6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands www.cta.int T he Technical Centre for Agricultural and Rural Cooperation (CTA) was established in 1983 under the Lomé Convention between the ACP (African, Caribbean and Pacific) Group of States and the European Union Member States. Since 2000, it has operated within the framework of the ACP–EU Cotonou Agreement. CTA’s tasks are to develop and provide products and services that improve access to information for ARD, and to strengthen the capacity of ACP countries to acquire, process, produce and disseminate information in this area. in the Agricultural and Rural Development of ACP Countries CTA annual seminar Brussels, Belgium 12 - 16 October 2009 http://annualseminar2009.cta.int COMPILATION DOCUMENT Postbus 380 the role of media in the agricultural and rural development of ACP countries — cta annual seminar - brussels, belgium COMPILATION DOCUMENT CTA the role of MeDIA Organised by CTA in collaboration with: CTA is financed by the European Union Centre Ivoirien de Recherches Economiques et Sociales IntoPrint Photographs Cover & p. 3: K. Hackshaw, G. Rambaldi, GRET p. 7: CTA p. 8: K. Hackshaw p. 12: S. Ouattara p. 13: K. Hackshaw p. p. p. p. p. p. 14: 15: 16: 19: 70: 71: K. Hackshaw R. H. Neun, S. Ouattara, T. Murray B. Guisse, CMA/WCA K. Hackshaw K. Hackshaw p. 72: K. Hackshaw p. 73: K. Hackshaw p. 87: GRET, G. Rambaldi COMPILATION DOCUMENT the role of MeDIA in the Agricultural and Rural Development of ACP Countries 3 Published by The (ACP-EU) Technical Centre for Agricultural and Rural Cooperation (CTA) Postbus 380 - 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands Tel: (31) 317 467 100 Fax: (31) 317 460 067 Email: cta@cta.int - Website: www.cta.int COMPILATION CTA Design www.acg-bxl.be Editing Anne Sweetmore, UK Printing Information, Press, Oxford, UK © CTA 2009 ISBN: 978 92 9081 429 0 Acknowledgements Organising a seminar is no easy matter, and involves the collective energy of a number of individuals. CTA wishes to acknowledge the input of all the individuals and organisations who contributed both to the seminar and to this document. This includes the members of the Steering Committee, who assisted in shaping and forming the themes and issues to be discussed, and also contributed by evaluating the abstracts. We also wish to thank all the authors and others who have contributed to this document, including participants in both the e-discussion and the seminar itself. 4 Expectations Aude Ehlinger, Head of partnerships at the NGO SOS Faim, in Cameroon and Burkina Faso Modeste Shabani Bin Sweni, Director, Radio Sauti ya Mkaaji Dr Hansjörg Neun, CTA Director, The Netherlands This was a terrific meeting. It gave us the opportunity to meet At the beginning of this seminar, I am fully satisfied with the way experts from all the CTA mem- I felt the theme being treated this workshop was organised, ber states – from Africa, the was too general and therefore particularly with the quality of Caribbean and the Pacific. The did not quench my thirst. I had the participants. CTA has good theme of the seminar, the role the feeling that what we heard criteria for selecting partici- of the media in agriculture, was was nothing more than a rep- pants. People tended to share fascinating. The recommenda- etition of what we had heard their knowledge systematically. tions show that there are enor- at other seminars. Fortunately, There were no “walk-ons”, as mous expectations that CTA, as gradually we turned to more we sometimes see at meetings. a small institution, will not be tangible examples. We heard Furthermore, I got an award in able to satisfy fully. We have a about field experiences, and the “Best Community Projects” fairly small budget. But I think limits to activities intended to category, which is a great bonus that, together with our partners strengthen information on agri- for me. It shows that our work in the ACP countries, we will try culture and by the farmers. I is important enough to be worth to share roles so that we can think this seminar will lead to an international prize. I am the apply some of the solutions that some concrete proposals, and only Congolese at this seminar are advocated. Our efforts at that the meeting will produce and, see, I got an award. I’m capacity-building for journalists an excellent document. thrilled! will be strengthened. We could, for instance, provide support for journalists who are networking, if they submit relevant training projects to us. 5 TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgements 4 Quotes, Expectations 5 Foreword 7 I Introduction 8 V Abstracts 22 1.1. Background 8 Media and ARD issues 22 1.2 The seminar in Figures 9 Media and Agricultural Extension 25 Media and Climate Change 27 Media and Gender Equality 29 Media Funding in ARD 32 Media and arid and semi-arid zones 33 Communication between Media and Other ARD Players 35 II Events 11 2.1 E  xecutive Summary: Why do the Media matter? 11 2.2 Brussels Briefing on the Media 13 2.3 Coming of Age 14 Contribution of the Media to Agricultural Policy 37 6 III Media 14 Institutional environment 3.1 Media coverage 14 Media, emerging new media service and ICTs 41 3.2 TV Programme 15 Working Group recommendations 43 3.3 Live Blogging 16 VI Annexes 45 39 IV Outputs 17 6.1 Programme 45 4.1 Summary – Pre-seminar blog 17 6.2 List of participants 52 4.2 Summary – E-discussion 19 6.3 25th Anniversary Programme 69 4.3 Brussels Declaration 20 6.4 Media Award Winners 70 6.5 More about the Media Award Winners 71 6.6 A long road, but well worth it 74 6.7 Articles from the pre-seminar blog 75 7.1 Acronyms and abbreviations 88 7.2 Order reports from previous seminars 89 Foreword C an the media participate fully in agricultural and rural development? If so, how should this be done in the context of the African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP) countries? These are the questions CTA considered at its 2009 annual seminar, held in Brussels, Belgium from 12 to 16 October. According to recent statistics, agriculture accounts for only 4–6% of GDP. This undoubtedly explains the low rate of government investment in the agricultural sector in most ACP countries. And if this is true, what conceivable reason would the media have to be interested in such an “insignificant” field? Perhaps we need to look more closely at the figures. According to a study by the Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture (IICA), these statistical data are incomplete and do not reflect the real contribution of agriculture. Argentina, for instance, has revised its original estimate from 4.6 to 32.3%, which includes the entire value chain, from transport to storage and processing, etc.; Brazil upped its figure from 4.3 to 26.2%; while in the USA, where only 2% of the working population is involved with agriculture, some 25% work in the food industry. Lastly, a World Bank study1 has revised its first estimate of the average rural sector contribution to the GDP from 26 to 41%. In other words, agriculture and rural development are big business. Not only are they important, they also make up a very attractive sector worth greater media coverage. I worked in Africa for 20 years, and know that media interest in agriculture is often limited to times of natural disaster, crop losses or food crises – or simply opening ceremonies for large projects. But agriculture has come back “loud and strong” onto the international development agenda. We can find proof in the studies mentioned above, and in the recent G8 decision to earmark €20 billion to promote agricultural output over the next 3 years. CTA, day in, day out, strives to convince politicians and their fellow citizens of the importance of agriculture and rural development. Furthermore, CTA is also persevering in its efforts to sensitise the media, as was the case in October 2006 at a seminar in the Bahamas, where memorable discussions were held between journalists and representatives of the ministries of agriculture of the Caribbean states. It is time for the media to shoulder their responsibility and promote a new perception of agriculture. Without them, the battle is lost in advance. CTA’s annual seminar, held during “CTA Week” in Brussels, brought together representatives of ACP countries to promote far-reaching dialogues aiming to facilitate interactions between the media, political decisionmakers and rural communities. During the week, CTA also celebrated its 25th anniversary. This was an excellent opportunity to strengthen partnerships with our governing authorities, especially the European Commission and the ACP Secretariat General, and to thank them for standing with us for the past 25 years and encouraging our partners to recognise our know-how and effectiveness. I should also like to address my sincere gratitude to everyone who worked relentlessly to make this seminar such a success. I am thinking especially of the members of the steering committee, and all our CTA team members, including the interns, who worked so very hard. I also would also like to thank the participants for their spirited contributions to the work sessions and discussions. Happy reading – and let me urge you to continue sharing your ideas through the new Media4Dev community. Dr Hansjörg Neun CTA Director 2005-February 2010 1 Guillermo E. Perry (author), William Foster (author), Daniel Lederman (author), Alberto Valdes (author), David M. De Ferranti (editor). 2005. Beyond the city: The Rural Contribution to Development. World bank, Washington, DC. 7 I – INTRODUCTION 1.1 Background D uring the past few years, international political communities have often discussed the consequences of food, economic and financial crises for development. The return of agriculture to the top of the development agenda is a reality. Some major multilateral institutions have carried out studies and reports on this theme, including: • t he 2003 progress report on the Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme (CAADP) of the New Partnership for Africa’s Development (NEPAD); • t he 2008 World Bank report on development; • t he 2009 FAO report on the state of food insecurity and agriculture; • t he analyses presented at various meetings of the G8 ministers of agriculture. In the ACP countries, the media often ignore these subjects or treat them lightly. To remedy this situation, the media should provide more reliable, up-to-date information on development and should disseminate information appropriately to political decisionmakers and rural communities, where people are often illiterate and number among the most seriously affected by these crises. 8 Despite the commitment to devote 10% of GDP to agriculture, stipulated in the 2003 Maputo Declaration, state budgets for this sector are still very low, mainly due to insufficient awareness of the importance of agriculture. The media have a role to play in funding and investment for agriculture. By creating greater awareness, they can encourage political decision-makers to become more actively involved in agricultural and rural innovation processes. This was the background to the international seminar that CTA held in Brussels (Belgium) from 12 to 16 October 2009 on the “Role of Media in the Agricultural and Rural Development of ACP Countries”, in order to: • contribute to formulating strategies to strengthen the media’s capacity to access and disseminate information on key questions related to agriculture in the ACP countries; Brussels Briefing • improve communications between the media and other actors involved in agricultural and rural development; • contribute to identifying support programmes for the media. The seminar was attended by over 170 experts from the sectors interlinking media and agricultural/ rural development – journalists of the written press, rural radio and television; research scientists; representatives of press agencies; communications specialists from public services and development projects; decision-makers from the six ACP regions (West, Central, East and Southern Africa, the Caribbean and the Pacific); national institutions in the EU countries, and regional and international organisations. The seminar focused on the following themes: • media coverage of agricultural and rural development (ARD) issues; Media awards Daily reports • c ommunications between the media and other actors in ARD; • t he media and the funding of agricultural development; • media capacity-building; • the role of new technologies in media development. The seminar programme was enhanced by pre-seminar activities including an e-discussion, with edifying input from over 2,000 experts. The media’s practical experiences in ACP communities were presented in specially-prepared videos, used to produce a TV programme that was broadcast in more than 30 ACP countries. The Brussels Briefing, on the first day of the seminar, set the tone by looking at the issue from the perspective of both journalists and policy-makers/stakeholders. It examined possible roles for the media in development, and considered how they could be used to cope with rural constraints – looking at what is required from the media, the resources needed, and the constraints faced by the media in fulfilling these roles. ROMs will be produced containing the special TV programmes. All the seminar products are available from CTA’s Publication Distribution service. Electronic versions of the documents, as well as the presentations that have been sent to CTA, are available on the seminar website at http://annualseminar2009. cta.int. PDF copies of the texts can be downloaded from CTA’s virtual library, Anancy. 1.2 The seminar in figures To encourage the ACP media to give more coverage to issues relating to ARD in ACP countries, and to encourage decision-makers in supporting agricultural development, CTA organised a contest to honour professional journalists and community media. During the seminar, exchanges and discussions culminated in conclusions and recommendations on strategies that will be implemented to strengthen the role of the media in ARD in ACP countries. Some of these can be found in the Executive Summary (page 11). These messages have also been set out in a Brussels Declaration (page 20). Concerted implementation of these strategies by the actors as well as the national, regional and international institutions will enable the media to play their role in ACP ARD. This summary document is one of a series compiled to present the richness of the discussions during the week in Brussels, as well as the resulting conclusions and recommendations. A more comprehensive, stand-alone version of the Executive Summary (page 11) will be published. Additionally, two CD- Should you wish to continue the debate or take part in the Media4Dev community, send an email to us at cta@cta.int. Participants by gender women 38% men 62% Participants by region 10 % Caribbean 20% West Africa 3 % Central Africa 13 % East Africa 12 % Southern Africa 6 % Pacific 6 % International 30 % Europe 9 Participants by type of organization 2% West Africa 1 % Bilateral Donors 10 % Development Projects 17% Research Organisations 3 % Farmers' Associations 6 % International Organisations 8% Regional Organisations 9 % NGOs 1% Governemental Organisations 1% Network Associations 3 % Private Sector 39% Combined Media 19 posters 40 oral Number of oral and posters presentations Illiterate or poorly-educated population Inappropriate information packaging or no communication strategies Contraints Faced by the Media 2.7 % 4.1 % 5.0 % Few or limited media facilities available Transportation problem 5.4 % Lack of leaders or political support 5.4 % Other constraints 7.2 % Problems between media and sources 7.7 % Difficulties to collect or get up-to-date information 10 8.6 % Lack of free and trustworthy information 10.4 % Lack of interest from editors and journalists 11.3 % Lack of funding for research, collecting, getting or sharing information 14.9 % 17.6 % Difficulties to understand the information and non-qualified journalists 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10 % 12 % 14 % 16 % 18 % 20 % II – EVENTS 2.1 executive summary: why do the media matter? I n ACP countries, there is a wide range of public, private and community media organisations whose print journalists, television, video and radio broadcasters – as well as communicators using both traditional means such as music or drama, and new digital, wireless technologies – constitute an important but disparate set of actors. These organisations can facilitate awareness, learning and action to address the major agricultural and rural development (ARD) challenges of the 21st century, including food security and climate change. Without this wide range of media, key policy commitments to the agricultural sector may be unaccounted for, knowledge may remain undocumented or not widely shared, and information may remain in the hands of the few. Therefore the media can be a strategic link in the chain of information dissemination and communication that brings many stakeholders together in the process of agricultural innovation. access information. However, the current media coverage does not guarantee the relevance, quality and quantity of information they need. The media face many constraints, including lack of skills and specialisation, poor remuneration, lack of equipment and transport, and limited or no affordable access to the internet and reliable information networks. The goal of strengthening the role of the media in ARD addresses these constraints and aims to build new, improved communication with knowledge partners such as farmers, extension workers, agribusinesses and scientists. An “essential service” in the development of ACP, the media can play a key role. They must assume responsibility to enable interaction with resource-poor farmers and rural communities, who face vast challenges in food production, nutrition and adaptation to climate change. THE 2009 CTA SEMINAR – RESPONDING TO THE CALL MEDIA – AN “ESSENTIAL SERVICE” Even though it is acknowledged in ACP nations that an adequate flow of information is an indispensable element in the achievement of basic needs, functioning of markets and the implementation of agricultural policies and programmes, media treatment of crucial issues such as food security, post-harvest technology and water management often tends to be insufficient. Millions of people in ACP nations rely on their local radio stations, mobile phones and cyber-cafés to OF ACP PARTNERS The focus on the role of the media in this year’s seminar emerged from calls from the ACP regions during events such as the Caribbean Week of Agriculture, and a West African study visit with journalists on problems associated with the livestock trade. The 2009 seminar also received input from many collaborating institutions; the international steering committee responsible for advising on the themes of the seminar included representatives from media organisations in the ACP region, Europe and North America. The seminar’s agenda addressed several current challenges, including the emergence of community media alongside public and private sector media; the growing need for capacity-building to enable the media to engage in ARD issues, including climate change and gender equality; and the rapid development and use of digital media in the ARD sectors. OBJECTIVES The objectives of the seminar were: • t o contribute to the formulation of strategies to improve the media’s ability to access and disseminate information on the core issues affecting the ACP agricultural sector and strengthen communication with and within the media; • t o contribute to identifying programmes to support the media. PARTICIPANTS The seminar brought together over 170 participants, representing experts and major players in the media and ARD. They included a range of journalists from media institutions such as newspapers and magazines, radio, television and webcasters. They were joined by agricultural researchers, representatives of a range of development media organisations, communication specialists working in public service and development projects, policy-makers from the six ACP regions (Central, Eastern, Southern and West Africa, the Caribbean and the Pacific), as well as representatives from national research and development institutions in EU countries and regional and international organisations. 11 PROCESS The call for proposals attracted over 225 abstract submissions. In total, 57 presentations were selected and organised into 10 thematic plenary and parallel panel sessions as well as interactive poster sessions. THEMES AND SESSION TOPICS 1. Media and ARD issues 2. Media and agricultural extension and learning 3. Media and climate change 4. Media and gender equality 5. Media funding in ard 6. Media in arid and semi-arid zones 7. C  ommunication between media and other ard players 8. C  ontribution of the media to agricultural policy, programming and knowledge management 9. I nstitutional environment of media: building the capacity of media in ard 10. Media, emerging new media service and icts Various activities were undertaken to gather the opinions and views of a wide range of international actors. These activities included an e-discussion comprising more than 2,000 participants, and a preseminar blog which was replaced by the live blog during the seminar. Regular and rapid additions to the seminar’s website were also produced synchronously. Once the seminar was under way, an exciting set of activities unfolded. On the first day, seminar participants had the unique experience of joining EU-ACP delegates 12 Presentation during the session on Media and Climate Change at the European Commission for a “Brussels Briefing” on the topic of the seminar as well as plenary and panel discussions (see page 13). Specific action-oriented working groups contributed detailed action items specific to the thematic areas as well as radio, television and video, print and community media (page 43). On the final day of the seminar, the Brussels Declaration was drafted to summarise recommendations from the online activities, seminar presentations and deliberations throughout the week (page 20). BEYOND 2009 – TOWARDS A STRONGER ROLE FOR THE MEDIA IN ARD In light of the many discussions and recommendations generated through the seminar process, CTA will ensure the following recommendations are put into practice as part of the newly-created media programme. •B  y September 2010, develop a media capacity-strengthening strategy that takes into account suggestions from the proposed list of actions, as well as regional variations on issues that are essential for agricultural development in ACP countries. •W  ithin the next strategic plan, collaborate with national and international institutions to involve the media more closely in the ACP development policy process and ARD programming, and respond to action items regarding annual conferences, small grants, awards and recognition efforts. •D  evelop guidelines for media roles, responsibilities and relations with national and international research, education and extension agencies. •U  se all its existing programmes to increase awareness among funding agencies about the support needed to act on suggested action plans for radio, television/ video/film and community media in the agricultural and rural sectors of ACP. •D  irect increased support to community media in ARD. •A  s far as possible, ensure gender equality in capacity-building. •P  romote information exchange throughout non-ARD media networks on successful practices and experiences in dealing with key ACP agricultural and rural issues, including climate change and food security. 2.2 Brussels Briefing on the media T he 14th Brussels Development Briefing on Media and Development, held on 12 October 2009, discussed key issues regarding the role media can play in raising awareness in ACP and EU member states, and in building public support for EU development policy. The participants agreed that efforts need to be made by the various actors to feature success stories on agriculture and rural development, not just bad news. If we want to boost productivity in order to respond to people’s needs in terms of food, employment and income in a sustainable and environmental way, there is a need for agriculture to be more visible in the media. But this cannot happen without increased investment in agriculture, and in information and communication infrastructure. All participants agreed that the media are essential partners in the ARD sector, and that they face real constraints: poor infrastructure, lack of equipment, low salaries, and lack of education and specialisation in agriculture leading to a poor understanding of development issues. There is a mismatch between the expectations of media and the development community – for the media, agriculture is not usually seen as newsworthy, whereas development partners do not trust the media to report accurately and objectively. While the use of information and communication technologies (ICTs) varies across ACP regions, they provide channels and means to enhance the role of media. We need to share good practice, including from other sectors such as health and education, and move away from traditional models to disseminate information and allow interactive learning across actors linked in broad networks. National ACP governments and the international community should engage in supporting the media. research skills and to collaborate with scientists. As Violet Otindo, the KBC–CNN award-winner, points out, scientists could win an award for teaming up with journalists and making agricultural stories more exciting and positive. Training in new technologies and strengthening of professional associations, especially for young female journalists, who may lack networks, are essential. More young journalists who champion ARD issues in our societies should receive recognition through awards, training and other forms of support. The good news is that “homegrown” local media specialists are increasing in number. Local media can satisfy local demand, in local languages, for news, information, action and possible influence on national development, through networking with other media beyond the local level. Some types of media can create and share power with rural communities, such as community radio; participatory video, which can also be linked to television and film documentaries; telecentres that function as community resource centres; and a press that shares many different rural voices/languages and reports on issues of importance to rural communities. We already see future developments in mobile phones and web 2.0 applications that allow rural citizens’ journalism and podcasts by rural communities of their own stories via rural radio. Participants at the Brussels Briefing Online interview with CTA Director Web-casting 13 Journalists lack specialised training to respond to issues related to agriculture and rural development, and they need to develop better Press Conference following the Brussels Briefing (L-R) Stephen Hazelman, SPC; Dr Wilson A Songa, CTA Chairman; Ian Barber, European Commission. 