3;<' '3;:; I/ @I HI ? 0<@+.>     $ $ $ !$                       !&   #          ($(    0-*         !               "  ""#     !"  !""#         %        &  !              !&   #      ( -*            " ""#     !" !""#      !&   #     ( /-*            " ""#     !" !""#      !&   #     (      $      0-*            "  ""#     !"  !""#  * (H   2        2       !      !"   &  # '1 '34561    7 ( "( 8  ' 1          !&   #        -*            " ""#     !" !""#   2        2       !      !"   &  # '1 '34561    7 ( "( 8  ' 1          !&   #       /-*            " ""#     !" !""#   2        2       !      !"   &  # '1 '34561    7 ( "( 8  ' 1          !&   #            $   A  0-*            "  ""#     !"  !""#   2        2       !     '1 !'  1 "   &  # '1 '34561    7 ( "( 8  ' 1          !&   #        -*            " ""#     !" !""#   2        2       !     '1 !'  1 "   &  # '1 '34561    7 ( "( 8  ' 1          !&   #       /-*            " ""#     !" !""#   2        2       !     '1 !'  1 "   &  # '1 '34561    7 ( "( 8  ' 1          !&   #        * &'    %     $   0-*    %    (      %'9:;1 '9:;1  '/1 -*    %   (    %'9:;1 '9:;1 '/1 /-*    %   (    %'9:;1 '9:;1  '/1        %    (       (    222  (    %'9:;1 '9:;1 '/1  * &( Education and research background  D. V. M. Cornell University, USA, 2005  Ph.D. Cornell University, USA, 2010  National Institutes of Health/ Fogarty International Clinical Research Scholar (NIH/FICRS), 2008, F. Oswaldo Cruz, Brazil  Diagnostic epidemiologist at Texas Veterinary Medical Diagnostic Laboratory 2010-2011  Post-doc at Texas A&M University, 2010-now Dissertation  Geographic distribution and zoonotic potential of Cryptosporidium in dairy cattle ◦ Cross-sectional study  Szonyi B, Seasonal variation in the prevalence and molecular epidemiology of Cryptosporidium infection in dairy cattle in the New York City Watershed. Parasitology Research (2010), 107(2): 317-25. ◦ Case-control study and risk factor modeling  Evaluation of factors associated with the risk of infection with Cryptosporidium parvum in dairy calves. American Journal of Veterinary Research (2012), 73(1): 76-85. ◦ Spatial analysis and Bayesian statistics  Szonyi B. Temporal and spatial dynamics of Cryptosporidium parvum infection on dairy farms in the New York City Watershed: a cluster analysis based on crude and Bayesian risk estimates. The International Journal of Health Geographics (2010), 9:31. ◦ Molecular typing of samples from Kenya  Szonyi et al. First report of Cryptosporidium deer-like genotype in Kenyan cattle. Veterinary Parasitology (2008), 153(1-2): 172-175 Dissertation ◦ Experience might be relevant for: ◦ Relation between poverty, pig-keeping and epilepsy in western Kenya. ◦ Comparing traditional knowledge of farmers to laboratory analysis for animal disease and community knowledge of disease prevalence to conventional surveys in Kenya. ◦ Prevalence of pig diseases and zoonoses in Laos. ◦ Multiple pathogen survey in dairy cattle in Tanzania – small project -design ◦ Testing food safety interventions –SFFF NIH/FICRS  Molecular epidemiology of leptospirosis in Latin America ◦ Szonyi et al. An outbreak of severe leptospirosis in capuchin (Cebus) monkeys. The Veterinary Journal (2011), 188: 237-239.  Experience might be relevant for: ◦ Leptospirosis in south Vietnam TVMDL/TAMU  Enhance collaboration between DL and Veterinary College in epidemiology ◦ Evaluate accuracy of new diagnostic tools  Schroeder et al. Development and performance evaluation of calf diarrhea pathogen nucleic acid purification and detection workflow. Journal of Veterinary Diagnostic Investigation (2012), 24(5): 945-953. ◦ Use diagnostic lab data to understand disease status of animal populations in TX  Szonyi et al. Spatio-temporal epidemiology of Tritrichomonas foetus infection in Texas bulls based on state-wide diagnostic laboratory data. Veterinary Parasitology (2012), 186(3-4): 450-455.  Gautam et al. Identifying high risk areas of Coccidioidomycosis in Texas using serology data from dogs. Zoonoses and Public Health. In Press.  Szonyi et al. Emergence of Corynebacterium pseudotuberculosis in Texas horses.  