2.3 Coming of age CTA’s 25th Anniversary Ceremony CTA celebrated 25 years of service to the 79 ACP states at a special ceremony on 14 October 2009, at the Palais des Colonies in Tervuren, Belgium. The evening ceremony was one of the highlights of the CTA seminar on “The Role of Media in the Agricultural and Rural Development of ACP Countries” held during what was dubbed, ‘CTA Week in Brussels’. A highpoint of the evening was, without doubt, the announcement of the winners of CTA’s first ever Best Journalism and Best Community Communication Awards for journalists who have contributed to ARD in ACP countries (see page 70). In addition to the 170 participants at the seminar, representatives of Brussels-based ACP and EU embassies, as well as representatives from international organisations and development partners, attended the event. HE Mrs Marcia Yvette GilbertRoberts, Ambassador of Jamaica, performed the duties of master of ceremonies for the evening, presiding over presentations from representatives of CTA’s governing authorities and international partners, who spoke of some of the key development issues shaping the current global and regional climate, and how they perceived CTA’s interventions in this context. In his presentation on behalf of the CTA Executive Board, Dr Wilson Songa, Chairman of the Board, congratulated the Centre on the dedication of its staff, “from the high level of activity, sometimes we have the impression that CTA employs well over 100 staff, when in reality the staff complement is just over 40”. However, as dedicated as the staff may be, as demanded as the Centre’s services were by its ACP members, and despite the Centre’s recent restructuring, Dr Songa pointed out that given the context in which the Centre worked, it desperately needed more funds if it wanted to remain relevant and have more impact over the next 25 years. CTA’s Director, Dr Hansjörg Neun, in his vote of thanks at the end of the evening, took the opportunity to congratulate the organisation on its achievements. III – MEDIA 3.1 Media coverage I 2,300 persons subscribed to the discussion, the results of which were presented during the seminar (page 19). For the past few years, CTA has relied on pre-seminar electronic discussions (e-discussions) to gather ideas and opinions that help shape the seminar’s theme. These e-discussions also allow more people, especially those who are not able to attend the seminar, to contribute their views to the discussions. This year over Whereas the e-discussion is targeted at professionals in the field, the pre-seminar blog, introduced this year, aimed to obtain first-hand, grassroots opinions from a wide range of participants on a number of topics, including capacity-building, use of new media, and first-hand views and opinions on the seminar’s themes (page 17). While it was also possible for participants to communicate with the blog using SMS, this feature was not as success- t seems appropriate that a seminar about the media should take advantage of all relevant media to communicate with its various audiences. A range of traditional and new media were used before, during and following the seminar. 14 ful, possibly because most users reading the blog online could submit comments directly online (for free), and also because the brevity of SMS may not have matched the type of discussion. The seminar website hosted material pertinent to the seminar’s organisation, themes and the preseminar blog. When the seminar began, the pre-seminar blog was converted to a live blog. Web 2.0 tools featured prominently. The tag “Media4Dev” was entered on Delicious, and a Twitter account was opened. A community was established on LinkedIn, and a Flickr account was set up for the seminar to facilitate the sharing of photos and videos. Once the seminar got under way, the blogs, tweets, photos and videos flowed in. A live webcast on day 1 of the seminar, of the Brussels Briefing, allowed viewers from all over the world to have a first-hand look at the seminar and even to post questions online. Over 100 media houses and organisations signed up for the broadcasts, and almost 200 users looked at the Briefing online. In addition to the online tools, CTA once again collaborated with People TV to produce a special TV programme on the theme of the seminar. The programme featured a panel discussion and highlighted video shorts from Africa (Kenya, Mali, Senegal and Zambia), the Pacific (Kiribati) and the Caribbean (Trinidad and Tobago). All the sessions were taped, and a DVD documenting the seminar will also be available. and English, are also available on the seminar website (http://annualseminar2009.cta.int). Radio is still king in many ACP countries. Special radio broadcasts were made of the TV programme, and participants were eager to assist with live interviews throughout the week. Radio also featured strongly during the two press conferences held during the seminar, on the first and last days. While some debate that the future of print media is uncertain, in ACP print media are still strong, and Daily Digests summarising each day’s proceedings were produced from Tuesday to Friday. PDF copies of the digests, produced in French 3.2 TV programme on media and agriculture in ACP countries A s part of the communication strategy used in organising the annual seminar, CTA and its partners produced a television programme on ‘Media and Agriculture in ACP Countries’. The objective of this special programme was to increase the impact of the seminar and share it with everyone involved in ARD in ACP countries (political leaders, media, rural communities and the general public), and to heighten awareness of the role the media can play in agricultural development in ACP countries. Five overall themes were selected: •m  edia and trade in agricultural products; • • • • m  edia and gender; media and climate change; m  edia and capacity-building; h  ow the media cover agriculture. Projects from the ACP region were selected for inclusion in feature reports, produced in French and in English, and were presented in Brussels as part of the TV programme. • I n the Caribbean, a national daily and a rural radio station were visited to provide examples of how the media (under)focus on the agricultural sector. • I n 2008, CTA organised a study trip that took about a dozen journalists from several coun- tries in West Africa along the Dakar-to-Bamako route. At the border they had to cope with the administrative headaches that seriously disturb trade in agricultural commodities in the sub-region. Press articles on this subject prompted some governments to react. • I n a region of West Kenya rife with AIDS, rural communities with support from the NGO Kenya Aids Intervention Prevention Project Group (KAIPPG), have created their own media. They record agricultural techniques and dietary advice on cassettes and videos, which are then passed from village to village. 15 Taping of TV programme Dr Hansjörg Neun, director of CTA and Oumarou Barry, presenter from People TV, stayed on scene during the live taping in Brussels. Various specialists were invited onto the set, depending on the subject: •A  bdoulaye Barry, journalist at RTS / Senegal • I n the Pacific, international media coverage of events in Kiribati largely contributed to stirring up international support on climate change issues. • I n Zambia, the International Women’s Media Foundation offers women journalists training sessions that include an introduction to agricultural problems and methods for treating agricultural news. These sessions have affected the way the media cover agriculture, for example, the Times of Zambia has started a weekly column on agriculture. Experts and journalists were invited to add information, and seminar participants were invited to attend the discussions. •B  l o n d e a u Ta l a t a l a , d e p u ty, National Assembly / Cameroon •B  usani Bafana, freelance journalist / Zimbabwe •C  ece Fadope, Africa programme manager, International Women’s Media Foundation / USA •D  iana Francis, expert in agricultural policy and trade negotiations, IICA / Trinidad •D  orienne Rowan-Campbell, organic farmer / Jamaica •F  atouma Sophie Ouattara, journalist at Sidwaya, a daily newspaper / Burkina Faso •O  biero Ong’ang’a, director of Lake Victoria Center for Research and Development / Kenya •N  azima Raghubir, journalist / Guyana •S  amisoni Pareti, freelance journalist / Fiji. The programme was scheduled to be broadcast in November 2009, in two 30-minute segments, by about 40 television channels that are partners of the People TV audio-visual production company, as well as in the Caribbean and the Pacific. To broaden the outreach, it will also be recorded on cassette for broadcasting by community radio stations and will be distributed via CTA’s website, www.cta. int. CTA will give a DVD of the TV programme to seminar participants and partner organisations upon request. • J ames Onyango, director of KAIPPG / Kenya •L  arry Thomas, co-ordinator, Media Centre, Secretariat of the Pacific Community (SPC) / Fiji 3.3 Live blogging aggregates content at CTA seminar L 16 ive blogging, carried out by a four-person francophone and anglophone team, complemented the overall media mix used during the seminar. The live blogging aggregated content documented in text, audio, pictures and video. The seminar blog was spiced by tweets, initially from the new media team members and later from participants and others who joined in tweeting the conference. The live blogging allowed people who were not at the seminar to comment on articles posted on the seminar blog. The content that was blogged was also picked up by other users. This resulted in richer information and content, which was further integrated and shared by yet more bloggers. “Tweeting at the CTA seminar was a great experience for me because I was very well informed about what was taking place … and I got to know what other participants were thinking too. In other words, there was a lot of information sharing, networking and advocacy on agriculture-sensitive media policies”, said Maureen, Agena a participant and tweeter at the conference. Using live blogging, the new media team was also able to integrate content from multiple platforms, including YouTube, Twitter, Blogspace and Flickr, to one platform: http://annualseminar2009.cta. int/blog. The team also integrated audio and text on the same blog platform. This involved stakeholders in sharing and disseminating information for knowledge-sharing applications for the agricultural community. The seminar blog content was also aggregated through the use of Ping.fm, which the team used to send content to other social networking sites, including Facebook, Yahoo! Mail, Google Mail, Flickr, Twitter and other social networking sites. A valuable output for both bloggers and organisers was seeing how geographically dispersed journalists can work together and be sensitised, evidenced by the way they contributed their comments to the blog and to Twitter and Facebook. The success of the live blogging may be seen in the continuation of community participation even after the conference had ended. Live blogging in figures Microblogging – more than 700 tweets Blog entries in the form of videos and short stories – 80 Photos documented – over 200 Comments to the blog (not including those made on other social networking sites such as Facebook) – 51 To be fully effective, live blogging depends on several conditions, including the existence of a dedicated wireless service in the conference area. Failing this, the bloggers can blog and tweet offline and then blog online when back on the internet. For maximum effectiveness, bloggers also need to use a laptop capable of capturing signals in a wide variety of environments. To provide more advanced services, the blog team also needs to have access to voice recorders with MP3 format, video cameras and mobile camera phones. While not essential, extra tapes and batteries allow for greater flexibility and efficiency. IV – Outputs Prior to the international seminar on The Role of Media in the Agricultural and Rural Development of ACP Countries (Brussels, 12–16 October 2009), CTA organised a pre-seminar blog and an e-discussion to allow experts from across the ACP region to share their opinions and experiences on the topic. log See b les artic ge 75 on pa 4.1 summary – pre-seminar blog Moderators: Marilyn Minderhout, Ibbo Daddy Abdoulaye The objective of the blog was to support development of the CTA 2009 seminar and to give ACP media practitioners the opportunity to exchange and share experiences. The majority of those who contributed to the blog were journalists, many of whom either had been or still were working on rural development issues. There were also several contributions from members of media networks and associations. The blog ran for almost 12 weeks, and was structured around selected themes. These had been identified in an introductory article and were further elaborated in the short articles posted each week. These articles provided a context and starting point for discussion, and prompted contributions that provided a startling commentary on the relationship between the media and rural development in ACP countries. The majority of the contributions came from Africa, but similar concerns were expressed 17 by bloggers from the Caribbean and Pacific. Blog contributors reflected on the institutional setting in which they – as journalists – work. The political context has a decisive impact on press freedom. More generally, even within democratic regimes, a certain level of fear and distrust of the media hinders factual and well informed reporting. Civil servants – mindful of their careers and the consequences of incurring the disapproval of their superiors – can block access to information. The inefficiency of government offices was also mentioned: materials not archived, statistics not kept and endless delays in retrieving information so, when it does become available, its relevance is often questionable. However, when government officials or researchers have something to report in their own interest, “they [know] how to shout”; otherwise, they are “allergic to the press”, as one blogger put it. The political culture, and the financial and corporate interest that support it, were seen as having an equally serious impact on the capacity of journalists and editors to choose stories that promote a more “public journalism” and that might benefit rural development. Several contributors supported the observation from the Pacific that the rapid privatisation and corporatisation of the media had created a culture in which “profit [has] overtaken the public good as the main motive of the news media”. 18 This type of environment did not encourage the transmission of information needed by farmers – especially small-scale farmers. One contributor, who had tried to find out from farmers why the media had not contributed more to development, was told: “Politicians have money, farmers don’t. They don’t want the country to know what’s going on here. They only come to the rural areas during election time to hand out presents!” Farm communities were prepared to put money and time aside for the media when “they saw that journalists were representing their issues and concerns”. But bridging the gap between a potential rural readership and gaining access to information that could have a positive impact on agricultural production and rural livelihoods is complex. Some contributors suggested that further professionalisation, training, specialisation and improved salaries could help overcome this problem. Others emphasised the need for legislation to facilitate the development of new technologies capable of bridging the urban–rural divide. While the constraints facing practising journalists – including low pay and limited budgets – discourage investigative rural journalism – it was seen to be important to remember that the media do have the potential to stimulate ARD. There was a general consensus that, in the absence of adequate state or private radio coverage of agricultural issues, community radio stations provide an important source of support for rural households. Here, the organisers are also the listeners, and community radio stations not only provide livelihood information, they also bring the concerns of rural communities into the public domain. In this way they stimulate the exchange of experience and knowledge between communities as well as providing journalists with useful materials. In addition, as a blogger from Nigeria suggested, community radio – if well co-ordinated – could be interwoven into a rural media network that could support agricultural extension – support much needed in areas where “extensionists are poorly trained, poorly paid and often reluctant to work in the rural areas”. Financial sustainability was identified as a serious problem for many rural media initiatives. But from the blog, it appeared that there are positive experiences of community radio stations that have developed a steady commercial base for themselves – sometimes with the support of local people – or have achieved stability by linking with a wide range of partner organisations. The community radio theme led into a discussion of the impact of new technologies on ARD. Here several contributors stressed the importance of first discussing with local communities the technologies available and their need, relevance and capacity to use and maintain these tools effectively. Strategies sensitive to the specific conditions within individual countries are needed. New technologies do not generate development, but the messages they carry can have an impact on development policies. Journalists in the mainstream media need access to supportive information and they must have sufficient skill, experience and determination to provide well documented, issue-based coverage of rural affairs. Journalists, broadcasters and webmasters can play a significant part in transforming their sector into an “inclusive media” – a media that draws all sections of society into the development process. 4.2 summary – e-discussion Moderators: Susanna Thorp and Laurence Lalanne-Devlin Over 2,000 people were invited to take part in the e-discussion, including journalists, communication specialists, researchers, librarians, regional organisations and rural development agencies. The four-week discussion was held simultaneously in English and French, and was broken into four themes: • constraints faced by the media; • expectations between the media and other development stakeholders; • the potential role of ICTs; • funding for capacity strengthening. This summary report gives a brief overview of some of the main points and recommendations arising from the discussion to provide a foundation for further discussion and action at the seminar. Media advocating for change in West Africa Constraints Expectations It was unanimously agreed that the media are essential in agricultural development – but concerns were expressed over the multiple constraints that limit the media from realising their full potential in this role. The reality is that the media, particularly in Africa, are faced with the challenges of poor infrastructure, low salaries, lack of equipment, a lack of specialisation (and training for agriculture) and therefore a poor understanding of development issues. Specific constraints with regard to the themes discussed in week one (including climate, marketing and extension) were that journalists lack timely and regionally appropriate data to communicate to their audiences. Different expectations exist between the media and other development partners (such as researchers and policy-makers). Media houses do not see agriculture as newsworthy, and find it difficult to interpret scientific jargon for their audiences. There is often a mistrust of the media among researchers and others, who may wish to have their stories published or broadcast without cost, and lack the skills to package the information in the right way. Key recommendation. To provide greater capacity-strengthening to the media. Key recommendation. More efforts are needed to bridge the gap between the media and development partners if agriculture is to have a higher profile among target audiences. Role of ICTs While ICTs and new media tools provide new channels and means to enhance the role of the media, it was acknowledged that ICTs are not a panacea. Key recommendations. Recognising the potential for ICTs needs to include learning from other sectors and sharing good practice. A more sophisticated model is required, of interactive and iterative learning across actors linked in broad networks, rather than the traditional, linear model for disseminating information. Funding With agriculture now back on the agenda for development support, it was felt that funding for agricultural communication initiatives has not followed suit, and greater efforts are required at national and international levels to support the media in agricultural development. Key recommendation. Agricultural communication for development must become a key priority for investment – and donor and national efforts should be better co-ordinated. 19 20 4.3 Brussels Declaration 21 V – Abstracts Media and ARD issues VIDEO IN DEVELOPMENT – FILMING FOR RURAL CHANGE (CTA BOOK LAUNCH) Dr Rico Lie and Mr Andreas Mandler, University of Wageningen, the Netherlands This new CTA publication is about using video in rural interventions for social change. It offers a glimpse into the many creative ways in which video can be used in rural development activities. Capitalising on experience in this field, the book aims to encourage development professionals to explore the potential of video in development, making it a more coherent, better understood and properly used development tool – in short, filming for rural change. Video has been used in development for more than 30 years, but only with the advent of digital video has filming and editing equipment become affordable and easier to use. Despite the consequent increase in the use of video in development activities, however, there is very little information available on the practical aspects of using video, from building it into development strategies to preparation, filming, distribution and screening. Recent trends show a heavy emphasis on participatory video, particularly in terms of farmer participation, with comparatively little attention being paid to educational or learning videos. There is very little literature, for example, on how to integrate adult learning with video, or how to stimulate farmer experimentation. 22 There is confusion, for example, about the degree of professionalism needed to design, produce and use video in development activities. Which professionals should be involved? Are different kinds of professionals needed – professional film-makers, professionals with facilitation or management skills, communication professionals, people with particular technical skills? There is also confusion about the terms “participation” and “participatory video”. Participation is a key concept, but we need to be more specific about the kinds of participation that are practical in making videos for development and the stages at which participation should be sought (e.g. script-writing, design, filming, reviewing). SOURCING INFORMATION ON ARD BY THE PACIFIC MEDIA Ms Viola Ulakai, Tonga Broadcasting and Television Corporation, Tonga Sourcing information in the Pacific for agriculture and rural development is not easy. This paper explores the challenges journalists have identified when trying to provide coverage on these topics, and presents the different views of journalists in the region who have shared their experiences with regard to sourcing information. In a recent ADVOC online survey, overwhelming reasons focused on the lack of capacity-building programmes, and the need for stakeholders to treat the media as peers, partners and trusted colleagues who can and will disseminate information accurately, without bias and in the simplest English or in the vernacular language. It also pointed to the need for resource-sharing when sourcing information, particularly when either party is unable to reach a remote or isolated area. Other challenges identified include the need for scientific sources to work with journalists on simplifying information, creating awareness on the importance of agriculture and rural development among journalists in the region and creating understanding of the media in the agriculture sector. The presentation provides scenarios in which these challenges are experienced and what can be done to address them. It highlights proposed programmes to make sourcing information simpler for journalists and sources. Lastly, it presents a set of recommendations to help CTA address sourcing of information on agriculture and rural development in the region by the media. THE VOICE OF THE VISUAL – VISUAL LEARNING STRATEGIES FOR PROBLEM ANALYSIS, SOCIAL DIALOGUE AND MEDIATED PARTICIPATION DEVELOPING A LOVE AFFAIR BETWEEN RURAL AGRICULTURE AND THE MEDIA Dr Loes Witteveen, IRDT, Wageningen University, Netherlands In the Caribbean island state of Trinidad (Trinidad and Tobago), media involvement is a moneymaking business. Rural farmers, mostly middle-aged men and women, know they must present agriculturists and agriculture more attractively if the media are to be prodded to invest in pushing a love affair between food producers and consumers. Some farmers, interviewed in their rural districts, expressed the need for government and other stakeholders to help enhance farmers’ image and role in society. Ideal for this task, they said, would be a media production company dedicated solely to coverage of agriculture, frequently presenting to the public a new image of rural farming and farmers. Such presentations could also attract rural youth, who often reject agriculture for higherpaying, less back-breaking jobs. A media production company could also be the national hub in an information web of rural community networks. Through engaging, quality programming, rural farmers would expect to attract the attention of government and other stakeholders whose intervention could bring resolution to issues such as land tenure; land allocation; ready and equitable access to land preparation equipment; clearing of clogged waterways and general water management; construction of access roads; and responsible supervision of agrochemical use. A dedicated production company with adequate financial support, and with the collaboration of educational institutions and other national and global agricultural organisations, could extend beyond the island nation of Trinidad and Tobago to stoke up a love affair between rural farmers and the media throughout the Caribbean. The changing need for innovative learning strategies in the life sciences results from the growing complexity of societal issues. Nowadays, these types of complex issues are sometimes called “wicked problems”. Wicked problems are complex problems that do not have one single solution that is right or wrong, good or bad, as they relate to social systems and values. They are problems in which many stakeholders are involved, all of them framing the problems and issues in a different way. Reflecting on the consequent changing role of scientists, it is realised that we need learning strategies to enhance problem analysis and intersubjective consensus. This paper reports on a research and design project on visual learning strategies for problem analysis and policy design, focusing on dialogue and participation by social actors, (future) practitioners and decision-makers. The design track resulted in the development of visual problem appraisal and embedded filming. These methodologies were used in productions regarding “Integrated Coastal Zone Management in Kerala, India” and “AIDS and Rural Development Professionalism in sub-Saharan Africa”. The films have been used in an array of situations and with a variety of audiences. They have shown the ability to bring complex realities and a diversity of stakeholders together in spaces of learning, reflection and change. The research results indicate the relevance of designing and producing specific visual learning strategies in the context of wicked problems in rural development, where using film provides options to enhance mediated participation and learning by vulnerable and overlooked stakeholders. Dr Eugenia Springer, Eugenia Springer Productions, Trinidad MEDIA TREATMENT OF AGRICULTURAL AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT ISSUES: CHALLENGES AND PROBLEMS Ms. Anne Matho Motsou, Jade, Cameroon Abstract: The media have to face the following challenges in dealing with problems of agricultural and rural development: -c  ontribute to improving living conditions in rural areas by disseminating information that can help the rural population increase agricultural and animal production. The media, therefore, must leave room for veterinarians, agronomists, etc. to share their expertise on the various problems that farmers encounter in their crop and stock production. Since African farmers are poor, journalists have to propagate effective, low cost techniques and practices. Farmers would be pleased to learn, by reading the newspaper, that feeding papaya seeds to chickens helps control worm attacks; -d  isseminate neighbourhood news. The journalist has to go out into the field regularly to talk with rural development people, i.e. village associations, NGOs, CIGs to identify topical subjects and report on them. The challenge is to provide information that reflects the reality in the field. The media have to face two types of problems: - insufficient financial resources to travel to areas far from their head offices; the result is that they constantly cover the same zones; -m  anipulation of journalists by certain rural development people, e.g. project managers who exaggerate the repercussions of their projects, or local populations who do not speak the truth. 23 SIM-INFO ANOPACI Mr Sylvain Kouao, ANOPACI, Côte d’Ivoire 24 The Ivorian agricultural sector is increasingly divided between industrial agriculture and subsistence agriculture, the latter being characterised by limited potential profit. During the past decade, the media have undergone considerable change, and there are still obstacles to be overcome. The media have an enormous impact on the agricultural environment, which is so locked up that the media are the only link between the rural world and the outside world. In Côte d’Ivoire, the media portray a negative image of agriculture. The small number and limited diversity of publications and broadcasts, the choice of subjects and the journalistic form adopted reflect a certain superficiality in the manner in which the media handle themes related to ARD. We see a current crisis in the way the media deal with questions regarding ARD. At present, there are very few journalists who are capable of making a relevant analysis and matching it against the truth in the field, to help people working in rural development take the right decisions. In most of our countries, because agricultural development issues are dealt with by international institutions, the treatment is biased and does not contribute to increasing rural productivity or improving rural living conditions. In the Ivorian media, the question of rural development is especially badly off. Newspapers feel that the subject is not very appealing to its readers, and give it lowest priority in national news coverage, as can be seen by the very small number of special features on agriculture. The other aspect of the way in which rural development issues are treated concerns information from the rural areas directed to the decision-makers and other citizens. If information from the rural areas was well handled, it could have disrupted social links and led to a new type of solidarity. It takes vision to decide to invest in development-oriented agricultural information. Development actions that involve the media sometimes lose sight of the human dimension of the process. An integrated approach, focused on improving services offered by the media and targeting ARD, should enable rural populations to build up the collective resources needed to improve their living conditions. The way agricultural development issues are treated is often too abstract and theoretical to fit in with this vision. Thanks to its partnership with CTA through the market information system (SIM) project, ANOPACI has helped more than 25 rural radio stations produce agricultural programmes devoted to information that responds to the needs of rural populations. Farmers can understand the radio broadcasts and newspaper articles as everyday language is used, and the approach is based on the everyday experiences of the target readers and listeners. Agricultural development, according to farmers, should be covered in a way that reflects their real experiences in their own environment, as well as their mind set and knowledge system. These are the conditions in which information can become meaningful to the farmers because it can be integrated in their daily activities and decisions. ANOPACI now uses television and video in its treatment of development issues. Eyes have no barriers. The food riots have brought out the challenges and shown that information is not always properly treated. Work and thought need to be devoted to the whole issue of development, to make this information available as required. MEDIA IN AGRICULTURE – WE ARE NOT SECOND BEST Mr Phil Malone, Countrywise Communications, UK After working in producing training materials in ACP countries for more than 24 years, we feel we must celebrate the talent that exists in agricultural communication, and encourage high-quality, low-cost production of useful information and training materials. Digital video cameras are now a f f o r d a b l e e ve n i n t h e m o s t remote areas, but there needs to be investment in training to help media professionals and agricultural development staff produce interesting material to improve incomes for time-poor farmers. There is a movement towards ensuring such material can be used in many different ways – the soundtrack on local radio; video on local and national TV; and DVDs distributed to farmers to help overcome particular problems. We show examples of videos to boost rice production, produced in Africa and Bangladesh by local teams and translated into many local languages. Planning and preparation make the final productions easy to follow, and they feature real farmers offering their advice. The challenge for the future is to involve those who want to invest in rural areas – mobile phone companies, banks, NGOs and international agencies – to use these means of communication so that skill levels can be improved in rural areas. The final products will be in demand by end-users if they know they are available, and progress will be made as the process of looking over the fence is speeded up. We need to use appropriate technology so that farmer champions can inspire others and prove that media in agriculture is not second best. THE USE OF MULTI-MEDIA TO PROMOTE AGRICULTURE AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT – “CABI’S SECRET SERVICE” Ms Janny Vos, CABI, UK With over 90 years’ experience of working with different stakeholders, including researchers, extension workers, policy-makers, trainers, input suppliers, traders and farmers, CABI recognises the roles played by different media in effective communication. In many countries, CABI has been working “behind the scenes” of radio, video, TV and the web to promote sharing and dissemination of agricultural information and technologies. Print and electronic media are complementary, but their effectiveness varies with the audience and purpose. User preferences should guide the choice of media, which in turn influences uptake and impact. Radio and video are effective in farmer-to-farmer communication. Messages must be simple and the broadcast publicised in advance. Mixed media (posters, leaflets, handbooks, CDROM, radio and video) are useful in promoting research outputs and training, and creating awareness among different stakeholder groups about complex issues such as pest outbreaks. A communication plan spelling out who, what, when and how is essential for effective media use and evaluation. Communication strategies developed and tested by CABI in Africa include, for example, creating awareness about the impact, management and prevention of invasive plant species (Ethiopia, Ghana, Uganda, Zambia); and a knowledge-sharing framework for an awareness campaign on cassava brown streak disease (ECA region). Evidence of increased awareness was demonstrated in the target countries. With partners, CABI currently pilots a web-based mobile agricultural information system using SMS, e-mail and wireless technologies to promote information-sharing among users in remote areas. In all cases, the role of intermediary agencies in delivering the messages and ensuring sustainability is pivotal. Media and agricultural extension and learning THE FARMER’S VOICE / LA VOIX DU PAYSAN – AGRICULTURAL EXTENSION AND INFORMATION IN CAMEROON Ms Marie Pauline Voufo, presented by Aude Ehlinger, Cameroon “I became an agricultural businessman by reading your technical descriptions” – said André Marie, a faithful reader of the newspaper La Voix du Paysan, who we met in January 2008 while he was working in his oil palm fields not far from Edea in the coastal region of Cameroon. He is not the only one to speak that way about La Voix du Paysan, a monthly that has been published in Yaoundé, Cameroon for over 20 years. The newspaper organised a contest at the end of 2007 to measure its interest to farmers and its impact on them. Several hundred people partici- pated and gave very instructive testimony about their agro-pastoral achievements based on what they have read in this newspaper, which some of them see as “the mirror of the farmer”. It was through its very well prepared, mostly technical and practical columns that La Voix du Paysan conquered an audience of ambitious, established producers from around the country. A survey of readers held in December 2008 and January 2009 confirmed readers’ preference for the technical profiles (fiche technique). These profiles focus on lessons in cropping and pastoral techniques. They are designed to spread practical, up-to-date information on agropastoral crops currently grown in Cameroon. In the future, more information will also be included on processing agricultural products and on marketing circuits. ROLE OF THE MEDIA IN BRIDGING THE DISTANCE BETWEEN LAB AND FARM Mr Sunil Kumar Singh, University of the South Pacific, Fiji Media such as radio, television, videos, newspapers and magazines can play an important role in disseminating findings from agricultural research to farmers. In Fiji, there are 11 radio stations broadcasting in three different languages (English, Fijian and Hindustani), five newspapers published in three languages, and two free-to-air television companies telecasting the majority of their programmes in English. Most farmers in Fiji have regular access to radio, television and newspapers; however, currently there are very few programmes dedicated to educating or informing farmers about pest management, use of technology and good agricultural 25 practices. The findings from scientific research are often targeted at academic journals, which farmers hardly have access to – and even with access, the presentation of findings is too technical for them to understand and apply. The knowledge gap between farmers and agricultural researchers can be bridged by journalists, who act as an important link between them. Agricultural researchers need to provide journalists with interpretations of their findings that are of value to farmers, so that wider dissemination can take place and more people can benefit. In this presentation, a short video illustrates how research findings can be used to educate farmers with the help of media. FARM RADIO – A TRIGGER FOR DEMAND-DRIVEN EXTENSION SERVICES IN MALAWI Mr Rex Chapota, African Farm Radio Research Initiative, Farm Radio International, Malawi This paper examines how farm radio broadcasts have triggered demand for agricultural extension services in Malawi. Farm Radio International is implementing the Africa Farm Radio Research Initiative (AFRRI), a participatory, multi-stakeholder action research programme aiming at discovering, documenting and disseminating best practices for using radio-based communication to enhance food security in Malawi along with Ghana, Mali, Tanzania and Uganda. 26 As part of the implementation process, AFRRI is working in partnership with five radio stations, which include private, public and community stations. The Ministry of Agriculture and Food Security’s Department of Agricultural Extension Services is a collaborating partner for content generation and reflective practice at both national and community levels. Throughout the radio campaign period, the broadcasts have triggered demand for extension services to the extent that the community extension workers reported to have started reading more widely on agricultural technologies than in the past, as farmers are asking them questions based on the broadcasts. Farmers have also started sending requests through the chiefs for extension workers to go to specific communities and demonstrate what they have heard on radio. Farmers have become proactive, in line with the extension policy for a pluralistic, demand-driven extension service in Malawi. The radio producers have also involved extension workers to provide information during broadcasts, which has resulted in them being more accountable for their advice and activities on the ground. The broadcasts have also challenged the extension services for standardisation of agricultural information, as farmers compare what they hear on air with what other stakeholders have told them. KNOWLEDGE, NETWORKING AND DIVERSITY – OPPORTUNITIES FOR AGRICULTURAL JOURNALISM IN AFRICA Mr David Mowbray, BBC World Service Trust, UK That agriculture has been neglected in media coverage throughout Africa has been recognised, but until now has gone largely uninvestigated. The International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) commissioned the BBC World Service Trust to conduct a research study to understand the underlying causes of the paucity of media coverage. We present initial results of that study. INNOVATIVE APPROACHES FOR IMPROVING ACCESS TO AGRICULTURAL INFOR-MATION – CASES AND APPLICATIONS Dr O. I. Oladele, University of Botswana This paper examines innovative approaches for improving access to agricultural information. This is based on the premise that the dissemination of information has been responding to the changing social, economic, cultural, technological and political challenges in many countries, with agriculture as the mainstay of the economy. Among the approaches covered are determination of agricultural and non-agricultural information needs; journalists’ attitudes to agriculture and rural development news; gender targeting; multimedia communication strategies; enhancement of feedback provision; multi-ligualism of information sources; use of video and other information communication technologies to supplement faceto-face contact with extension agents; and partnership with information service providers. These approaches, based on the extension needs of clients and effective research–extension–farmer links leading to the evolution of agricultural innovations, have increased information access among agricultural stakeholders. This paper covers innovative approaches that have been applied in Nigeria, Botswana and other parts of the world, presented as case studies. The paper concludes with suggestions for application of these innovative approaches in other parts of the world. OBSTACLES TO THE USE OF MEDIA IN EXTENSION AND LEARNING IN THE RURAL SET-UP Mr Charles Oduor Ogada, Ugunja Community Resource Centre, Kenya Agriculture remains the major economic mainstay of the developing economies in Africa. In Kenya, 80% of the population are employed in the agriculture sector, the majority being the rural population (Kenya Ministry of Agriculture Strategic Plan, 2006–2010). Despite its importance, agricultural production has not recorded significant growth in the past 10 years. However, the agriculture sector remains vital in realising Africa’s potential and attaining the Millennium Development Goals, particu- larly that of eliminating extreme poverty and hunger by 2015. The agriculture sector has faced numerous challenges: bad governance, lack of access to information, inadequate extension, lack of markets and unreliable weather conditions. The media have been proven to be a powerful tool that is very effective in transforming the sector. The use of media is becoming more popular, and there are many successful case studies demonstrating how the media have helped to inform, mobilise and educate farmers. At Ugunja Community Resource Centre (UCRC), we have employed a mix of media tools including audio broadcasts, print media and traditional media to help disseminate and package farmers’ technologies in a friendlier way for storage and sharing. Although the use of media to promote agriculture extension and leaning has proven to be effective, it is not easy, and many obstacles hinder its full exploitation at the rural level. The most notable challenges include inadequate infrastructure, lack of content, communication policies and costs. UCRC strives to overcome these problems by creating “community learning resource centres” to help facilitate information sourcing and sharing at the rural levels, and to promote networking. changing climatic conditions, and farming practices that do not give back to the environment. In addition, government extension services are not adequately equipped to help farmers deal with these challenges. It is important that practical, expert and scientific information on sustainable practices reaches the farming community in a timely manner. THE ROLE OF MEDIA IN DISSEMINATING SUSTAINABLE FARMING PRACTICES TO SMALLSCALE FARMERS IN KENYA This paper describes the experiences of The Organic Farmer (TOF) magazine and radio programme in Kenya in building up partnership with farmers’ groups to improve access to information on sustainable farming practices, in order to boost farm income and food security. The paper suggests that media practices that allow farmer participation encourage more information-sharing between individual farmers and groups, while speeding uptake of appropriate technologies to boost production and environmental conservation. Mr John Cheburet, The Organic Farmer, Kenya Kenya is an agricultural country whose economic development depends on this sector, which employs over 70% of the population. However, Kenya is faced with dire food insecurity compared with its neighbours Tanzania and Uganda. This situation is caused by a number of factors, chief among them the high cost of inputs, Media and climate change MEDIA COVERAGE OF CLIMATE CHANGE IN THE SADC REGION: THE CASE OF MOZAMBIQUE, SWAZILAND AND ZAMBIA Mr Parkie Mbozi, PANOS Institute Southern Africa, Zambia Mass-mediated messages, when properly planned and systematically executed, contribute to shaping and affecting science and policy discourses as well as increasing public understanding and action. The public learns a large amount of science through consuming mass-mediated messages. Questions have, however, been asked about the effectiveness of the mass media in creating awareness of climate change. This prompted Panos Southern Africa to commission a study to investigate media coverage, community awareness and national responses to climate change and change adaptation. It aimed to examine how the media in southern Africa handle the issue of climate change, focusing on current trends, strengths and weaknesses in print and electronic media. The results show that the knowledge base of journalists in climate change and climate change adaptation is limited. Their attitudes towards featuring climate change in their media are not very supportive: the media (editors and journalists) do not consider climate change a sellable topic. There is neither specialisation on the subject, nor journalists specifically assigned to report on it. The media also indicated a lack of incentives and support to cover climate change issues. This leads to limited coverage of climate change issues in the media, yet the pub- lic relies on the media for both news and information. The public understanding of climate change and climate change adaptation is limited. The countries studied (Mozambique, Swaziland and Zambia) had yet to finalise policies and legislation that directly address climate change and climate change adaptation. There was also limited co-ordination on climate change issues in all three countries. CLIMATE CHANGE AND THE MEDIA IN THE PACIFIC Mr Samisoni Pareti, Islands Business International, Fiji This paper provides an insight into work currently being undertaken in the Pacific to progress media 27 outreach and media reporting of issues relating to climate change. It emphasises the unique position of climate change in that it cuts across all sectors – rural development, forestry, fisheries, health and socio-economic development of people in the Pacific – and why it is important to involve journalists to champion these issues. The paper discusses a set of objectives that journalists in the Pacific have developed, and hope will be implemented by media organisations, to ensure continuous and consistent coverage, awarenessraising and community outreach programmes to ensure climate change is placed at the top of a g e n d a s , d e ve l o p m e n t s a n d strategies at local, national and regional levels. The presentation then focuses on constraints the media faces when addressing issues regarding climate change. These include lack of resources, lack of funding to support the media, and lack of partnership and collaboration between media, governments, partners in development and regional technical and scientific organisations. Also, there is a need for media reporting guidelines, and for information sharing with stakeholders. And importantly, there is a need to use credible sources of information when dealing with data and statistics. 