Szonyi et al. Epizootic hemorrhagic disease in captive white-tailed deer in Texas. ◦ Understand Lyme disease distribution in TX - grant  Szonyi et al. Exploratory spatial data analysis of human Lyme disease cases in Texas. TVMDL/TAMU  Experience might be relevant for: ◦ Sensitivity and specificity of PDS for detection bird flu in Egypt. ◦ Comparing traditional knowledge of farmers to laboratory analysis for animal disease and community knowledge of disease prevalence to conventional surveys in Kenya. ◦ Multiple pathogen survey in dairy cattle in Tanzania – small project -design ◦ Prevalence of pig diseases and zoonoses in Laos. Research background and interests Pablo Alarcon Post-doctoral research fellow in food system Epi on Safari meeting – ILRI - 2013 Education and Experience • Veterinary Medicine (University of Cordoba, Spain) – 2005 • Meat Inspector in Abattoir (UK) - 2006 • MSc in Veterinary Epidemiology (RVC/LHSTM) - 2007 • Research assistant in veterinary epidemiology (RVC) – 2009 • PhD in veterinary epidemiology (RVC) – 2009 • Post-doctoral research fellow in food systems (RVC and ILRI) – since 2012 PMWS (Post-weaning Multi-systemic Wasting Syndrome) Porcine Circovirus type 2 Multi-factorial disease ! (The virus itself is not enough to trigger clinical signs) Disease impact Animal welfare High cost to the farmer Subclinical pigs Aims and Objectives • Identify the most effective, profitable and social acceptable options to control PMWS at the farm level Understand severity of disease on farms Risk factors associated with severity of the disease Economic impact of the disease Identify the most cost-effective control measure Investigate best way of communication the results Farm recruitment April 2008 to April 2009 147 farrow-to-finishing farms  Complete data for 141 farms (17% England sow population) Researchers: • 2 qualified veterinarians • 2 days pig free before each visit Data collection: • PMWS • Production performance • Possible risk factors (management, environment, etc.) Definition of PMWS severity Principal component analysis PMWS severity score (0-10) Alarcon, P., et al., Assessment and quantification of post-weaning multi-systemic wasting syndrome severity at farm level. Pre. Vet. Med. 98 (2011), 19-28 Alarcon, P., et al., Farm level risk factors associated with severity of Post-weaning multi-systemic wasting syndrome. Prev. Vet. Med. (2011) 101, pp.182-191 Risk factors: Environment interaction Farm Biosecurity Co-infections PMWS – Disease economic model Industry cost : -£53 million /year (-72 to -34) -200 0 200 400 600 800 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 £ / s ow / ye ar PMWS severity Total PMWS + PCV2SI PMWS-D + PMWS-R Sub-D + Sub-S Total profits Alarcon, P., et al., Cost of PMWS and porcine circovirus type-2 subclinical infection in England – an economic disease model. Pre. Vet. Med. (2013) In press. Alarcon, P., et al., Economic efficiency analysis of different strategies for the control of PMWS and porcine circovirus type 2 subclinical infection. Pre. Vet. Med. (2013) In press. Most cost-effective measure: Vaccination and Bio-security measures Development of a tool for decision-making process Investigation farmers decision process for disease control • Qualitative study (20 farmers) • Use of Socio-psychological framework • Provide recommendations to improve communication of research outputs Interests • Investigation of the epidemiology of zoonotic diseases in value chain context • Including link with human behaviour • Development of decision support tools: • Economic models • Risk analysis • Food system modelling • Multidisciplinary research THANK YOU palarcon@rvc.ac.uk Presentation Mt Kenya workshop 2013 Research background and interests Johanna Lindahl Quick-who am I • From Uppsala Sweden • DVM and PhD degree from Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences • Background as a clinician and county veterinarian Pojken (the boy) Pixel Thesis work Japanese Encephalitis Virus in pigs and vectors in the Mekong Delta- with special reference to urban farming • Publications – Reproductive performance in sows in relation to Japanese Encephalitis Virus seropositivity in an endemic area (Trop anim health and prod) – Occurrence of Japanese Encephalitis Virus Mosquito Vectors in Relation to Urban Pig Holdings (Am j trop