28 The paper raises issues in relation to the lack of capacity-building programmes, such as training and workshops, for both media and stakeholders (including government officials, scientists and experts) on understanding each other’s work and roles. Additionally, it recognises the need for networking and the important roles the media play in educating, informing and empowering people on climate change issues and issues that affect their livelihoods, earning capacities and, significantly, their lives in islands in the region. Finally, it outlines a programme currently being developed in the Pacific to increase communication outreach work in relation to environmental issues including climate change. THE CONTRIBUTION RADIO SCRIPTWRITING OF COMMUNITY RADIO COMPETITIONS PROMOTE TO UNDERSTANDING LEARNING FOR AFRICAN THE IMPACT OF CLIMATE BROADCASTERS ON CHANGE ON AGRICULTURE TOPICS OF RELEVANCE TO IN KOUTIALA, MALI SMALLHOLDER FARMERS Mr Moctar Niantigui Coulibaly, Alliance des Radios Communautaires, Mali Ms Blythe McKay, Farm Radio International, Canada Climate change is a major handicap to the sustainable development process in general and, more specifically, to agricultural development. According to weather predictions, the Malian climate is becoming warmer, drier and more variable, with mean temperatures perhaps reaching 45°C by the year 2025. These climate changes seriously threaten agricultural activities and food security for the people of Mali, especially as the people depend totally on agriculture, and agriculture depends totally on climate – this dynamic of life is becoming more and more precarious. Climate change is affecting people’s right to development. Farmers living in essentially rural areas such as Koutiala have little knowledge about the new national and international directives on the subject. Yet their communities are the most vulnerable, and their lifeline activity is compromised by climate change. ARCOM, the Alliance des Radios Communautaires du Mali, via its member radio stations, has led a radio campaign on this subject. Several interactive broadcasts have been produced. Each one contributed at three levels: (i) intermediation to develop relations and active synergy among the various actors; (ii) investigation to make certain that the vulnerability of the local communities is well understood; and (iii) advocacy to support appropriate concerted actions that help local communities adapt to climate change. The ultimate goal of this campaign was to allow farmers to talk with specialists, and to be given the opportunity to express themselves. Since 2005, Farm Radio International, in collaboration with other partners, has held three scriptwriting competitions for radio broadcasters across sub-Saharan Africa. The first competition focused on the Millennium Development Goals; the second was on smallholder farmers’ strategies for adapting to climate change; and the current competition highlights smallholder farmer innovations. The competitions aim to strengthen the capacity of organisations and individuals that work with radio to develop scripts and radio programmes on the specific competition topic, and also to increase quality broadcasts on that topic across sub-Saharan Africa. An evaluation of the climate change competition concluded that: • t he resources developed to assist the scriptwriters were well received and appreciated as offering useful support; • t he competition was a great opportunity to provide coaching to radio practitioners in scriptwriting and farm radio programming; • t he competition increased the availability of high-quality scripts on climate change; • the learning potential of script competitions is perceived by stakeholders, including competitors, to be better achieved if it is a recurrent event; • the scripts are extensively used and appreciated by the broadcasters who receive them; • the radio programmes produced on the basis of the scripts are popular; • anecdotal evidence suggests that radio programmes produced on the basis of the scripts have changed local farming practices. The current competition is experimenting with online training to assist competition participants in developing their scripts. The panel presentation will focus on the evolution of the script competition model as a tool for learning. CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES OF REPORTING AND COMMUNICATING AGRICULTURAL AND RURAL ISSUES Mr Gerald Businge (Mr Risdel Kasasira, Presenter), Ultimate Media Consult, Uganda The limited coverage of agricultural issues in Africa has been well documented (see Sowing the Seeds, International Women’s Media Foundation, 2008). The pressure to cover audienceattracting issues, and the belief that “agriculture does not sell” (used in media circles to refer to attracting sales or audience interest), have contributed to limited interest by journalists and media houses in covering agriculture and rural development issues (whether by reporting and publishing via print or online media, or airing via broadcast media). Yet agriculture, which employs more than 75% of Ugandans (Uganda National Housing and Population Census, 2002, Uganda Bureau of Statistics) and contributes more than 67% of Uganda’s gross domestic product (Background to the 2009/2010 National Budget, April 2009, Ministry of Finance Planning and Economic Development), is – or should be – an issue of interest to the majority of Ugandans. For the past 10 years, “The New Vision” (www.newvision.co.ug) has been publishing two pages of farming every Wednesday. News and best practices in agriculture are the major content. In 2008 the newspaper added another series, “Harvesting Money”, which profiles farmers who are marking large earnings from agriculture. These efforts were started by the newspaper as an internal initiative. Early this year, the Daily Monitor (www. monitor.co.ug) started to dedicate four to eight pages to covering agricultural issues. This initiative is a result of partnership with the International Women’s Media Foundation (www.iwmf.org) on reporting agricultural and women issues in Africa (see www.huffingtonpost. com/2009/02/24/profound-disconnect-betwe_n_169647.html). What outputs, in terms of quality and quantity of coverage, have been achieved by the media houses’ initiatives? What lessons can be learned from these initiatives to inform greater coverage and communication of agriculture and rural development issues? How can this increased coverage be enabled to reach the grassroots, given the access limitations of newspapers, television, online and radio? This research attempts to answer these questions. Media and gender equality PROMOTING GENDER EQUALITY IN ARD THROUGH INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIES – A MYTH OR REALITY IN BOTSWANA? Dr Bantu Morolong, University of Botswana, Botswana In 2007, women made up about 41% of total employment in agriculture globally, while in Africa they performed 80% of the work associated with ARD. In both the Caribbean and sub-Saharan Africa, women produce up to 80% of basic foodstuffs. Despite this and their most important contribution to food security, in many African countries women’s access to infrastructure, specifically the media, for effective performance of their agricultural tasks is still not equal to that of their male counterparts. This paper acknowledges, in this information age, the central role of ICTs in agricultural development in Africa. It seeks to assess the extent to which application of these technologies in this sector, with the aim (among others) of improving productivity, access to markets, quality of products and access to information for effective decision-making, has contributed to gender equality in Africa generally, and in Botswana in particular. The paper uses documented and field experiences to show that agricultural programme-planners in Africa still have the perception that farmers are male. As a result, the increasing use of the media in this sector continues to target men, thus under-serving the gender equality agenda. This disservice has been accentuated by several factors, key among which is the persistent under-representation of women in science and technology in schools, in the media, and in technology policy decision-making and leadership. While upholding some of the inroads made to remedy the situation, this paper concludes by suggesting that this era of great growth in ICT is an opportune time systematically to integrate into the gender equality debate the issue of ICTs as one of the key vehicles for gender equality in ARD. 29 AGRICULTURAL AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT IN THE PACIFIC – CONNECTING GENDER EQUALITY AND THE MEDIA ORGANIC FARMING, CLIMATE CHANGE, LITERACY AND LOCAL FOOD NEEDS – WHAT ROLE FOR MEDIA? Ms Bernadette Masianini, Secretariatof the Pacific Community, Fiji Ms Dorienne Rowan Campbell, Networked Intelligence, Jamaica The SPC/EU “Development of Sustainable Agriculture in the Pacific” (DSAP) project, implemented in 16 Pacific island countries and territories, promotes and implements sustainable agriculture targeted at improving food production, thereby enhancing food security and income generation in the Pacific. The DSAP project uses participatory methods and is gendersensitive to the implementation of its activities. Pacific island countries and territories have shown different gender roles in all areas of activity, including agricultural production; these roles are capitalised upon when planning the implementation and monitoring and evaluation of activities in the participating countries. Equal participation and gender sensitivity promoted by the project ensured that the information getting to the target groups was relevant to their agricultural production needs. Using participatory methods, the project worked within the cultural and traditional settings of the Pacific island community, providing an enabling environment for connecting gender equality and the media. 30 Through our work with a network of women farmers in the Caribbean region (the Knowing and Growing – K&G – network), it is apparent that an increasing number of women farmers are looking to re-learn farming methods, and to apply the principles of organic farming to their farm activities, lifestyles and livelihood choices. Health concerns, the overall benefits of multi-cropping, the conservation of biodiversity, and the care of soil health and water systems have become even more critical factors for farmers in the context of climate change. Mono-cropping and slash-and-burn methods run counter to protecting the land. Secondary to the network’s main thrust, but increasing in importance, is the realisation that, contrary to many prevailing myths about organic farming, the yields from inter-cropping and biofarming can sustain regional food needs and contribute maximally to regional food security. What began as a network of farmers seeking to become organic has now broadened to farmers concerned about a healthy and resilient food economy in a context of climate change and environmental stress. The role of the media is key in countering mainstream thinking about these interrelated and complex issues. This case study presentation illustrates how organic farming provides a viable response to climate change prevention, mitigation and adaptation, with examples from organic farms in the Caribbean, and speaks to what needs to be done to support organic farm development in the region. Building on our experience of running five training workshops for over 150 women in the region, it makes the case for increased media engagement, with a view to supporting the needs of small-scale farmers and the particular strate- gic interests of women farmers. Three primary roles for the media are described. (i) Media stories and realities – “what’s happening on the farm”, using a range of media, from programmes for local radio stations, to hand-held video production on the farm, to use of Facebook groups by K&G members. The media play a critical role in public awareness and knowledge about production practices and sharing of local and regional information. Constraints to mainstream media coverage mean that alternative approaches need to be used to share information that is not necessarily “headline-grabbing”. Climate change adaptation needs to be incorporated and mainstreamed into national budgets and broader development efforts. This can be successful only if there is sufficient understanding of local livelihood realities and contexts, and how these relate to local climate variability and change. In this context, media capacity-building for Caribbean women farmers is urgent. While the K&G workshops have consistently engaged the media to interview farmers and highlight their perspectives, much more needs to be done to ensure these farmers are able to articulate their issues in a media-friendly way. We need to provide national, regional and independent media with a range of field-based messages and stories to promote organic farming in the region. (ii) Media as an advocacy tool to influence policy-makers – the development of local audio-visual training tools specifically for farmers and public campaign materials for the general population needs to go hand-in-hand with the sensitisation and briefing required for policy-makers and champions of a robust and viable food economy in the region. In the context of climate change, women need to find those individuals within government bodies and institutions who understand and champion smallholder farm interests. These institutions often function at a policy-making level, not at the grassroots level, and do not involve or engage farmers. This includes those responsible for solid waste management, national security forces, national water commissions, forestry, meteorological offices, climate risk insurance bodies, tourism, aqua and fisheries development, coastal lands management and environmental legislature. The policy context, while still evolving, needs strong and vocal advocacy from and for women farmers, and the media are important tools in this. (iii) Media’s function as a climate change literacy tool – specialist journalists need to be trained and supported in sector-specific issues relating to climate change and agriculture. Climate change literacy will require sustained and comprehensive activities in the following aspects. • B asic climate change literacy, awareness and understanding of global and local climate change issues among farmers and consumers. • Further development of digital networking and electronic access to climate-change information and networks. • Inspiration and affirmation from what farmers have been able to do to mitigate and adapt to climate change, and what can be done locally in the Caribbean; women’s voices need to be promoted too. • A range of technical know-how encompassing permaculture, organic farming and “beyond organic” needs to be made readily available to counter mainstream agro-industry (such as easily available GMOs, fertilisers and pesticides). • A n awareness of issues that farmers do not often get to hear about, such as access to information about on-farm and processing energy use and options; maximising carbon sequestration on farm and minimising carbon emissions; trends in biofuel production; practical actions to collect weather data; and future plans for climate risk insurance and reduction in the region. • U nderstanding their farming roles in reducing carbon emissions and the farm’s role in carbon sequestration. • Understanding the key aspects of water systems management for the farm and beyond. •U  nderstanding links with forestry departments and possible partnerships there; a systemic shift away from current single-species monoculture model (whether in crops, livestock, aquaculture or forestry) towards a more integrated, closed-cycle polyculture system. •B  eginnings of an understanding of traditional means of farm protection in hurricanes. GENDER PRINCIPLES IN THE MEDIA IN GUINEA Ms Mama Adama Keita, Radio Nationale, Guinea The media in Guinea have been going through a period of change since 20 August 2005, when m e d i a l i b e ra l i s a t i o n b e c a m e effective through the installation and operationalisation of private radio stations (now 20 of them). Before that time, the country had several newspapers and many online information sites, in addition to the community and rural radio services that were relays of Radio Télévision Guinéenne (RTG). Besides these two public sector media, there are also Radio Kaloum Stéréo (RKS) and Channel 2 on national television. The public media cover the whole country, and broadcast in various national languages and in foreign languages including Arabic, English and French. As Guinea has its own journalism training facility, students can choose this profession; women, especially young girls, are actively joining in. Until recently, most young girls and boys showed interest in journalism as a career only when they could not get jobs as civil servants or somewhere else after completing their university studies. Another reason for joining the media now is the ease of recruitment; standards are not imposed. The founders of private stations hire young people without legal guarantees, training or due processing. Journalism as a career is attracting more and more girls and boys, who are anxious to get ahead – but, unfortunately, they face numerous constraints when exercising this profession in the field. Girls are always relegated to the back seat concerning initial and continued access to school. This situation can be traced to stereotypical discrimination in traditional societies. According to statistics in the Guinea Country Report, Global Advocacy Project 2004–2005, in the community stations 29% of male agents have higher education diplomas, compared with 3% of the women; 71% of those working as journalists have an average level that shows professional training, and the majority (55%) are women. When political, economic, scientific or juridical subjects or wars are assigned as feature stories, men are often selected because the station heads feel that current events can only be covered well by male journalists. The advancement of women in this profession is also held back by insufficient computer literacy and by sexual harassment. This is a problem in terms of women’s emancipation and their social and administrative vulnerability. Insufficient training is also a problem, as it often turns women into potential victims, especially those fortunate enough to have a household (with all that that entails). Reconciling field work and household work is difficult for women with a family, and women who do not have a partner are generally ill-considered by the people around them. Despite the problems listed above, Guinean women stand out in this sector, where they are given senior positions such as minister, director or chief editor, or are tasked with creating newspapers or private radio stations. 31 THE MULTI MEDIA RESOURCE KIT Ms Sylvie Siyam, Cameroon (Ms Melanie Hughes, Presenter), Protégé QV, Canada The Multi Media Resource Kit (MMRK) provides information relevant to the creation, improvement and management of micro-enterprises in Cameroon in one document, with elaboration through a CD-ROM, website and hardcover book. Users of the MMRK are radio professionals who develop distance training programmes designed to reinforce the capacities of women micro-entrepreneurs. The MMRK can be used as the main resource, or as a complementary resource, in the development and elaboration of radio broadcasting programmes. Based on research carried out in 2005 on “Small Business Training for Women using Radio Programmes”, PROTEGE QV identified what type of information microentrepreneurial woman need, as well as their radio listening habits. From the data gathered, the MMRK was elaborated and organised into seven main themes related to micro-entrepreneurship: • • • • • • • starting a micro-enterprise financing taxes and duties management of an enterprise training and information improving production product sales. A first draft was elaborated and tested through a pilot phase with Radio YEMBA and Rural Radio FOTOUNI in the Western Province of Cameroon. The pilot phase also involved six “Common Initiative Groups” (GICs), composed mainly of women agricultural workers, who carefully monitored the broadcast programmes to evaluate the relevance of the content. The goal was to identify the issues involved in assembling radio programmes with the MMRK, and to discover the MMRK’s impact on women’s work in the field. The difficulties raised at this preliminary stage were taken into account to improve the MMRK and to prepare the final draft. The final draft was presented to the public on 3 September 2007. For this event, PROTEGE QV organised a workshop with approximately 20 radio stations from both urban and rural areas, as well as several groups of micro-entrepreneurial women, to participate in a day-long workshop to learn how to use the MMRK. The workshops consisted of creating an online account for radios and showing them how to use the tool online. Each radio left with the hard-cover copy of the MMRK. In November 2007, field research was conducted with the two pilot radio stations and the six GICs of the project. The objectives were to follow up on the use of the MMRK; collect information to make web pages dedicated to the work and progress of the women, as well as the relevance of the MMRK to their work; and reinforce the radio stations’ and GICs’ ability to use the tool on the web. The MMRK enables women to have access to important information that is otherwise difficult to obtain, through the commonly used communication medium of radio. With increased access to valid, concrete and pertinent information, women can manage their learning by knowing precisely what type of information they need, and request further information or training to improve their work. Media funding in ARD IS CLOSER COOPERATION THE ANSWER TO THE FINANCIAL PROBLEMS ways of breaking through these barriers, citing examples from various regions of the world. OF ACP MEDIA HOUSES? Mr Hans Determeyer, Free Voice Programme, The Netherlands 32 This paper examines some of the key challenges of media finance, credit and investment. It discusses the “hostile environment” in which the media operate, and highlights the often limited technical support services and the difficulties of retaining trained and experienced staff in ACP media. The paper further examines the issue of limited capital. It concludes by suggesting FUNDING FOR MEDIA AND ARD Mr Michael Waigwa, Cooperative Insurance Company, Kenya Funding is a key issue for strengthening the role of media in ARD. This paper examines the funding challenge specifically from the perspective of the importance of “demand-driven media” for ARD. On one hand, the paper argues that many different agencies may be willing to fund stronger media for ARD, from manufacturers to banks and insurance companies to government and research institutions. On the other hand, the paper discusses the need for selffunded media that respond to the demands of farmers themselves. The paper highlights examples, including the dairy industry in Kenya. AGRICULTURE, WOMEN AND THE MEDIA – CRITICAL INVESTMENTS Ms Cece Fadope, International Women’s Media Foundation, USA This presentation highlights an initiative by the International Women’s Media Foundation to invest specifically in the area of women, media and ARD. The project “Reporting on Women and Agriculture: Africa” is described. Its goals are to increase and sustain accurate, consistent, and more rigorous news media reporting on agriculture and rural development; to incorporate women’s roles, stories, needs and solutions in the coverage of agriculture and rural economies; and to create more gender equality in newsrooms. The paper presents examples from the project, and concludes with a list of indicators of success. KEY TRENDS IN FUNDING THE ROLE OF MEDIA IN AGRICULTURAL AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT Dr Helen Hambly Odame, University of Guelph, Canada There are several key trends apparent in the role played by the media in ARD. This poster highlights the wavering pattern of funding in recent decades that affects investment in media in ARD in ACP countries and regions. The poster also identifies some key research and development projects that underlie the funding trends. Of specific importance is the decline in public funding of agricultural extension that has adversely affected media funding in ARD since the mid-1980s; the continuing challenges faced by community media to fund their initiatives in print, radio and participatory video; and the increasing importance of private foundations in media for ARD during the past five years. The poster recommends improved partnerships among funding agencies to share information about their initiatives, to exchange knowledge about both successes and challenges in media for ARD, and to harmonise the quality and quantity of media in ARD. Media and arid and semi-arid zones STUDY AND ANALYSIS OF THE IMPACTS OF AGRICULTURAL HOLDINGS AND LIVESTOCK FARMS LOCATED AROUND PROTECTED AREAS – THE CASE OF THE “W” PARK OF NIGER REPUBLIC Ms Teresa Fernandes Pereira da Veiga Tavares, Cape Verde The “W” Park experiences significant anthropogenic pressure due to population growth and agricultural, pastoral and hunting activities. Its effective and sustainable management strategy requires the consideration of medium- and longterm problems posed by human activities, particularly through land use. To understand the impacts, a study on the dynamics of interactions between biophysical and socio-economic systems is needed. This understanding will make it possible to obtain indicators on resource degradation and to develop decision-support tools for sustainable management of these resources. In this context, agro-pastoral uses and practices are considered to be disrupting the natural environment. The aims of the initiative are to: (i) contribute to the biophysical characterisation of the area in order to help with concerted agro-pastoral resource management and the prevention of conflicts around the “W” Park; (ii) study and analyse the impact of human activities on the environment through land use around the Park; and (iii) determine a useful area and a mode of sustainable natural resource management for the agro-pastoral activities of the communities living around protected areas. The project includes a literature review, analyses of maps, utilisation of remote sensing and GIS, and surveys and interviews with the authorities of the “W” Park of Niger, livestock service and villages, local authorities, farmers, livestock breeders, representatives of farmers’ and livestock breeders’ associations and NGOs. Zoning of the Park periphery based on the various anthropogenic pressures, and the socio-economic activities and resource utilisation in riverine villages around the Park, are known. The pressure on resources and the environmental impact resulting from agro-pastoral practices in and around the Park, and the strategy adopted for managing the lands around the Park, are described. Proposals for better management will be submitted to the authorities and will be used for other such parks in the country. TAKING STOCK OF THE REHABILITATION OF DEGRADED SOILS IN THE SAHELIAN DRY REGIONS USING THE ZAÏ TECHNOLOGY (BURKINA FASO, MALI, NIGER) Ms Delphine Droux, France In the dry regions of Sahel, soil degradation reduces the extent of arable land and reduces agricultural production, leading farmers to poverty and migration. Zaï is an indigenous technology, traditionally manual, that allows farmers to produce on degraded lands and to restore their fertility [by concentrating runoff water and organic matter in basins dug during the dry season]. Despite the efficiency of this technology in Sahel, its adoption is challenged by the quantity of labour required (approximately 33 500 hours per person per ha) in the harsh conditions of the dry season. Mechanised zaï drastically reduces the labour requirement and its drudgery, and improves agricultural production. Perspectives opened by mechanised zaï justify the current scientific interest in the method. This work takes stock of existing results and experiences on both versions of zaï technology, manual and mechanised, to build up scientific knowledge prior to its wide dissemination. It is based on a critical review of the available literature and a survey of 60 farmers located in 12 villages scattered over five departments of Zondoma Province, in the northern part of Burkina Faso. In this semiarid zone, annual average rainfall ranges between 500 and 700 mm, soils are ferric lixisols 50–80 cm deep, and the main crops grown are cereals (sorghum and millet). All farmers surveyed practice manual zaï, but only a few have adopted mechanised zaï, which is currently practised only in northern Burkina Faso, mainly within development schemes of the International Fund for Agricultural Development, and is the subject of only limited research. 34 Manual zaï is a common farmers’ practice in Burkina Faso, Mali, and Nige. It has been investigated largely in Burkina Faso; access to the results of investigations carried out in Mali and Niger is difficult. When practised in the same conditions, the performance of mechanised zaï is said to be higher than that of manual zaï, due to the higher soil humectation allowed by mechanised zaï. The field survey showed a large diversity in farmers’ practice of manual zaï. The functioning of zaï and its impacts on soil water, organic matter, biology and nutrients, and induced changes in soil properties (pH, exchange complex and texture) have been little investigated. Field evidence confirms that there are situations where zaï undoubtedly aggrades lands that were initially degraded and unproductive. It remains necessary to understand (i) in which soil, slope and crop situations zaï is efficient; (ii) when one can consider the major soil functions restored, and what the indicators are; and (iii) which agricultural practices or cropping systems can be advised as a follow-up to zaï. Responses to these questions will help in considering the integration of zaï in innovative cropping systems that may favour ecological intensification. Zaï in its manual and mechanised forms deserves a substantial research investment. AN ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF THE EFFECT OF VARIETY TRAITS ON THE ADOPTION OF IMPROVED PIGEON PEA VARIETIES ability to fetch a price premium. Early maturity was not a significant variable explaining farmers’ adoption decisions, in contrast to the short-duration varieties responsible for the rapid technology uptake in Africa’s largest producer, Malawi. The implications of this are twofold: varietal development and promotion must include consumption and market characteristics in addition to production traits when determining which varieties to promote; and nonyield production characteristics such as taste and ease of cooking are significant factors in farmers’ assessment of the value of a new variety. IN KENYA’S DRYLANDS – A CASE STUDY OF TAITA AN ANALYSIS OF FARMER DISTRICT GROUPS IN CONSERVA- Ms Zipora Otieno, University of Nairobi, Kenya In principle, farmers view improved seed as a derived input embodying production and consumption attributes, and decide on its adoption and the intensity of adoption. This paper proposes a holistic approach to plant breeding policy in developing countries. Drawing on the theory of duality, which explicitly incorporates variety traits into the household’s optimisation process, this study sought to investigate the drivers of the AIDA project’s success story in Taita District. The paper summarises the results of research into factors contributing to the rapid adoption of improved pigeon pea varieties in Kenya’s drylands, with a focus on variety traits. Empirical analysis was based on a double-hurdle model using data collected from 200 households in Taita District in 2009. A multitude of production and consumption traits valued by farmers, as well as an array of household socio-economic characteristics, were considered. Both probit and multivariate probit results indicate that the variety traits significantly influencing the rapid adoption of improved pigeon pea varieties were drought tolerance, pest tolerance, yield, ease of cooking, taste, and the variety’s TION AGRICULTURE IN DRYLAND AREAS OF MALAWI: CHINGULUWE EPA IN SALIMA AND NKOMBA MODEL VILLAGE IN BAZALE EPA, BALAKA DISTRICT Mr Mavuto Mdulamizu, Malawi This study on farmer groups’ management of land and water in the drylands of Malawi was undertaken to understand the factors within farmer groups that are crucial to the successful implementation of conservation agriculture. Data were collected from farmers implementing conservation agriculture, and analysed using both qualitative and quantitative methods. Results revealed that social factors, such as group leadership, social networks, structures and systems, competencies and skills, purpose and values, beliefs and the identity members attach to the group, contribute to groups’ effective performance in implementing conservation agriculture. Issues of resources and the environment in which the groups operated were not significant for the groups’ effective performance. Further results showed that farmers’ perceptions on the various conservation technologies were dependent on the performance of the technologies, considering the biophysical and socio-economic environments. It is recommended that social factors of groups should be considered if farmers’ groups are to be effective and successful in implementing conservation agriculture technologies. It is further recommended that bottom-up approaches must be pursued when recommending technologies. AFRICA’S DRYLANDS – “AN OUNCE OF PREVENTION IS WORTH A POUND OF CURE” Judith Ann Francis, CTA, The Netherlands Danièle Clavel, AIDA coordinator, France Yodit Kebede, CTA, The Netherlands Africa is extremely dry, 43% of the continent’s landmass being classified as drylands, and is under con- tinuous threat from erosion and nutrient mining. Climate change may aggravate this situation further. Several major regions are affected, and more than 40% of the continent’s population, 268 million people, live in dryland areas. Dryland people are resilient, having developed adaptation strategies to cope with the very variable environmental and climatic conditions. Yet drylands are often seen as non-productive lands and their importance and contributions to the livelihoods of millions of people are not given sufficient attention. The perception exists that little can be done to raise productivity sustainably. However, Africa’s drylands have high potential for development, and can provide multiple goods and services. Within the EU-INCO “Agricultural Innovation in Dryland Africa” (AIDA) project, 22 case studies were evaluated, and surveys were conducted among policy-makers and researchers to identify key drivers for success, and policy options that can promote investment in Africa’s drylands. Results show that there is need for harmonisation of policies and interventions in drylands, which should reflect realities that dryland people face; ensure compatibility with land tenure issues; reduce resource-based conflicts; and pave the way for more trade exchange. Traditional users and owners of drylands must be involved in policy development, programme planning and research design. Research in support of drylands agriculture should be participatory and reflect the diversity of indigenous adaptation strategies. Communication is key to success and for dissemination of existing practices for the development of local innovation. Communication between media and other ARD players PARTNERSHIP BETWEEN AGRICULTURAL AND NATURAL RESOURCE MANAGEMENT TRAINING AND RURAL RADIO IN THE SOUTHERN AND SOUTH-EAST REGIONS OF SENEGAL Mr Madior Fall, USAID Wula Nafaa-Senegal USAID/Senegal encourages media coverage of American aid programmes in Senegal in order to increase understanding and support for its objectives and interventions. USAID/Senegal has asked its partners to give positive publicity to their joint activities by efficiently planning events and involving the media, the beneficiaries of its activities and programmes, as well as US government officials and officials from the host coun- try’s government. USAID/Senegal expressed this will strongly in the second phase of the Agriculture and Natural Resources Management Programme by establishing a policies and communications branch, in which communication involves both information dissemination and communication used as a political tool to enlighten public debate. Communication is a tool needed for promoting fruitful dialogue in favour of political change that promotes economic growth, and for better natural resource management. Communication should also be a tool that allows people at grassroots level to express constraints encountered in implementing forest and agricultural policies. Rural radio is considered as: •a  n extremely powerful technology for transmitting knowledge with a potentially enormous outreach at local level; • a practical, creative channel for facilitating the dissemination of information in rural areas; • a tool for reaching all categories of the community through the use of local languages; • a local development tool that promotes the exchange of information, knowledge and skills within the community, thanks to the “neighbourhood effect”. T h e A g r i c u l t u r e a n d N a t u ra l Resources Management Programme is developing a partnership with the rural radios network installed in its area of intervention. Field officers, called facilitators, are creating and producing broadcasts on themes and activities related to agriculture (support to agricultural and forestry sectors) and natural resources management (including local natural resource management). 35 ROLE OF RADIO IN AGRI- SURFACING THE CULTURAL DEVELOPMENT STRENGTHS OF LOCAL IN THE PACIFIC CONTENT THROUGH Ms Rita Narayan, Regional Media Centre, SPC, Fiji COMMUNICATION This paper discusses the importance of radio in agricultural development in the Pacific. It highlights the challenges faced in disseminating agriculture and extension information in the Pacific island countries and territories, and the need for capacity-building of stakeholders, including extension officers, journalists and agriculture information officers, in the production of effective radio programmes on agriculture. The paper discusses the lack of resources and funding to support radio training in the Pacific, and the lack of partnership and collaboration between radio broadcasters, governments, development partners, researchers and technical stakeholders. The presentation also looks at the need for agriculture networks to support journalists and producers of radio programmes. These networks should also support the dissemination of information in local languages. Also, there is a need for minimum quality standards of broadcasting on agriculture, to enable radio broadcasters to provide quality agriculture communication to their respective target audiences in a manner that is effective in achieving the planned objectives. 36 Finally, the paper discusses the need to use community radio as a means of effectively sharing information with rural communities and the outer islands of the Pacific. This supplements work carried out by mainstream radio stations and communication outreach work in relation to agriculture and rural development. PARTICIPATORY organisations with sincere respect for the views of rural people are critical for the success of this rural development-centred media strategy. Mr Charles Dhewa, Knowledge Transfer Africa, Zimbabwe INNOVATIVE FARMER In Southern Africa, the mainstream media do not satisfy the needs of rural people. The voices of farmers, innovators, artisans, traditional medical practitioners and rural industries are rarely featured in the media. With more than 80% of people eking out a living in rural areas, developing countries are not fully exploiting the potential of rural communities whose practices have deep roots in indigenous and local knowledge. USING ICT In Zimbabwe, the creation of “community knowledge centres” is already showing fruitful results. Through community knowledge centres, conservation agriculture practices are being integrated with the vast quantities of knowledge that exist in rural areas, locked away in the collective memory of the people as inherited knowledge and personal experience. Knowledge centres are also documenting locally created information, and linking up with the mainstream media. A lot of information comes from rural communities, but few community members know about it. Information collected by extension workers, NGOs and researchers is often sent to higher officials at head offices, not back to the community structures, perhaps because there are no structures to store and continuously evaluate such knowledge. Community knowledge centres are making sure local information becomes the basis for raising awareness about development issues in rural communities. Community knowledge centres are demonstrating that participatory communication should be embraced because it emphasises “listening”, compared with mainstream communication, which focuses on “telling”. This effort can enrich media content with grassroots indicators of knowledge-sharing and climate change. Champions, people and ADVISORY SERVICES Mr Francois Stepman, Forum for Agricultural Research in Africa (FARA), Ghana The FARA Inventory on Innovative Farmer Advisory Services is the result of an online consultation with the FARA Regional Agricultural Information & Learning System (RAILS) held during the month of October 2008, and a desk study. The inventory was an attempt to document all known innovative farmer advisory services or systems currently in design, in existence or recently completed in Africa. Entries include projects using ICT solutions or implementing ICT-based activities; institutions/groups providing services using ICTs; and ICT solutions software providers, at both national and regional levels. While many of the entries are projects with a definitive beginning and end date, providing one or two services, others are national or regional information systems providing many agricultural services using ICTs. The conclusion of our study is that there will probably never be a “one-fit-for-all” system. But the inventory suggests that systems which use a voice platform or audio files provide an innovative and promising entry point for farmer information, while the other platforms (SMS and webbased) remain essential to provide a back-end offering more detailed information. In order to answer the question “how can we monitor the impact?”, we need to look into the broader innovation opportunities of farmers. To monitor the impact of the tool, we need to look into the most effective ways of reaching farmers with timely agricultural information and knowledge (indigenous and external); mechanisms for harnessing the potential of FM radio stations and digital telephony as technologies for communicating agricultural information; options for repackaging agricultural information and knowledge for smallscale farmers; and the potential role of an e-repository (of local agricultural content) in Africa for purposes of disseminating local agricultural content. BRIDGING THE GAP – WRENMEDIA’S APPROACH TO SUPPORTING BETTER SCIENCE REPORTING BY JOURNALISTS AND BUILDING PARTNERSHIPS BETWEEN MEDIA AND THE AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH COMMUNITY Ms Susanna Thorp, WRENmedia, UK A pilot initiative to provide training to African radio and print journalists alongside major international conferences is helping to strengthen links between scientific researchers and the media. Selected international science events have provided journalists with a focus for their reporting and the opportunity to improve their understanding of issues presented. To improve technical skills in science reporting, sessions on content gathering, photography, news and feature writing, as well as digital editing, were provided. In addition, the WRENmedia team and the journalists held a “Making the most of the media” session at each venue for interested conference delegates to learn more about interacting with the press. This valued, interactive event offered conference participants the chance to discuss the importance and challenges of making the most of the media, to get tips on how to perform well and deal with the difficulties that journalist’s interest may present, as well as to learn ways to develop good, clear messages appropriate to particular audiences. The sessions not only provided valuable advice to the researchers, but also helped to stimulate the important process of building partnerships between the media and the agricultural research community. The confidence of journalists in capturing and sharing science stories was increased, and their contribution to communicating science was recognised and taken more seriously. This DFID-supported initiative for training African journalists builds on previous WRENmedia experience in working alongside journalists to communicate agricultural research in Kenya (with the horticulture industry) and in Uganda (raising awareness on sleeping sickness). Contribution of the media to agricultural policy, programming and knowledge management The SIST tool and access to information for agricultural and rural journalists Mr Helmer Thierry, CIRAD, France SIST, a Scientific and Technical Information System, is a project for Africa funded by the French Ministry of Foreign and European Affairs and operated by the French Agricultural Research Centre for International Development (CIRAD). The main aim of the SIST project is to make African research less isolated and, at the same time, to reduce the scientific digital divide between North and South. This stand-alone, innovative scientific and technical infor- mation tool has been installed in six countries in Africa. Problems with access to new ICTs are making it slower for African communities to emerge from their isolation and enjoy greater visibility on the information highways. Furthermore, the diversity and complexity of modern tools make it difficult to appropriate and share them. The SIST project aims to provide a complete, intuitive, pragmatic work platform. The scope of this project goes beyond the scientific communities and can be used by any community that consumes or produces information. Journalists, for instance, should have easy access to agricultural and rural information in both the North and the South. Research results that have been capitalised through publication on the internet or inclusion in a database of results, or through any other route, constitute a resource that journalists should be able to access. There are several tools to meet these needs, enabling users to: • access e-information available on the internet or via networks, regardless of form (useful for the construction of agricultural and rural information portals, for instance); • popularise access to new ICTs, enabling scientists to communicate, create and share (useful for the construction of a joint work platform among journalists); • publish on the internet without computer skills (be able to construct an information website 37 quickly and manage it without being an IT expert); • collect and structure information and make it accessible (co-construction and co-management of various databases among journalists). MWANA ALIRENJI (FOOD SELF-SUFFICIENT) RADIO MAGAZINE TURNS MALAWIAN FARMERS INTO RESEARCHERS, INNOVATORS AND SELF-SUFFICIENT FOOD PRODUCERS Mr Gladson Elemiya Makowa, Story Workshop, Malawi This paper highlights the impact of Mwana Alirenji, a farmers’ radio magazine programme that I produce for Story Workshop, Malawi. Mwana Alirenji, a common Malawian expression meaning “there is nothing a child can cry for when food is plenteous”, aims to attain food self-reliance among small-scale farmers in rural Malawi. The programme features both local farmers who are still struggling to become food self-sufficient, and those who experienced similar challenges but have managed to overcome them through the use of innovative farming methods. The latter category act as our programme models. We use Radio Research Gardens, our brainchild radio-listening methodology, where we encourage members to “listen, learn and try” from the solutions and innovations aired in the programme (farmer-to-farmer concept). The trials are then implemented in a group using a designated model farm, and the group share their monthly progress with other farmers on the radio programme. The technical experts are only included to supplement the model farmers’ innovations and experiences. 38 The EU-funded project began in 1999 and has so far undergone three phases; the current fourth phase runs from 2008 to 2011. To assess impact, we ask farmers to write us letters explaining how the information they receive from the programme has helped them. We also use reporters’ interviews, and obtain more substantiated data from our monitoring visits to farmers. The results show that Mwana Alirenji has inspired and benefited many people through the networking forum that it offers. Although the programme is oriented towards farming, farmers have also used this forum to discuss issues related to food management, nutrition, health and the environment. Due to this, we have seen some farmers practising diet diversification, and others trying out various types of manure to maximise their yields. Mwana Alirenji also encourages farmers to become more innovative and to explore new farming techniques and inputs, such as organic manures that are friendly to the environment. Mwana Alirenji has therefore proved to be a reliable source of new agricultural technologies for both field assistants and farmers in Malawi. The major challenge, however, is lack of advocacy for positive findings. The adoption level of innovations by the Ministry of Agriculture is low because there are weak links between the media and the Ministry, so there is limited circulation, and a knowledge gap of new innovations and findings within agricultural extension structures. There is a need to strengthen relations between programme reporters/producers and policy-makers. Special follow-up mechanisms are needed to allow a wider distribution of innovative ideas, and for government to ensure replication of best practices in other areas. THE VALUATION OF BROADCAST RADIO IN RURAL DEVELOPMENT – A QUESTION OF TRANSACTION COSTS Mr Chris Yordy, Consultant with Community Development Service in Egypt, Canada This presentation examines factors that have prevented fishers and fish traders from accessing price information in two artisanal fishing communities in the Ada region of Ghana. Previous studies have found that high search costs have led to market failure and product spoilage, as part of a broader theoretical framework of transaction cost analysis that allows for the classification of both physical and information barriers within a rural economy. Despite the high costs of searching for market information implied by distance and a lack of communication infrastructure in rural areas of sub-Saharan Africa, in this study we found that community radio stood out among ICTs in reach and accessibility, and was helpful in reducing barriers to price information, particularly among women as fishmongers and traders in Ghana’s wholesale fish industry. This type of market analysis has implications for how radio and ICTs are valued and evaluated as part of the process for securing investment in communication for development initiatives, and in agricultural and fisheries investment in sub-Saharan Africa more generally. KEY CAPACITIES FOR COMMUNITY RADIO Mr Oumar Seck N’diaye, AMARC-Africa, Senegal This poster highlights the importance of capacity-building for community radio. It identifies the challenges of the current context of community radio stations in Africa. It suggests ways to address these challenges, including institutional changes that implicate organisational structures and funding. The poster also highlights key themes, levels and formats of training to build the capacity of community radio in Africa. BUILDING UNIVERSITY CAPACITY FOR MEDIA AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT Professor Bénédict Mongula and Ms Langa Sarakikya, University of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania The media are very important tools for rural development, but have often been overlooked in development discourse and initiatives. Many rural challenges – in the form of food and nutrition, access to and quality of rural social services such as health, water, energy and education, livelihoods and economic conditions, human rights, gender, local power relations and constraints, and cultural setbacks – are not known to policy-makers and the general public. In a project with the Maasai community in four villages of Monduli District, by University of Dar es Salaam and Huron University College, Canada, the villagers were clearly concerned about making their situation known to the wider Tanzanian public and to policymakers. They wanted critical problems relating to their livelihoods – difficulties in accessing veterinary services, markets for cattle and milk, health services, water, and fuelwood – to be made known. Equally, they were concerned about knowing of national and local government policies affecting their lives, including opportunities in different programmes. Despite the fact that Tanzania has numerous newspapers, radio and television stations, coverage of and access to rural areas has been extremely limited. Furthermore, the media in Tanzania face critical problems in terms of research capacity (data collection and analysis); ability to articulate information, including creative writing and packaging of information for a local rural audience; a lack of basic and specialised training and therefore of in-depth understanding of issues; as well as limited ability to identify the most critical, relevant and important problems to report. Transportation constraints, low access to technology, poor media literacy among rural populations, and editors’ and reporters’ lack of interest in travel to and reporting on rural local issues (closely related to media financing), only serve to compound the problem. The local community radio of the Maasai is no exception. While several higher-level education institutions in Tanzania have programmes relating to media training (including the Institute of Journalism and Mass Commu- nication of the University of Dar es Salaam, St Augustine University, Tumaini University and Dar es Salaam School of Journalism), these face critical staff problems. For example, there are very few PhD-holders to take up postgraduate training in media, and as a result the existing programmes are very new and urgently need strengthening. Humanities programmes, too, have often overlooked the importance of communication for rural development. Moreover, the