med hyg) – Circulation of Japanese Encephalitis Virus in Pigs and Mosquito Vectors within Can Tho City, Vietnam (PLOS negl trop dis) What did I do? Teaching • Reproduction – Obstetrics – Gynaecology – Andrology • Master students – Presence of Japanese Encephalitis virus vectors in Can Tho City – Seroprevalence of Japanese Encephalitis Virus in pigs and dogs in the Mekong Delta – The quality of SLC selected semen Other projects • Stallion spermatozoa selected by single layer centrifugation are capable of fertilization after storage for up to 96 h at 6 C prior to artificial insemination (Acta Veterinaria Scandinavica) • Uganda cow reproduction study • Pan-flavivirus PCR Research interests Hung Nguyen-Viet - EPH, SwissTPH - FSZ, ILRI - CENPHER, Hanoi School of Public Health Epi on Safari expectations Nairobi, 27 April 2013 1. Mai 2013 Präsentationstitel 2 Hung Nguyen-Viet, 36 2005 PhD in Life and Environmental Sciences: Besançon, FR 2001 MSc in Environment, Health, Society: Besançon, FR 1999 BSc in Biology: Hanoi, VN 2009-now: Center for Public Health and Ecosystem Research, HSPH 2011-Now: joint appointee ILRI - Swiss TPH 2006-2009: Postdoc, Swiss TPH, Sandec/Eawag (Thailand, Vietnam, Côte d’Ivoire) 2011-now: lecturer HSPH environmental health 2011-now: Adjunct Faculty of AIT, Bangkok 2004 - 2006: Lecturer, Besançon, France Center for Public Health and Ecosystem Research (from 6.2013) Mission & activities CENPHER studies the health and well-being impacts of development factors (environmental, ecological, cultural, socio-economic, and demographic) using the integrative approaches of Ecohealth/One Health (Transdisciplinarity), with special focus on South East Asia as well as links to analogous issues in Africa. We focus on the link between health and agriculture, infectious and zoonotic diseases, chemical pollution, and food safety and nutrition, at all levels from the lab to the field. Main themes of research and training: 1. Ecosystem Health / One Health 2. Food Safety 3. Health Impact Assessment Team in Hanoi Ongoing projects: 1. Environmental sanitation and health: balancing between health risk, livelihood opportunities and environmental impacts 2. Ecohealth Field Building Leadership Initiative (FBLI): Advancing Ecohealth in Southeast Asia / Agricultural intensification and Health 3. Human-Animal-Environment transmission and risk factors of Leptospirosis 1. Ecosystem Health / One Health • Human health is determined by inter-linkages of human, animal and environmental health in a socio-ecological context using an integrated approach such as Ecohealth or One health. • Health impact of environmental pollution, agricultural intensification, urbanization, and environmental sanitation. The main health issues are tropical neglected diseases, zoonoses + environment, socio-economics. Main research themes Main research themes Ongoing projects: 1. PigRISK “Reducing disease risks and improving food safety in smallholder pig value chains in Vietnam” 2. FOOD-RISK “Strengthening Risk Assessment Capacities in Food Safety” 3. Risk assessment task force for food safety 4. Dioxin and food 5. Chemical contamination of drinking water 6. QMRA Asia 2. Food Safety • High food demand  an intensification of agricultural production  many benefits but also causes negative environmental and health effects • Main issues: microbial contamination, pesticide use, antibiotic residues, growth promoter, and toxins and how to use a risk-based approach to food safety management in the developing world. Prospective projects: 1. Air pollution and health (risk assessment) 2. Building up capacity and expertise on HIA for the region Main research themes 3. Health Impact Assessment • SEA – hotspot for infrastructure development projects (dam construction, mining industry) • Urbanisation, climate change, agriculture, waste management • Clear need for Health Impact Assessment in the region Expectation/interest - Design Quantitative Microbial Risk Assessment - Design Quantitative Chemical Risk Assessment - Design Lepto research – Thanh Hoa Vietnam - Testing food safety interventions – PigRISK- design (EcoZD) - Statistical modeling - Model validation - Analysis of EcoZD SH-Vietnam 1. Mai 2013 Präsentationstitel 8