existing media training curriculum is too general and theoretical, and lacking in experiential learning. The university-based radio and television stations at the universities, for example, can only engage few students and are themselves still to be adequately developed. Existing initiatives, such as the Tanzania Media Fund, the Media Institution of Southern Africa (MISA-TAN), and attempts to introduce courses on development and communication in existing humanities programmes, are steps in the right direction to try to cover the gaps left by the existing media training system. In view of the above, there is a need for government and development partners to support media training at both basic and postgraduate levels, and staff development in training institutions. Institutional environment: building the capacity of media in agricultural and rural development THE AFRICAN MEDIA DEVELOPMENT INITIATIVE Mr David Mowbray, BBC World Service Trust, UK Media can be a powerful agent for change in Africa but an extensive survey in 17 African countries through the African Media Development Initiative (AMDI) shows serious deficiencies in the capacity of media at all levels from basic journalism to management skills. The BBC World Service Trust has adopted a new capacity building model using highly trained in-station mentors with backstopping by a senior international trainer to address this problem while at the same time facilitating the creation of the new African Media Initiative (AMI), a ‘made in Africa’ solution to the funding and development of professional African media. MEDIA TRAINING IN THE CARIBBEAN Dr Maria Protz, Caribbean Institute for Media and Communication (CARIMAC), Jamaica This paper discusses a Caribbean approach to building media capacity for the agricultural sector. To start, the presentation describes the work of CARIMAC, the 39 Caribbean Institute for Media and Communication of the University of the West Indies, located on the Mona Campus, Jamaica. Media training for agriculture and natural resource management has involved CARIMAC staff in partnership with a range of agencies, including the new Communication for Sustainable Development Initiative (CSDI) collaboration with the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). “Pieces” of sustainable capacity-building within the CSDI include mainstreaming communication and development in three ministries of agriculture in the region, supporting community-based organisations in communication for development, and professional training for extension workers in communication for development for agriculture. Other elements include published case studies, new ICT applications linking farmers and extension staff, a professional association for communication for development, new academic offerings, and a web platform focused on climate change adaptation. THE EXPERIENCE OF GAINS WITH COMMUNITY RADIO Mr Joel Sam, INSTI, Ghana 40 This paper discusses the Ghana Agricultural Information Network System (GAINS) – a network of agricultural libraries and information centres in Ghana, which was established in 1991 under the Government of Ghana/ World Bank National Agricultural Research Project. The presentation explains the efforts of GAINS to revitalise library and information systems in the agricultural sector, to make information easily available and accessible to research and academia, and to provide information on demand to research scientists, lecturers, research managers, policy-makers and students. In its second phase, GAINS has been working to support the information needs assessment of extension agents and provide information provision through agricultural information centres. In its third and fourth phases, the system is placing emphasis on information services for farmers, fishermen and extension workers, including involvement with community-based FM radio stations and their agricultural programme producers to create question-andanswer service radio programmes in local languages. The presentation ends with reflections on the challenges experienced by GAINS and the importance of collaboration with community radio in Ghana. CAPACITY-BUILDING AND KNOWLEDGE-SHARING THROUGH COMMUNITY RADIO Dr Marcelo Solervincens, AMARC, Canada This paper describes the experience of AMARC in networking and working with community radio stations in ACP countries and regions around the world. From a community radio perspective, it highlights several challenges to the role of the media in ARD. A key element in increasing the effectiveness of community radio involves adopting a learning, knowledge-sharing and capacity-building model that (i) strengthens the appropriation of the media by local communities and individuals; and (ii) reinforces radio literacy and content literacy through exchanges between local and expert knowledge. CHALLENGES IN AGRICULTURE AND DEVELOPMENT – REPORTING IN MALAWI Mr Levi Zeleza Manda, University of Malawi, Malawi For decades, Malawi has been an agricultural economy. Despite occasional food shortages over the years, the country has generally been able to feed itself. Most recently, Malawi has outshone all its neighbours by realising bumper yields, particularly of maize (the country’s staple), tobacco and cotton. The key to Malawi’s food security success is threefold: focused government agriculture policy (such as agriculture input subsidies); determined leadership (President Mutharika is his own Minister of Agriculture); and prudent prioritisation of resources (agriculture is national development priority number one). Focused policy, prudent allocation of resources and determined leadership aside, the media have played a critical role in promoting agriculture and food security in Malawi. However, the Malawi media has faced a lot of challenges. Recent research studies indicate that Malawi lacks an agriculture reporting/communication policy and training; there is no specialisation in agricultural reporting; agriculture and rural development in do not feature highly as a news value in Malawian news media, which are instead dominated by elitist and Eurocentric news values. This paper shares both the successes of Malawi media involvement in agriculture and the challenges the media face. Media, emerging new media service and ICTs ICTS AND RURAL COMMUNITIES – FROM FERTILISER TO DROPLETS FOR AFRICAN AGRICULTURE Mr Souleymane Ouattara, African Journalists for Development Network (JADE), Burkina Faso In Sissili Province (Burkina Faso), M. Korogo, an agricultural adviser at the Fédération des Professionnels Agricoles de la Sissili (FEPPASI), stands for change. He visits Moumouni Nébié, another ICT buff, on his farm. Nébié owes a lot to ICTs. On the internet in 2005, he found a producers’ organisation in Benin specialising in yam production techniques. He learnt from them, and now produces his own yam seed. Another ICT aficionado in Sissili is Joseph Dagano, the President of FEPPASI. Early, he understood the enormous potential of ICTs to improve production, post-harvest conservation and marketing. His association is a member of the ‘TIC et Agriculture’ network. This is a Burkina ICT promotion association, created as a platform for sharing ideas, experiences and resources in agriculture-oriented ICTs as a source of progress for rural communities. An approach to ICTs is to focus on the production of training modules, funding, calls for tender, and also to report plant diseases to research institutes so that they can look for solutions. ICTs are also useful as tools of transparency in producers’ choices. Reporters record the information on their portable telephones and send it by text message to websites, or even for broadcasting on national radio and television. FEPPASI members can rightly exclaim that “digitisation gives a boost to agriculture”. But their success, paradoxically, proves that access to ICTs will, for a long time to come, be nothing but an inaccessible dream for thousands of Burkina farmers. THE USE OF WEB 2.0 TOOLS FOR SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURE – A CASE OF SMALL-SCALE FARMERS IN UGANDA LINKING RADIO WITH ICTS TO ENHANCE INTERACTION AND “RADIO ON DEMAND” Ms Maureen Agena, Women of Uganda Network (WOUGNET), Uganda Ms Margaret Nana Kingamkono, African Farm Radio Research Initiative, Farm Radio International, Tanzania In the modern era, both public and private sectors need fully to utilise and appreciate the effectiveness and efficiency of new media such as web 2.0 tools in processing, storing and retrieving agricultural information. In Africa, particularly Uganda, web 2.0 tools are a development that is new to many people, especially among small-scale farmers. Awareness and application of web 2.0 tools to their agricultural practices is minimal. Using the Citizen Journalism in Africa project, WOUGNET has equipped some of its members with skills in using social networking tools (such as blogs, wikis, RSS web feeds, Flickr and Skype), as well as writing articles, developing audio, video and digital stories, and online publishing. Radio has long been recognised as an excellent tool for reaching rural populations with low literacy levels. Access to radio is much greater than access to any other medium and, because it disseminates sounds rather than printed words, it benefits all listeners. However, the traditional weaknesses of radio have been that it is usually a oneway medium; and that it is available only at the time and on the day it is broadcast. The first weakness has made it an imperfect tool for dialogue, discussion, feedback and interaction; the second has meant that intended audience members (particularly rural women) may miss key broadcasts, or that more complicated information cannot be listened to repeatedly to ensure comprehension. This initiative has helped some rural farmers to use and interact with various forms of media to help them maximise their communication strategies in agriculture. The Citizen Journalism in Africa project aims to build the capacity of civil society organisations to use online and offline citizen journalism as a means of publication, lobbying, networking and knowledge-sharing, with a focus on both traditional and new media. This presentation focuses on the potential and challenges of applying web 2.0 tools in agriculture. Farm Radio International, through the African Farm Radio Research Initiative (AFFRI), has been learning about creative ways to use ICTs to address both weaknesses. Interactivity with listeners can be increased through the use of mobile phones, SMS, and low-cost recording devices. Phone-in and phone-out shows, SMS management software, and MP3 players are being used by AFRRI’s radio partners to put the voice of farmers on the air and allow dialogue between and among farmers, extension workers and researchers. Wind-up MP3 players, interactive voice-recording systems and other ICTs offer the potential to provide more farmers with “radio on demand”, with repeat listening at any time of convenience to farmers. 41 CONNECTING RURAL AFRICA USING MOBILE DEVICES Mr Dion Jerling, Connect Africa Services, South Africa This presentation is based on a CTA-sponsored project in Central Zambia that uses ICT and mobile devices to deliver multiple public and private sector services to deep rural communities. The success of the mobile phone in Africa is universally acknowledged and well documented – but it remains largely an urban success. Rural Africa has yet to benefit from these sometimes spectacular advances in mobile communications. Connect Africa sets out to address this challenge by combining a unique combination of social enterprise and entrepreneurship to build a deep rural service network that cooperates with government and the private sector to deliver multiple services directly to rural communities. With access to all ICT solutions currently available, Connect Africa is using a strategy of “fit for purpose” technology provision to ensure optimum service delivery can be sustainably maintained. This presentation touches on the technology solutions used and currently being trialled; the real and often underestimated challenges facing service providers in rural areas; who the key stakeholders should be to ensure optimum service levels are provided; and the all-important requirement of ongoing sustainability. 42 INFORMATION, RESOURCES, MULTIDISCIPLINARY AND MEDIA ENVIRONMENT FOR AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT IN TANZANIA Mr Jabir Jabir, Sokoine National Agricultural Library, Tanzania The media houses in Tanzania lack information resources such as libraries, internet connectivity, information collection, and well trained staff to serve and meet journalistic desires and needs. This also includes the issue of multidisciplinary media staff in the area of agriculture and its allied fields. With a multidisciplinary component among media practitioners, the current move by policy-makers in Tanzania, Africa and the world in general to make agriculture a number one priority can be achieved successfully if the media play a major role. The democratisation process in Tanzania continues to make it possible for more mass media houses to become involved in the information dissemination process. Currently, most are concentrating more on political and profit-oriented information. They provide little regarding the agricultural sector, which employs about 75% of Tanzanians. With a lack of public broadcasting services, the existing media (both government and private) concentrate on stories that favour and protect their institution, instead of translating, analysing and evaluating the policies with regard to the current development outlook. To make the mass media more effective in the development of agriculture and other socioeconomic issues, changes in the curriculum and the introduction of information literacy training in journalism studies will be needed. Media houses should be able to enrich their collections, have reliable connectivity, have qualified staff to manage their information resources and centres, and also have assigned sections for agricultural information packaging and processing – not forgetting the involvement of agricultural stakeholders in providing not only techniques, but also success stories from work in which they are currently involved. NAKASEKE TELECENTRE UGANDA Mr Peter Balaba, Nakaseke Telecentre, Uganda This poster highlights the work of the well known Nakaseke Telecentre in Uganda. It was established as one of five telecentre projects supported by UNESCO, the International Development Research Centre (IDRC) and the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) (the others being located in Benin, Mali, Mozambique and Tanzania). The telecentre provides information services to mainly illiterate farmers in subjects such as farm inputs, post-harvest handling, market price information, environmental protection, soil management, commodity value addition, credit schemes, and commercial farming skills. The telecentre has innovated with many different kinds of service since it was first opened in 1997. It has set up a community radio (FM102.9), operates a library, offers internet and wireless services such as phone charging, and provides computer training, repair and maintenance, secretarial services, video coverage, and information on HIV/AIDS, along with an outreach programme and a “Book Box” service. Working group recommendations Radio •R  eview previous capacity-building work that has already been done by all relevant players in the media industry in Africa to maximise what already exists, rather than duplicating efforts. • Enable each country/region to determine how training will take place in terms of accreditation or time frame. • E n c o u r a g e d e m a n d - d r i v e n capacity-building that embraces different radio stakeholders, actors and institutions. • E nsure capacity-building for radio is rooted at the local level and is needs-driven. • Ensure capacity-building is comprehensive, with generalised standards to include technical, production, radio station management and content development. • Adapt capacity-building for different types of radio station and their programming. • E stablish a small, competitive grants programme [e.g. €10,000–15,000, similar to the Gender, Agriculture and Rural Development in the Information Society (GENARDIS) programme] to focus on radio stations’ innovation and learning; focus grants on cooperation of listeners and listener representation in ARD. • Strengthen monitoring and evaluation (M&E) in radio stations, and identify methods to measure inputs, outputs, outcomes and impacts. • Provide training opportunities in planning and M&E for radio stations. • D evelop internal M&E in radio stations as much as possible, recognising that if the radio is government-funded or has to dovetail M&E with government ministries of agriculture or extension, it is important that the government provides sufficient guidelines to conduct M&E. • E ncourage radio stations to • • • • have an M&E work plan from the inception of each programme, and an annual work plan. E ncourage radio stations that started under external (e.g. UNESCO) funding to request the donor institution to assist in conducting M&E. A  ssist radio with the skills to fund-raise, conduct quantitative evaluations, and ensure listener involvement. E  nsure sustainability with a strategic/business plan from the inception. A  dvocate for a conducive legislative environment for community and independent radio. Television, video and film • I dentify existing training needs assessment studies for video/ television and address priorities for capacity-building. • Produce a glossary of agricultural terms for journalists/media practitioners in ACP countries. • P rovide a clearing house for (short) videos on agricultural and related rural issues at a professional level in ACP countries. • Assist governments in developing policies that support visual communication on ARD issues. • M obilise and support existing networks, regional organisations and farmers’ platforms to disseminate video programmes developed by multiple sources. • Organise regional and in-country workshops with multiple stakeholders and media practitioners to articulate demand for new agricultural video productions. • P rioritise film/video in ARD as a powerful tool that crosses boundaries of distance, language and season, and provides new and relevant opportunities for analysis, learning and reflection with all stakeholders. • Improve the quality of film/video in ARD by distinguishing between the roles of everyone involved (even when they are combined in one or a few people): commissioners, producers, film-makers, process facilitators and communication specialists. • E laborate strategic choices regarding the level of professionalism being in line with expected outputs, feasibility of expectations raised, and ethical considerations. • P r o f e s s i o n a l i s e f i l m / v i d e o through a peer-reviewed event such as a film festival (conference) – professionals watch, discuss and learn from their peers and improve the quality and impact of video as a product and a process. • Strengthen capacities and inform stakeholders of the importance of defining intellectual property rights, and of mutual respect among different actors in filmmaking. P  rint Newspapers, magazines and supplements •B  uild capacity by offering print media scholarships and exchange programmes. • Provide information about possible funding agencies for travel and fellowship grants within ACP regions. • Mainstream ARD in print media through multi-stakeholder workshops. • Create competitive seed grants for internal ARD training exercises, internal capacity-building and mentoring. • C onvene an annual ACP print media conference. • Establish a print media award to stimulate excellence in reporting ARD, networking and sharing ideas. • Translate CTA’s portal of success stories in ARD into book form, to be released annually by print and made available in ACP languages. 43 •P  rovide guidance on fundraising and circulate proposal templates. Other printed materials (newsletters, posters, brochures, comics, banners) •P  rovide training in citizen journalism. • Identify appropriate M&E tools (such as surveys and questionnaires). • Provide learning materials about audits, financial management, stocktaking of equipment, etc. • S upport internships, secondments and apprenticeships for print production. • Develop exit policies to hand over actions to the ACP regions. • Continue e-discussions and the print portal of success stories on CTA’s website. • Identify possible models for the establishment of an ACP Print Media Networking Forum. • • • • • • • • • • • Community media • I nvolve the community in the planning, operation and evaluation of community media. • U se a participatory approach, and include all members in the community. • Set up a multi-stakeholder platform to support community 44 • • • media, including expertise that is not present in the community. A  ddress institutional constraints, such as easing the licensing procedure for community radio stations and making it more affordable. D  evelop and adopt the use of agreed principles, ethics and guidelines for community media governance. D  ocument the required policy and regulatory environment for community media. D  evelop guidelines for engaging policy-makers and raising the profile of community media. S  upport capacity-building for community media on management issues. I dentify models for sustainability in community media. I nclude women in management as well as in production. I dentify ways to motivate and retain volunteers. P  romote networking among community media locally, nationally and across countries. D  evelop content based on local needs, understanding and languages. C  opyright/protect local content and respect intellectual property rights. E  ncourage documentation of local content using ICTs. P  romote the use of appropriate, affordable ICTs, and build on existing infrastructure, experience, availability and the community’s level. I ntegrate ICTs with other community media tools and resources. •P  rovide continuous training on emerging ICTs as needed. • I dentify ICTs and examples of best practices. • Engage communities in the entire M&E process. • P lan and fund M&E from the beginning of community media processes and communication strategies. • Use M&E results to revise practices as needed. • C ommunity media capacitybuilding must be inclusive of age, gender, ethnicity, class, etc. in the community itself. • Work with partners across ACP countries to exchange best practices and share experiences. • Offer training in management, production and programme M&E. • Continuously build institutional capacity to integrate emerging development challenges. • E ncourage capacity-building through a system of awards and recognition. VI – Annexes 6.1 Programme 09:00–12:00 Monday 12 October 2009 Registration of participants (Bedford Hotel) 10:00–12:00 Briefing meeting with steering committee members, panellists, moderators, participants and rapporteurs 12:00–13:00 Lunch (Bedford Hotel) BRUSSELS BRIEFING NO. 14: ACP AGRICULTURE AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT: WHY MEDIA MATTER? 13:10–13:30 Departure from Bedford Hotel to Borschette Centre 13:00–14:30 Registration to Brussels Briefing 14:30–15:00 Introductory remarks: Mr Ian Barber, European Commission, Sir John Kaputin, ACP Secretariat, Dr Hansjörg Neun, CTA Report on CTA Seminar 2009 e-discussions: Ms Susanna Thorp and Ms Laurence Lalanne, WRENmedia, UK 15:00–16:15 Panel 1: MAINSTREAMING MEDIA IN DEVELOPMENT: THE WAY TO GO? Moderator: Ms Tumi Makgabo, Africa Broadcasting and Media, South Africa Panellists • Her Excellency Ndisale Brave, Ambassador of Malawi • Hon. Ignatius Jean, Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture (IICA) • Mr Thozi Gwanya, Director-General, Department of Rural Development and Land Reform, South Africa • Mr Jean-Philippe Rapp, Director of the International Media North South Forum, Switzerland • Dr Kris Rampersad, Media and Literacy Consultant, Trinidad and Tobago • Dr Hansjörg Neun, Director of CTA, The Netherlands 16:15–16:45 Coffee break (EU Commission) 16:45–18:30 Panel 2: HOW CAN MEDIA BETTER SERVE RURAL COMMUNITIES?  oderator: M Dr Eugenia Springer, Director of Eugenia Springer Productions, Trinidad and Tobago Presentations and panel discussion • The needs and challenges in strengthening media capacities in ACP countries: Mr Sayouba Traoré (RFI) and Ms Violet Otindo, KBC-CNN Award Winner, Kenya • Linking media with local communities: Dr Helen Hambly, University of Guelph, Canada • ACP media and global challenges: bridging the gap: Ms Tumi Makgabo, African Broadcasting and Media, South Africa Conclusions 19:00 Reception (EU Commission) 20:15 Departure Borschette Centre to Bedford Hotel 45 Tuesday 13 October 2009 09:00–09:20 Presentation of the structure and the objectives of the seminar: Dr Helen Hambly, University of Guelph, Canada; Mr André Vugayabagabo, CTA, The Netherlands Session 3: MEDIA AND ARD ISSUES (plenary session) Moderator: Professor Chris Kamlongera, University of Malawi Discussant: Mr Kole Odutola, University of Florida, USA 9:20–10:10 Oral presentations • Video in Development – Filming for Rural Change (CTA book launch): Dr Rico Lie and Mr Andreas Mandler, University of Wageningen, The Netherlands • Sourcing information by the Pacific media on ARD: Ms Viola Ulakai, Tonga Broadcasting and Television Corporation, Tonga • The voice of the visual – visual learning strategies for problem analysis, social dialogue and mediated participation: Dr Loes Witteveen, IRDT, Wageningen University, The Netherlands • Developing a love affair between rural agriculture and the media: Dr Eugenia Springer, Trinidad and Tobago Posters • Media treatment of ARD issues – challenges and problems: Ms Matho Motsou Anne, Jade, Cameroon • Sim-info ANOPACI: Mr Kouao Sylvain, ANOPACI, Côte d’Ivoire • Media in agriculture – we are not second best: Mr Phil Malone, Countrywise Communications, UK • The use of multi-media to promote agriculture and rural development – “CABI’s Secret Service”: Ms Janny Vos, CABI, UK 10:10–10:40 Panel discussion 10:40–11:00 Coffee break 11:00–11:30 Media and agricultural extension and learning Moderator: Dr Kris Rampersad, Media and Literacy Consultant, Trinidad and Tobago Discussant: Mr Riccardo del Castello, FAO, Italy Oral presentations  La Voix du Paysan/The Farmer’s Voice and agricultural information extension work • in Cameroon: Ms Marie Pauline Voufo and Aude Ehlinger, Cameroon • Role of media in bridging the distance between lab and farm: Mr Sunil Kumar Singh, USP, Fiji • Farm radio – a trigger for demand-driven extension services in Malawi: Mr Rex Chapota, AFRRI, Malawi • Knowledge, networking and diversity – opportunities for agricultural journalism in Africa: Mr David Mowbray, BBC World Service Trust, UK 46 Posters • Innovative approaches for improving access to agricultural information – cases and applications: Dr O. I. Oladele, University of Botswana • Obstacles to the use of media in extension and learning in the rural set-up: Mr Charles Oduor Ogada, Ugunja Community Resource Centre, Kenya • The role of media in disseminating sustainable farming practices to small-scale farmers in Kenya: Mr John Cheburet, Radio Manager, The Organic Farmer, Kenya 11:30–12:30 Panel discussion 12:30–14:00 Lunch Session 3 continued: MEDIA AND ARD ISSUES (parallel sessions) Parallel session: 1. Media and climate change 2. Media and gender equality 3. Media funding in ARD 4. Media and arid zones Moderator Dr John Fitzsimons, UoG, Canada Ms Oumy Ndiaye, CTA Ms Jacqueline Sluijs, KIT, the Netherlands Mr Rabah Lahmar, CIRAD, Burkina Faso 14:00–14:40 Presentations Presentations Presentations Presentations 14:40–15:30 Discussion Discussion Discussion Discussion 15:30–15:50 Coffee break Coffee break Coffee break Coffee break Parallel session 1: MEDIA AND CLIMATE CHANGE Moderator: Dr John Fitzsimons (University of Guelph, Canada) 14:00–14:40 Oral presentations • The Climate Change Media Partnership: Mr Parkie Mbozi, PANOS, Zambia • Climate change and the media in the Pacific: Mr Samisoni Pareti, Islands Business International, Fiji • The contribution of community radio to understanding the impact of climate change on agriculture in Koutiala, Mali: Mr Moctar Niantigui Coulibaly, Alliance des Radios Communautaires, Mali • Radio scriptwriting competitions promote learning for African broadcasters on topics of relevance to smallholder farmers: Ms Blythe McKay, Farm Radio International, Canada Posters • Challenges and opportunities of reporting and communicating agricultural and rural issues: Mr Risdel Kasasira, Uganda 14:40–15:30 Panel discussion 15:30–15:50 Coffee break Parallel session 2: MEDIA AND GENDER EQUALITY Moderator: Ms Oumy Ndiaye, CTA, The Netherlands 14:00–14:40 Oral presentations • Promoting gender equality in ARD through information and communication technologies: a myth or reality in Botswana? Dr Bantu Morolong, University of Botswana, Botswana • Agricultural and rural development in the Pacific – connecting gender equality and the media: Ms Bernadette Masianini, Fiji • Organic farming, climate change literacy and local food needs – what role for media? Ms Dorienne Rowan Campbell, Networked Intelligence, Jamaica Posters • Gender principles in the media in Guinea: Ms Mama Adama Keita, Radio Nationale, Guinea • The Multi Media Resource Kit: Ms Melanie Hughes, Protégé QV, Cameroon 14:40–15:30 Panel discussion 15:30–15:50 Coffee break 47 Parallel session 3: MEDIA FUNDING IN ARD Moderator: Ms Jacqueline Sluijs, Royal Tropical Institute (KIT), The Netherlands 14:00–14:40 Oral presentations • Is closer cooperation the answer to the financial problems of ACP media houses? Mr Hans Determeyer, Free Voice Programme Manager Media Finance, the Netherlands • Media funding in the Pacific: Mrs. Ruci Mafi, SPC, Fiji • Funding for media and ARD: Mr Michael Waigwa, Cooperative Insurance Company, Kenya • Agriculture, women and the media – critical investments: Ms Cece Fadope, International Women’s Media Foundation, USA Posters • Key trends in funding the role of media in agricultural and rural development: Dr Helen Hambly Odame, University of Guelph, Canada 14:40–15:30 Panel discussion 15:30–15:50 Coffee break Parallel session 4: MEDIA AND ARID AND SEMI-ARID ZONES Moderator: Mr Rabah Lahmar, CIRAD, France 14:00–14:50 Oral presentations  ote: In this session the presentation titles reflect the dryland scientists’ area of research. N The round table discussion in this session focused on how to strengthen the role of media in drylands research. • Study and analysis of the impacts of agricultural holdings and livestock farms located around protected areas: the case of the “W” Park of Niger Republic: Ms Teresa Fernandes Pereira da Veiga Tavares, Niger • Taking stock of the rehabilitation of degraded soils in the Sahelian dry regions using the zaï technology (Burkina-Faso, Mali, Niger): Ms Delphine Droux, France • An economic analysis of the effect of variety traits on the adoption of improved pigeon pea varieties in Kenya’s drylands – a case study of Taita District: Ms Zipora Otieno, Kenya • An analysis of farmer groups in conservation agriculture in dryland areas of Malawi: Chinguluwe EPA in Salima and Nkomba Model Village in Bazale EPA, Balaka District: Mr Mavuto Mdulamizu, Malawi 14:50–15:30 Panel discussion 15:30–15:50 Coffee break Session 4: COMMUNICATION BETWEEN MEDIA AND OTHER ARD PLAYERS (plenary session) 48 Moderator: Mr Phil Malone, Countrywise Communications, UK Discussant: Dr Kerry Albright, DFID, UK 15:50–16:20 Oral presentation • Partnership between agricultural and natural resource management training and rural radio in the southern and south-east regions of Senegal: Mr Madior Fall, USAID WULA NAFAA-Senegal • Role of radio in agricultural development in the Pacific: Ms Rita Narayan, Radio Producer, Regional Media Centre, SPC, Fiji • Surfacing the strengths of local content through participatory communication: Mr Charles Dhewa, Managing Consultant, Knowledge Transfer Africa, Zimbabwe Posters • Innovative farmer advisory services using ICT: Mr Francois Stepman, FARA, Ghana • Bridging the gap – WRENmedia’s approach to supporting better science reporting by journalists and building partnerships between media and the agricultural research community: Ms Susanna Thorp, WRENmedia, UK 16:20–17:10 Panel discussion 17:10–18:00 POSTER SESSION (ALL PARTICIPANTS) Wednesday 14 October 2009 Session 5: CONTRIBUTION OF THE MEDIA TO AGRICULTURAL POLICY, PROGRAMMING AND KNOWLEDGE MANAGEMENT (plenary session) Moderator: Ms Helene Michaud, BARN, the Netherlands Discussant: Dr Abibtou Diop-Boare, CIRES, Université Abidjan, Côte d’Ivoire 9:00–09:40 Oral presentations • The SIST tool and access to information for journalists working in the agricultural and rural sector: Mr Helmer Thierry, CIRAD, France • Mwana Alirenji (food self-sufficient) radio magazine turns Malawian farmers into researchers, innovators and self-sufficient food producers: Mr Gladson Elemiya Makowa, Story Workshop, Malawi • Highway Africa: Dr Chris Kabwato, Rhodes University, South Africa Posters • The valuation of broadcast radio in rural development – a question of transaction costs: Mr Chris Yordy, Canada • Key capacities for community radio: Mr Oumar Seck N’diaye, AMARC-Africa, Senegal • Building university capacity for media and rural development: Professor Benedict Mongula and Ms Langa Sarakikya, University of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania 09:40–10:30 Panel discussion 10:30–11:00 Coffee break 11:00–12:00 Set-up for the special broadcast TV (only for participants involved in TV session) Sessions 6 and 7 Session 6 : Poster Session Session 7: TV programme “Media and agriculture: a marriage of necessity?” 12:00–13:30 Francophone group Anglophone group 12:30–14:00 Lunch 14:00–15:45 Anglophone group 16:30 Departure from Bedford Hotel to Palais des Colonies Francophone group 49 Session 8: CTA’S 25TH ANNIVERSARY CEREMONY 18:00–21:30 CTA’s 25th Anniversary Ceremony and CTA Media Awards 2009 Thursday 15 October 2009 Session 9: INSTITUTIONAL ENVIRONMENT OF MEDIA: BUILDING THE CAPACITY OF MEDIA IN AGRICULTURAL AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT (plenary session) Moderator: Mr Stephen Hazelman, SPC, Fiji Discussant: Professor Chris Kamlongera, University of Malawi 9:00–9:40 Oral presentations • The African Media Development Initiative: Mr David Mowbray, BBC World Service Trust, UK • Media training in the Caribbean: Dr Maria Protz, CARIMAC, Jamaica • IAALD – capacity-building for linking libraries and media partners: Mr Joel Sam, INSTI and IAALD, Ghana • Capacity-building and knowledge sharing through community radio: Dr Marcelo Solervicens, AMARC, Canada • Capacity-building in the Caribbean: Dr Arlington Chesney and Mrs Diana Francis, Caribbean agricultural research and development institute and IICA, Trinidad and Tobago Posters • Challenges in agriculture and development – reporting in Malawi: Mr Levi Zeleza Manda, University of Malawi, Malawi 9:40–10:20 Panel discussion 10:20–10:40 Coffee break Session 10: MEDIA, EMERGING NEW MEDIA SERVICE AND ICTS (plenary session) Moderator: Dr Hansjörg Neun, Director, CTA, The Netherlands Discussant: Mrs Oumy Ndiaye, CTA, The Netherlands 10:40–11:20 Oral presentations • ICTs and rural communities: Mr Souleymane Ouattara, JADE, Burkina Faso • The use of web 2.0 tools for sustainable agriculture: a case of small-scale farmers in Uganda: Ms Maureen Agena, WOUGNET, Uganda • Linking radio with ICTs to enhance interaction and “radio on demand”: Ms Margaret Nana Kingamkono, African Farm Radio Research Initiative, Tanzania • Connecting rural Africa using mobile devices: Mr Dion Jerling, Connect Africa Service, South Africa 50 • New communication and information technologies in the agricultural sector in Haiti: M. Talot Bertrand, MICT, Haïti Posters • Information, resources, multidisciplinary and media environment for agricultural development in Tanzania: Mr Jabir Jabir, Sokoine National Agricultural Library, Tanzania • Nakaseke Telecentre Uganda: Mr Peter Balaba, Nakaseke Telecentre, Uganda 11:20–12:00 Panel discussion Session 11: WORKING GROUPS ON MEDIA – WORKING TOGETHER FOR ACTION AND RECOMMENDATIONS 12:00–13:00 Radio (Moderator: Rex Chapota, AFRRI, Malawi) Television and video (Moderator: Riccardo del Castello, FAO, Italy) Print media (Moderator: Howard Williams, Union of Environmental Journalists, Sierra Leone) Media and rural communities (Moderator: José Felipe Fonseca, CTA, The Netherlands) 13:00–1400 Lunch 14:00–15:30 Radio Television and video Print media Media and rural communities 15:30–16:00 Coffee break 16:00–18:00 Radio Television and video Print media Media and rural communities Session 12: CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS – CLOSING CEREMONY AND PRESS CONFERENCE 18:00–18:45 Conclusions and recommendations Closing ceremony 18:45–19:30 Press conference 19:00 Refreshment Friday 16 October 2009 9:00–10:30 Departure of participants Visits to institutions in Brussels (for those leaving on Friday evening or Saturday) 51 6.2 List of participants Last name First name Organisation / address Telephone E-mail Abdoulaye Ibbo Daddy Director Les Echos du Sahel Villa 4012 – Cité 105 Logements, Niamey Niger +22 720 743 217 ibbo_daddy@yahoo.com Adolph Serge Accountant CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 123 adolph@cta.int Agena Maureen Information Officer WOUGNET PO BOX 4411 Plot 55, Kenneth Dale, Kamwokya Uganda +256 782 807 709 560 414 532 035 info@wougnet.org Daniel Aghan National Co-ordinator Media for Environment, Science, Health and Agriculture (MESHA) PO Box 1285, 0100 Nairobi, South Gate Centre, South B, Mukoma Road Kenya +254 728 27 99 66 meshakenya@yahoo.com daghan@handicap-international.or.ke Albright Kerry Research Communication +44 20 7023 0035 Manager Research Uptake Team DFID Research & Evidence Division Department for International Development 1 Palace Street, London SW1E 5HE United Kingdom K-Albright@dfid.gov.uk Amédé Louis General Co-ordinator +22 520 370 666 Réseau des Journalistes de l’Afrique de l’Ouest et du Centre pour l’Agriculture (REJAOCA) 01 BP 1807, Abidjan Côte d’Ivoire louisamede@yahoo.fr Andriessen Wim DGIS-Wageningen UR Partnership Wageningen UR PO Box 88, 6700 AB, Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 486 810 wim.andriesse@wur.nl Audigier Ariane Consultant Development Communication Projects 6, Rue Rampal, 75109 Paris France +33 6 60647756 aaudigier02@yahoo.fr Masese Azael Winsley Journalist / Correspondent/ Writer G The standard group Kisumu Kenya +254 734 549 140 wmasese@eastandard.net 52 Bafana Busani Media Consultant Food, Agriculture and Natural Resources Policy Analysis Network 64961 Tshabalala, Bulawayo Zimbabwe +263 912 755 553 busani.bafana@gmail.com bafana@netconnect.co.zw Balaba Peter Manager Nakaseke Telecentre Uganda +256 782 902 991 balapet2001@yahoo.com Baluku Rev. Nason Chairman SATNET Board PO Box 346, Kasese Uganda +256 782 309 778 nasoncanon@yahoo.com Barber Ian Head of Unit Information & Communication European Commission DG DEV/SC 153-39 European Commission, 1049 Brussels Belgium Barro Albert Agricultural machinist / Soil scientist INERA/SARIA Programme GRNSP BP 10 Koudougou Burkina Faso +22 50 44 65 10 altbarro@yahoo.fr Barry Abdoulaye Journalist RTS BP 1765, Triangle Sud Dakar Senegal +221 33 849 12 21 bary_sn@yahoo.fr Bel Sarah Communications Officer Microinsurance Innovation Facility, International Labour Organization 4, route des Morillons, CH-1211 Genève 22 Switzerland +41 22 799 82 97 Bengaly Oudou Financial Officer – +223 21 622 450 IT Support Technician KENETIC4DEV TIC pour le développement dans le Kenedougou BP 215 Mali oudoubeny@yahoo.fr Bertrand Talot Head – Planning and Resource Mobilisation Direction de la Protection Civile (DPC) Ministère de l’Intérieur et des Collectivités Territoriales (MICT) 310, Route de Bourdon, Port-Au-Prince Haïti +50 937 335 953 talotbertrand@yahoo.fr Director Radio Sauti ya Mkaaji 53, avenue LAMBA , Kasongo DRC +243 81 31 36 043 sautiyamkaaji@yahoo.fr or modesteshabani@yahoo.fr Shabani bin Sweni Modeste bel@ilo.org 53 Blenman Rose Senior Project/ Communications Officer CARICOM Secretariat PO Box 10-1089, Lot 18, Brickdam, Stabroek, Georgetown Guyana Boto Isolina Head of CTA Brussels Office +32 2 513 74 36 Rue Montoyer 39, Brussels Belgium boto@cta.int Boulc’h Stéphane Publication Officer – Studies officer COTA 7 rue de la révolution B – 1000 Brussels Belgium +32 2 250 38 36 stephane.boulch@cota.be rblenman@caricom.org +32 2 218 18 96 Boutin Jean Fritz Executive board of CTA c/o Secretary to the Executive Board, CTA +5 092 463 202 jfritzb@hotmail.com Burguet Jean-Claude Head Administration, Budget and Human Resources Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 125 burguet@cta.int Chapota Rex National Research Co-ordinator AFRRI PO Box 30268 Lilongwe 3 Malawi +265 09 99 899 489 rex@wuscmw.org Executive Director Caribbean Agricultural Research and Development Institute PO Bag 212, University Campus, St Augustine Trinidad and Tobago +1 868 6451205/7 Chevouline Thilda Intern Communication Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 186 Clarke Kevin Writer/Producer/Presenter +18 769 291 269 Jamaica Information Service Direct line – Radio Department. +1 876 484 9721 Jamaica Information Service, 58A Half-Way-Tree Road, Kingston 10 Jamaica kclarke@jis.gov.jm koclarke@gmail.com Clavel Daniele AIDA project co-ordinator +33 4 67 61 59 70 CIRAD-BIOS (Bat 1, bureau 34) TA A-08/01, Av Agropolis 34398 Montpellier cédex 5 France daniele.clavel@cirad.fr Chesney 54 +592 222 0001/75 Dr Arlington +265 01 771 823 executive@cardi.org +1 868645-3573 chevouline@cta.int Coulibaly Moctar Niantigui Executive Director Alliance des Radios Communautaires du Mali Djelibougou Doumanzana Rue 251 Porte 370 BP E 1539 Bamako Mali +223 76 23 69 94 radioscommunautairesdumali@yahoo.fr Dardagan Colleen Journalist The Mercury Newspaper PO Box 47549, Greyville 4023, KwaZulu-Natal South Africa +27 31 08216 colleen.dardagan@inl. co.za de Sousa Professor Raul Bruno Executive Board of CTA c/o Secretary to the Executive Board, CTA +351 213 653 427 brunosousa@isa.utl.pt Del Castello Riccardo Communication Officer FAO, Research and Extension Division Via delle terme, Rome Italy +39 657 054 051 riccardo.delcastello@fao. org Determeyer J. E. J. (Hans) Programme Manager – Media Finance Free Voice Sumatralaan 45, Hilversum The Netherlands +31 356 250 110 hans.determeyer@antenna.nl Dhewa Charles Knowledge Transfer Africa 30 Shortson, Derbyshire Waterfalls, Harare Zimbabwe +263 4 759695 dhewac@yahoo.co.uk Diagne Falilou Chairman Union des Groupements Paysans de Meckhe (UGPM) BP 43 Meckhe Senegal +221 33 955 51 13 ugpm@sentoo.sn Touré Diallo Haby Director and Programme Officer Radio Communautaire Bèlèkan BP 133A Kati Immeuble Sériba Sidibé Noumorila Mali +223 21 27 28 84 Dieye Papa Oumar Head of Communication and Information Centre Regional AGRHYMET, CILSS, PO Box 11011, Niamey Niger +22 793 930 626 +227 203 153 016 habiba_dl@yahoo.fr +223 66 76 42 75 P.Dieye@agrhymet.ne admin@agrhymet.ne Diop-Boaré Abibatou Associate Director CIRES, Université Abidjan 08 BP 1295, Abidjan Côte d’Ivoire adiopboare@yahoo.fr Doudet Head of Department +31 317 467 127 Information Products and Dissemination Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands doudet@cta.int Thierry 55 56 Droux Delphine AIDA project Université de Paris 12, CIRAD /INERA 01 square Boileau 78150 Le Chesnay France +33 1 67 97 34 20 Ebeda Xavier Consultant Glasshouse 25 rue Dauphine, 75006 Paris France +33 6 16960597 Ehlinger Aude Partnerships officer (Burkina Faso et Cameroon) SOS Faim Luxembourg 88, rue Victor Hugo, L-4141 Esch/Alzette Luxembourg +352 49 09 96 24 aude.ehlinger@sosfaim. org Fadope Cece Africa Program Manager International Women’s Media Foundation 1625 K Street NW, Suite 1275 Washington, DC 20006 USA +1 202 567 2602 cfadope@iwmf.org Fall Madior Communication Officer USAID WULA NAFAASenegal BP 45 Tambacounda Senegal +221 33 939 80 16 salabigue@hotmail.com Faye Ibrahima Lissa Publication Director www.pressafrik.com Sicap Liberté 6 no. 8117 Dakar BP 30018 Senegal +221 33 867 92 83 ilf@pressafrik.com Fitzsimons Dr John Professor School of Environmental Design & Rural Development, Ontario Agricultural College University of Guelph 1 Stone Road, Guelph, Ontario, N1G 2W1 Canada +1 519 824 4120 jfitz@uoguelph.ca Fonseca José Filipe Senior Programme Co-ordinator Communication Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 133 fonseca@cta.int Francis Judith Senior Programme Co-ordinator Planning and Strategic Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 190 francis@cta.int delphine.droux@laposte. net Francis Diana Regional specialist, Policy and Trade NegotiationsCaribbean region IICA 3 Herbert Street Newtown, Port of Spain Trinidad and Tobago +1 868 284 4403 diana.Francis@iica.int Goutier Hegel Head Chef ACP – Press communication Le Courrier 45 rue de Trèves, 1040 Brussels Belgium +3 222 374 392 hgoutier@acp-eucourier. info Hackshaw Karen Programme Co-ordinator +31 317 467 157 Information Products and Dissemination Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands hackshaw@cta.int Hailu Michael Head of Information Services, Communication and Publication CGIAR Ethiopia M.Hailu@cgiar.org Hamidou Djibo AIDA project Centre Regional AGRHYMET, CILSS, PO Box 11011, Niamey Niger hdjibo@agrhymet.ne Hanschke Oliver Public Awareness Networks and Knowledge Management for Rural Development Division 45 – Agriculture, Fisheries and Food Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ) GmbH PO Box 5180 65726 Eschborn Germany +49 6196 79 3293 Oliver.Hanschke@gtz.de Hazelman Stephen Co-ordinator SPC Private Mail Bag, Suva Fiji Islands +6 793 370 733 stephenh@spc.int Helmer Thierry Head of SIST project CIRAD/DSI TA 383/05 Avenue Agropolis 34398 Montpellier Cedex 5 France +33 4 67 61 44 10 thierry.helmer@cirad.fr Hughes Melanie Volonteer PROTEGE QV 7488 avenue de l’épée Montreal, Quebec H3N 2E5 Canada +1 514 475 3394 melhugs@gmail.com 57 58 Jabir Jabir A. Principal Library Assistant Sokoine National Agricultural Library PO Box 3217 Morogoro Tanzania +255 773 718 725 jjjbjaj@yahoo.com Jama Charles Communications Officer Common Fund for Commodities Stadhouderskade 55 1072 AB, Amsterdam The Netherlands +31 20 575 49 56 Charles.Jama@commonfund.org Jean Ignatius Representative IICA Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture PO Box 10-089 Lot 18, Brickdam, Strabroek – Georgetown Guyana +592 2 268 347 +592 2 268 835 ignatius.jean@iica.int Jerling Dion Co-ordinator Connect Africa Services Postnet Suite 96, Private Bag X9, Melville, 2109 Johannesburg South Africa +27 82 487 8354 (South Africa) +260 97 686 0113 (Zambia) +27 82 487 8354 dion@connectafrica.net melanie.malema@connectafrica.net Johnrose Johnson Communications officer Caribbean Tourism Organization One Financial Place, Collymore Rock, St Michael Barbados +1 246 427 5242 jjohnrose@caribtourism. com Kaah Aaron Yancho Producer/Journalist Radio Oku PO Box 214 Bamenda Cameroon +23 799 280 196 aaronkah@yahoo.co.uk Kabwato Chris Director Highway Africa Rhodes University, Grahamstown South Africa +27 8 25829534 c.kabwato@ru.ac.za Kamlongera Chris Director SADC Centre for Communication and Development Malawi Karamagi Ednah Executive Director BROSDI PO Box 26970 Kampala Uganda +256 772 506 227 comdev@fanr-sadc.co.zw +256 392 963 527 ednahkaramagi@brosdi. or.ug Kasasira Risdel Editor Ultimate Media Consult PO Box 36665 Kampala Uganda +25772627676 +256 751 627 676 +256 782 308 901 risdel.kasasira@gmail.com kasasira@ultimatemediaconsult.com Kayula Frank Regional Programme Director PANOS Southern Africa PO Box 39163, Lusaka Zambia +260 211 263 258 frank@panos.org.zm fmkayula@yahoo.co.uk Kazadi Carine Young Professional Officer CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 142 kazadi@cta.int Kebede Yodit Junior Consultant Planning and Strategic Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 145 kebede@cta.int Keita Mama Adama Journalist Radio Nationale BP 4334, Conakry Guinea +224 60 28 14 12 / 64 54 31 87 ananconakry@yahoo.fr Khadar Ibrahim Head of Department Planning and Strategic Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 159 khadar@cta.int Kindembe Kanza Tito Editor C retro magazine 39 avenue Houba de Strooper 1020 Brussels Belgium +32 488 602 782 contact@c-retro-actuel.net Kingamkono Margaret Nana African Farm Radio Research Initiative PO Box 105110 Kiko Avenue, Mikocheni, Plot no. 247/248 Dar es Salaam Tanzania +255 784 695 028 +255 222 701 840 margaret.kingamkono@ afrri.net Kleinbussink Debbie Senior Administrative Assistant CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 150 kleinbussink@cta.int KodaTraoré Aboubacar Programme Co-ordinator Communication Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 138 koda@cta.int Kojane Mogogi Director of Agricultural Information and Public Relations Ministry of Agriculture P/Bag 003 Gaborone Botswana +2 673 689 475 mkojane@gov.bw Project Leader ANOPACI 01 BP 8089 Abidjan 01 Côte d’Ivoire +2 550 782 928 Kouao Sylvain 59 skouao@gmail.com 60 Lahmar Rabah KASSA project co-ordinator CIRAD, Départment Cultures Annuelles, Programme Gestion des Ecosystèmes Cultivés Avenue Agropolis, FR-34398, Monpellier Cedex 5 France +33 4 6761 5641 LalanneDevlin Laurence Consultant WRENmedia 99 High Street, Wheatley, Oxford OX33 1XP United Kingdom +44 18 65 87 40 03 laurence@lalanne.fsbusiness.co.uk Lie Rico Assistant Professor Wageningen UR Department of Communication Science – Communication and Innovation Studies Group PO Box 8130, 6700 EW, Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 482 599 Mafi Ruci Pacific Way Reporter Regional Media Centre SPC 3 Luke Street Nabua, Suva Fiji Islands Makgabo Tumi Journalist and Consultant African Broadcasting and Media PO Box 307, Bromhof, 2154 South Africa +27 82 859 9190 Makowa Gladson Elemiya Manager Media and Communications Story Workshop Private Bag 266 Blantyre Malawi +265 888 208 130 gladson@africa-online.net +265 1 821 335/657 Malone Phil Director Countrywise Communications 103 Main Road, Wilby, Northants NN8 2UB United Kingdom +441 933 272 400 media@countrywise.com Manda Levi Zeleza University of Malawi P/Bag 303 Chichiri Blantyre 3 Malawi +2 659 991 156 lmanda@poly.ac.mw Mandler Andreas Consultant 50122 Florence Italy +393 346 194 460 andreas.mandler@googlemail.com Masianini Bernadette Agricultural Information Officer SPC/EU Development of Sustainable Agriculture in the Pacific Fiji Islands +31 20 5688259 berni@connect.com.fj rabah.lahmar@cirad.fr Rico.Lie@wur.nl rucim@spc.int ronniewhit@wol.co.za Mbozi Parkie Executive Director PANOS Southern Africa PO Box 39163, Lusaka Zambia +260 21 1 263258 +16 137 613 652 McKay Blythe Development Communication Co-ordinator Farm Radio International 1404 Scott Street, Ottawa, Ontario Canada Mdulamizu Mavuto AIDA project parkie@panos.org.zm +260 978 506 945 bmckay@farmradio.org mavutomdula@yahoo.com Université du Malawi Malawi Michaud Hélène Africa Producer senior BARN PO Box 222, Hilversum The Netherlands +31356724272 Helene.Michaud@rnw.nl Mikenga Samuel Programme Co-ordinator Communication Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 101 mikenga@cta.int MinderhoudJones Marilyn Consultant Benedendorpseweg 1267, 6862 WH, Oosterbeek The Netherlands +31263391126 marilynminderhoud@ yahoo.co.uk Mitchell Damion Journalist Jamaica Gleaner Newspaper 7 North Street, Kingston Jamaica +1 876 773 7474 +31 652 053 495 mitchell.damion@gmail. com damion.mitchell@gleanerjm.com Mongula Benedict Professor Institute of Development Studies, University of Dar es Salaam PO Box 35169, Dar es Salaam Tanzania Fax: +255 22 2410078. mongula@uccmail.co.tz Morant Philippe Technical Advisor of CEO Centre Régional AGRHYMET PO Box 11011, Niamey Niger +227 20 31 53 16 (poste 265) morant@cirad.fr Morolong Dr Bantu University of Botswana Private Bag UB 00707 Gaborone Botswana morolongbl@mopipi.ub.bw Mowbray David Director Africa +442 075 572 702 BBC World Service Trust 301 NE Bush House, The Strand, London WC2B 4PH United Kingdom david.mowbray@bbc.co.uk Consultant +31 30 2443005 Rua Design Laan van Nieuw Guinea 55 3531 JC, Utrecht The Netherlands tony@ruadesign.org Murray Tony 61 Narayan Rita Radio Producer +679 3370 733 ext ritan@spc.int Regional Media Centre 358 SPC Private Mail Bag, Suva, Fiji 3 Luke St, Nabua, Suva Fiji Islands Ndiaye Oumy Head of Department Communication Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 140 ndiaye@cta.int N’diaye Oumar Seck Chairman of AMARC Africa and Vice Chairman of AMARC International Scat Urbam lot 68 appartement B2 – Dakar Senegal +221 77 6779090 +221 77 5531978 oumar_seckndiaye@ yahoo.fr Neun Dr Hansjörg Director CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 131 neun@cta.int Hambly Professor Helen Associate Professor School of Environmental Design & Rural Development Capacity Development and Extension, University of Guelph, Room 119 Landscape Architecture, Ontario Canada +1 519 824 41 20 hhambly@uoguelph.ca Odutola Kole Instructor Yoruba, African & Asian Languages and Literature Dept University of Florida, Gainesville 2601 NW 23rd Blvd. #173 Gainesville, FL 32605 USA 13 522 732 959 Odutola@scils.rutgers.edu Ogada Charles Oduor Programme Co-ordinator Ugunja Community Resource Centre PO Box 330 – 40606, Ugunja Kenya +225 22 41 65 4 +225 22 41 54 83 charlesogada@swift-mail. com Oladele Professor O.I. Professor Education and Extension Botswana College of Agriculture University of Botswana P/Bag 0027 Gaborone Botswana +26 774 658 247 oladele20002001@yahoo. com Paul Intern Communication Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 185 62 Onana +2 673 928 753 onana@cta.int Ong’an’a Dr Obiero Director Lake Victoria Center for Research and Development (OSIENALA Friends of Lake Victoria) Dunga Beach – Kisumu PO Box 4580 – 40103 Kisumu Kenya +254 572 023 487 goganda@yahoo.co.ke Onyango James Executive director KAIPPG PO Box 2448 Kakamega 50100 Kenya +254 56 641004 kaippg@africaonline.co.ke Otiendo Zipora Awuor AIDA project University of Nairobi, Faculty of Agriculture, Department Agricultural Economics PO BOX 19301-40113 Kisumu Kenya +254 721 848 785 ziplindah@yahoo.com Otindo Violet KBC-CNN Award Winner K24 Television 3rd Floor, Longonot Place, Kijabe Street Nairobi 00100 Kenya +254 2124800/1/2 violet.otindo@K24.co.ke Ouangraoua Boukari Journalist/Development Communicator/Trainer Inades Formation Burkina 01 BP 1022 Avenue Conseil De l’Entente Secteur 9 Ouagadougou Burkina Faso +226 50 38 28 29 ouaboukari@yahoo.fr Ouattara Fatouma Sophie Reporter/Journalist Edition Sidwaya 01BP 5O7, Ouagadougou 01 Burkina Faso +2 270 690 870 Sofifa2@yahoo.fr Ouattara Souleymane Journalist Jade Productions 01 BP 6624 Ouagadougou Burkina Faso Ouédraogo Roukiattou Reporter Burkina – NTIC 09 BP 1170, Ouagadougou 09 Burkina Faso +226 76 64 97 42 +226 50 38 82 74 roukiattou@yahoo.fr Pareti Samisoni Senior Writer Islands Business International PO Box 12718, Suva Fiji Islands +6 799 930 873 paretis@gmail.com Executive Director Farm Radio International 1404 Scott Street, Ottawa, Ontario Canada +16 137 613 652 Perkins Kevin souattara@fasonet.bf 63 kperkins@farmradio.org 64 PompigneMognard Nicolas Secretary General African Press Organization MCM – 1, rue du Grand Chêne – Case 574, 1001 Lausanne Switzerland +41 22 534 96 97 sg@apo-opa.org Protz Maria Co-ordinator for the Caribbean Communication for Sustainable Development Initiative CARIMAC Caribbean Box 291 St Anns Bay Jamaica +18 768 785 326 mariaprotz@cwjamaica. com Raghubir Nazima Journalist TV/CTA Video, Guyana Press Association, PRIME NEWS Inc. 302 Church Street, Queenstown, Georgetown Guyana +5 922 317 188 +5 922 371 787 nazimaraghubir@gmail. com Rambaldi Giacomo Senior Programme Co-ordinator Communication Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 174 rambaldi@cta.int Rampersad Dr Krishendaye Media and Literary Consultant 20 Bedaissie Street, St Augustine South, Trinidad and Tobago +18 683 909 367 +18 687 525 067 krislit2@gmail.com kriscivica@yahoo.com Richards Peter Journalist CMC – Caribbean, Radio TV Internet 28 Turquoise Drive, Diamond Vale, Diego Martin Trinidad and Tobago +1 868 764 5745 stlucian@tstt.net.tt Rodgers Josephine Director Countrywise Communications 103 Main Road, Wilby, Northants NN8 2UB United Kingdom +441 933 272 400 media@countrywise.com Rodriguez Merche Assistant +31 317 467 163 rodriguez@cta.int +12 126 559 525 +1610144 dorienne.rowancampbell@ gmail.com Communication Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands RowanCampbell Dorienne Consultant/organic farmer Networked Intelligence for Development 552 Westminster Ave., Ottawa, Ontario K2A 2V3 Canada Ruquet Robin Consultant Glasshouse 25 rue Dauphine, 75006 Paris France +33 6 16960597 robin@glasshouse.fr Salm Mundie Co-ordinator and Editor, Farming Matters LEISA Magazine, ILEIA PO Box 2067, 3800 CB, Amersfoort The Netherlands +31 33 467 3878 m.salm@ileia.nl Sam Joel GAINS Co-ordinator CSIR/INSTI PO Box M 32, Accra Ghana +233 21 76 48 22 egy28@yahoo.co.uk Sanou Issouf Programme Co-ordinator Fédération Nationale des Organisations Paysannes (FENOP) 09 BP 977 – Ouagadougou 09 Burkina Faso +226 76 60 90 52 sissoufou1@yahoo.fr Sarakikya Langa Professor Institute of Development Studies, University of Dar es Salaam PO Box 35169, Dar es Salaam Tanzania Fax: +255 22 2410078 langasarakikya@googlemail.com Schaap Mirjam Web-supported Communication and Learning Wageningen UR PO Box 88, 6700 AB, Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 481 408 mirjam.schaap@wur.nl Singh Ranbeer Journalist Fiji Television Limited PO Box 5511, Lautoka Fiji Islands +6 796 665 444 +6 799 990 233 rsingh@fijitv.com.fj ranbeer_singh@hotmail. com Singh Sunil Kumar Course Development Assistant The University of the South Pacific Private Mail Bag Laucala Bay Road Suva Fiji Islands +6 799 045 758 singh_su@usp.ac.fj Sluijs Jacqueline Sociologist KIT Postbus 95001 1090 HA, Amsterdam The Netherlands +31 20 5688259 j.sluijs@kit.nl Solervicens Marcelo Secretary General AMARC 705 Bourget, suite 100, H4C 2M6 Montréal (Quebec) Canada secgen@si.amarc.org 65 66 de Sousa Raul Bruno Executive Board c/o Secretary to the Executive Board, CTA +351 21365 3427 brunosousa@isa.utl.pt Songa Dr Wilson A. Chairman of CTA Executive Board c/o Secretary to the Executive Board, CTA +254 202 718 870 wsonga@africaonline. co.ke Springer Dr Eugenia Director ES Productions 98 Eastern Main Road, Suite #1, Tunapuna Trinidad and Tobago +868 663 6009 dreugenia.springer@ gmail.com Stepman François Communications and +233 21 772823 Public Awareness Specialist FARA PMB CT 173 Cantonments, Accra Forum for Agricultural Research in Africa, Ghana fstepman@fara-africa.org Tadegnon Noel Kokou Journalist De Reuters S/C Maison de la Presse Tokoin Trésor, Lomé 01 BP 2539 Togo +228 905 38 35 +228 225 50 03 +228 225 03 50 tadenoe@yahoo.fr Talatala Hon. Blondeau Talatala Member of Parliament of Cameroon – Co-ordinator of UNGC-REPADER BP 3410 Yaoundé Cameroon +237 994 84 48 btalatala@yahoo.com Tavares Teresa Fernandes Pereira da Veiga AIDA project Centre Regional AGRHYMET, CILSS, PO Box 11011, Niamey Niger Teyssier Laurent Consultant Glasshouse 25 rue Dauphine, 75006 Paris France Thomas Larry Co-ordinator Regional Media Centre SPC 3 Luke Street, Nabua, Suva Fiji Islands Thorp Susanna Director WRENmedia Gulls Green, Fressingfield, Eye, Suffolk IP21 5SA United Kingdom +441 379 586 787 s.thorp@wrenmedia.co.uk Tollens Professor Eric Executive Board of CTA c/o Secretary to the Executive Board, CTA +32 16321616/ 1614 eric.tollens@biw.kuleuven. be tavarest_1@yahoo.com.br +33 6 16960597 larryt@spc.int Treinen Sophie Knowledge Management Officer FAO Knowledge Exchange and Capacity-building Division Viale delle Terme di Caracalla, 00153 Rome, Italy Room A111 int Italy +39 06 5705 4297 Sophie.Treinen@fao.org Ulakai Viola Journalist Tonga Broadcasting and Television Corporation PO Box 36 Nuku’alofa Kingdom of Tonga +676 23 555 violavlaka@yahoo.com Van Mele Dr Paul Program Leader, Learning & Innovation Systems Africa Rice Center (AfricaRice) 01 BP 2031, Cotonou Benin +229 21 35 01 88 p.vanmele@cgiar.org Van Velden Annelies Programme Manager Voices of Africa Media Foundation Jansweg 42-E, 1011 KN, Haarlem The Netherlands +31 235 428 366 annelies@voamf.org Vos Edwin Vice-chairman of CTA Executive Board c/o Secretary to the Executive Board, CTA +33 603 321 808 edwin.a.vos@gmail.com Vos Dr Janny Business Development Manager Europe CABI Nederland Kastanjelaan 5 , 3833 AN, Leusden The Netherlands +31 33 432 1031 j.vos@cabi.org Vugayabagabo André Senior Programme Co-ordinator Communication Services Department CTA PO Box 380, 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 467 158 vuga@cta.int Waigwa Michael Agricultural Underwriter The Co-operative Insurance Company of Kenya Ltd CIC Plaza, Mara Road, Upper Hill, PO Box 59485-00200, Nairobi Kenya +254 202 823 106 michael.waigwa@cic.co.ke Senior Advisor Communication for Development PANOS London 9 White Lion Street, London N1 9PD United Kingdom +44 20 7239 7603 Warnock Kitty 67 kitty.warnock@panos.org. uk Werner Sandra Journalist Radio Kankan 41 Rue James Ensor, 1070 Anderlecht, Brussels Belgium +32 4 71192333 sandra.werner@vision-s. org Witteveen Loes Professor Van Hall Larenstein, University of Applied Sciences PO Box 411, 6700 AK Wageningen The Netherlands +31 317 486 301 loes.witteveen@wur.nl Journalist C retro magazine 39 avenue Houba de Strooper 1020 Brussels Belgium +32 488 602 782 contact@c-retro-actuel.net YalalaewaBonkele 68 Yoda Françoise Bibiane President Association Pugwisenga 09 BP 359 Ouagadougou 09 Burkina Faso +226 70 10 03 78 frbibiane@gmail.com Yordy Christopher Consultant Community Development Service (Egypt) c/o 1011 Kenning Place Elmira/Ontario/N3B2Z1 Canada +20 19 50 87 456 chris.yordy@gmail.com Zangrond Fenny Adeline Journalist Suriname Newspaper Malebatrumstraat 7-9, Paramaribo Suriname +597 472 823 fennyvd@yahoo.com Zulu Brenda Journalist c/o MISA Zambia PO Box 32295, Plot No. A343 Mandevu, Lusaka Zambia +260 977 891 431 brendazulu2002@gmail. com 6.3 25th Anniversary CTA’s 25th Anniversary Palais des Colonies in Tervuren, Brussels 14 October 2009 18:00–21:30 Programme Official opening ceremony Master of Ceremonies: HE Mrs Marcia Yvette Gilbert-Roberts, Ambassador of Jamaica Speeches Dr Wilson Songa, President of CTA’s Executive Board HE Dr Mrs Brave R. Ndisale, Co-President, ACP Committee of Ambassadors ACP-EC, Ambassador of Malawi to the EU Musical interlude Mr Ola Sohlström, Second Secretary, on behalf of HE M. C. Danielsson, Co-President, EU Committee of Ambassadors ACP-EC, Permanent Representative of the Kingdom of Sweden to the EU Mr Luis Riera Figueras, Director, European Commission DG Development, Environment and Rural Development Musical interlude HE Ambassador Olukorede Willoughby, on behalf of Dr Ibrahim Assane Mayaki, Chief Executive Officer, NEPAD Dr Hansjörg Neun, CTA Director Dinner Testimonials Introduction of the CTA Media Awards 2009 by Mrs Judith Francis, CTA Presentation of Media Awards for Journalism Presentation of Media Awards for Community Communication Projects Vote of thanks by Dr Hansjörg Neun 69 6.4 Media Award Winners Best Journalism Award Best Community Communication Award And the Winners Are… After months of planning, calls for consultants, for nominees, and finally for clarification, the winners of the CTA Journalism and Community Media Awards were announced during CTA’s 25th Anniversary Ceremony Celebration. Out of a total of 105 entries and an eventual shortlist of 14, the final six names were called. Category A: Journalism Journalism published or broadcast through print, radio, TV or online outlets Category B: Community communications process Front (l-r): Modeste Shabani bin Sweni, Gladson Makowa Community-level communication projects (any medium) — 1st prize — Aaron Kaah (Cameroon) Plant a Tree, Save a Bee — 2nd prize — Rev. Nason Baluku (Uganda) Banana wilt campaign — 3rd prize — Modeste Shabani bin Sweni (Democratic Republic of Congo) Sauti ya Mkaaji — 1st prize — Gladson Makowa (Malawi) — 2nd prize — local or community level – raising awareness or creating a debate, sharing important information or contributing to change. Topics included agriculture or related environmental, social, political or economic topics. Category B, Community-level communication projects, sought initiatives that have used participatory communication (through any medium, including face-to-face communication) to strengthen communities’ agriculture or their capacity to manage related issues such as natural resources. Colleen Dardagan (South Africa) The Awards — 3rd prize — First prize in each category: €2,500 and a 2-week opportunity for training, study or research (location and terms to be agreed between CTA and the winner). Rambeer Singh (Fiji Islands) Rev Nason Baluku, Aaron Kaah, Modeste Shabani bin Sweni More about the competition 70 Back (l-r): Ranbeer Singh, Rev Nason Baluku, Colleen Dardagan and Aaron Kaah Winners of the award for journalism (l-r): Rambeer Singh, Gladson Makowa and Colleen Dardagan The competition, managed by Panos London, was open to professional and non-professional journalists, media houses and community-level communication projects from ACP countries. A panel of judges comprising representatives from Africa, Europe, the Caribbean and the Pacific was convened to judge the shortlisted entries. Second prize in each category: €1,500 and a 2-week training, study or research opportunity as above. Third prize in each category: €500 and a 2-week training, study or research opportunity as above. All three winners in both categories also participated in the CTA seminar in Brussels (all costs covered). For Category A, Journalism, the competition looked for journalism that has had an impact at national, The award which was specially designed for the CTA. 6.5 More about the Media Award Winners Winners – Journalism Award Gladson Makowa Colleen Dardagan Ranbeer Singh I was born from a father who was a Field Agriculture Extension Assistant on 10 September 1974 in Lilongwe in a family of seven children, two boys and five girls. I learnt many farming technologies from him. Because I never liked farming, he encouraged me to work hard in class to avoid becoming one of the local farmers. Born on a farm in the Eastern Cape region of South Africa in 1958, I have loved to write since my school days. Married young and with two daughters, it was only in my later years that my dream to become a journalist was finally realised. I was born in Lautoka, the second City in Fiji Islands in 1977. My late father worked for the Civil Aviation Authority of Fiji, at the Nadi International Airport as a communicator, while my mother stayed at home. Both my late father and mother’s parents came to Fiji from Punjab, India in the 1930s. Due to limited places at government secondary schools, I went to Malawi Correspondence Distance Education (MCDE) centre and finished secondary education at Dedza Night Secondary School. I was selected to the University of Malawi, Chancellor College where I did my Bachelor of Education in Humanities from January 1995 to 1999. I worked part-time at the Story Workshop as a researcher and radio drama script writer while still at University from 1997. Having majored in geography (environmental studies, rural development and urban studies) and because of my knowledge of agricultural issues I became an Agricultural Programmes Production Researcher soon after graduating. Ms Pamela Brooke, the American owner of Story Workshop, had registered it as a non-governmental media organisation. With assistance from Pamela, I conceptualised the format of Mwana Alirenji (food selfsufficiency) to make farming easier and more interesting. Ten years ago I was employed as an editor for a tabloid industrial publication, which focused primarily on the manufacturing sectors in KwaZulu-Natal, a province on the eastern seaboard of South Africa. Five years ago I was employed as a business reporter at the 157-year-old newspaper The Mercury, the main morning newspaper in KwaZulu-Natal, headquartered in the port city of Durban. For the past 4 years, one of my specific responsibilities has been the issue of post-apartheid-era land-reform policies and their impact on food security and the economy of the region. I am the second eldest in my family of five: two brothers, one sister and parents. My elder brother is a sports reporter with the Fiji Times, while my sister is a high school teacher. I started my journalism career soon after leaving high school in early 1996, as a cadet sports reporter with Fiji’s Daily Post. I was offered the position after I had met the Editor of the newspaper during a rugby match in Nadi, when he asked me if I would be interested in covering sports events at the weekends. I was offered a fulltime position the following year and I was based at the company head office in Suva, Fiji’s capital city. I was transferred to Lautoka in mid-1998 and remained with the company for a few more months before I received an offer from the Fiji Times for a similar position. I was employed at the Fiji Times for 4 years, covering both sports and news events. I received an employment offer from Fiji Television Limited in 71 2003. I made the jump to TV in March 2003, and have been based at the Lautoka office since then. I am the sole reporter based at the office, and work with two cameramen. Our work involves covering news and current affairs activities for the entire western division of Fiji’s main island, Viti Levu, which comprises one city, five towns and a township. The total population in this division is approximately 250,000. news and current affairs, both local and overseas, outdoor activities such as gardening and going to the beach. I am married. My hobbies include travelling, meeting people, watching sports, Winners – Best Community Media “Plant a Tree, Save a Bee” Aaron Kaah – Cameroon “Plant a Tree, Save a Bee” is a radio programme that encourages fruit and honey tree nurseries, transplanting, conservation and protection. These trees include species such as Acacia, Calliandra, Schefflera, manni croton and other tropical trees such as Prunus africana and shrubs that provide nectar for bees as a means of increasing honey production for the 150,000 inhabitants of the slopes of the Kilum/Ijim mountain forest in Bui Division of north-west Cameroon. The weekly programmes, featuring dramas, debates, spots, roundtable discussions, field interviews, radio quizzes and monthly meetings with farmers’ groups, advocate and promote bee farming in a bid to improve the pollination of food crops, as honey bees are pollinators for many food crops in the area. By effectively integrating honey bees into the various agroforestry schemes in the Oku area, the 72 project has become a live wire for farmers, especially the women and youths who have eagerly involved themselves in agroforestry, bee farming, wood carving, honeyprocessing techniques, and the conservation and protection of their environment. This engagement has led to an improvement in forest protection, production of honey and crop yields in the Oku area. The recommendation of sustainable strategies via the radio, and the institutionalisation of the villages into community forest zones, have involved some opinion-leaders, and the expertise of local forest extension workers and some external NGOs to keep the project afloat. To date, the ‘Plant a Tree, Save a Bee’ project has produced over 126 bulletins with the technical support of the Oku honey cooperative society. With over 60% of farmers having access to radio sets, the future of the project and that of the Okus, their forest and environment is bright. SATNET (SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURE TRAINERS’ NETWORK) BANANA BACTERIAL WILT CAMPAIGN STRATEGY 2008) Rev. Nason Baluku, Uganda SATNET (Sustainable Agriculture Trainers Network) is a network of community-based organisations, NGOs and faith-based organisations aiming to promote food security at household level and promoting household economic empowerment through training farmers about modern agricultural methodologies. The Rwenzori region is comprised of five districts: Bundibugyo, Kabarole, Kasese, Kamwengye and Kyenjojo districts, in western Uganda. The region is named after Rwenzori Mountain, which is the second highest mountain in Africa. There was a need to address the effect of banana bacterial wilt on banana plantations in the Rwenzori region. In January 2008, SATNET member organisations organised a symposium through which methods to fight banana bacterial wilt were developed. The symposium brought together stakeholders at national, regional and local levels. The content was based on knowledge from research institutions on how the disease spreads and what needed to be done to prevent its future spread. Task forces were established at all levels of leadership, different materials were developed and translated in various languages, and local community/farmer training was organised by various local authorities. The use of radio to communicate to farmers contributed much to the campaign against the spread of banana bacterial wilt. Community meetings and the involvement of farmers in causing awareness have greatly contributed to eliminating this disease in most parts of the region. The Rwenzori region, in the western part of the Uganda, is in the most fertile land of the country, where much of the banana production had been affected. Having applied all the methods recommended by the researchers, banana bacterial wilt has been controlled in this region. Both men and women are fully aware of the disease, and the whole community has doubled its efforts in both conserving the environment through practical soil conservation, and being sensitive about any pest that can encroach on their crops. Radio Sauti ya Mkaaji Modeste Shabani bin Sweni, Democratic Republic of Congo This project on creating awareness for rural self-promotion covered two areas of Sud Maniema: Kasongo and Kabambare. It was created and implemented by Radio Sauti ya Mkaaji, a community radio station based in Kasongo with funding from the United Nations Development Programme’s Unit for Community Recovery (UNDP/ COMREC). The area has a population of 900,000, who depend mainly on agriculture. Like the other regions of DRC, Sud Maniema has suffered badly from the wars with all-round harmful consequences, thus plunging the local population into great poverty. The overall objective of the project was to make the people of Sud Maniema more amenable to rural self-promotion, and specifically to contribute to reducing the food crisis by increasing agricultural production in the region and to train moderators of radio Sauti ya Mkaaji radio clubs or listener groups on rural self-promotion through farming, cropping techniques, rural activities and micro-programme production techniques. Eighty radio club facilitators were trained, including 27 women. As part of the rural self-promotion efforts, 225 radio club facilitators were trained (87 women), with costs covered by the radio clubs themselves. In addition to radio broadcasts, awareness building and extension activities also included cropping techniques, which the network of radio clubs carried out through door-to door and village-to-village contacts. Now, in each village there are between one and 10 or even more farmers’ or fishers’ groups and committees […] to work the fields or make fish ponds, build brick houses, buy household goods, provide schooling for war orphans […] thus making a very effective contribution to improving their living conditions. Moreover, this has led to the creation of an association dedicated to rural self-promotion. A 3-month project was carried out. Afterwards, the radio had to extend it by producing and broadcasting programmes composed of testimonies on the success of various farm groups; the fight against the food crisis became a permanent, cross-cutting theme at Radio Sauti ya Mkaaji. 73 6.6 A long road, but well worth it Panos London won the market consultation to manage the Awards. In consultation with CTA staff and members of the seminar steering committee, Panos wrote the competition announcement, terms and conditions for two categories of entry – Category A, Journalism and Category B, Community communication projects. The announcement was posted on the Communication Initiative website on 2 August, and was the top item in issue 504 of the Communication Initiative’s Drumbeat electronic magazine on 10 August. It was also disseminated by e-mail through the Panos Institutes in London and the ACP regions, and to CTA contacts. Panos drew up criteria for the judges, and members of the seminar steering committee suggested names of possible candidates. By the 1 September deadline, 105 entries had been received in Category A, Journalism. 15 entries were received for Category B, Community communication projects. Of these, two were from the Pacific and the rest from Africa. Five were in French (33%), 10 in English. Entries for the journalism media award (Total= 105 entries) Print By media Television Africa By ACP region 74 Caribbean Pacific By gender Women Men By language English French Percentage (%) 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Entries for the community communication project award (Total= 15 entries) English Per language Panos developed templates for scoring and reviewed all the entries to compile shortlists of eight entries in Category A and five in Category B. All shortlisted candidates were invited to participate in the Brussels seminar. The shortlisted entries were translated and sent to the judges, mainly electronically, along with the scoring templates. During a conference call chaired by the consultant, the five judges selected the final list of three winners in each category, and the names of the winners were communicated to CTA. Radio or Multimedia French Africa Per ACP region Pacific Percentage (%) 0 10 20 All six winners were invited to attend the Seminar. The names of the winners were not released until the presentation of the awards during the 25th anniversary celebrations on 14 October. 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 CTA takes this opportunity to thank the co-ordinators and the judges, and to congratulate the winners on their well deserved achievement. 6.7 Articles from the pre-seminar blog 1. Introduction Are the media contributing to rural development? Marilyn Minderhoud 2 The simple answer, of course, is often, no. At least, if you confine yourself to the conclusions of the lengthy reports and articles pointing to the professional and technical weakness of the media in ACP countries. But such conclusions overlook the reality of those journalists and media practitioners who have left their city desks to report and broadcast stories of agricultural life from small rural centres and community radio stations. They also overlook the efforts being made within civil society, international agencies and pubic organisations to strengthen media capacity in ACP countries. Yet it cannot be denied. The column inches in the national press devoted to issues that help and guide farmers in no way compare to the page-long reports on crime, celebrity activity and government news. And the endless music broadcast on local radio? Well that’s simply the result of programme makers having no other material. Power failures, unstable equipment, expensive internet connections, unreliable transport, poor salaries and the interventions of unsympathetic editorial boards and commercial sponsors determine how effectively ACP media practitioners can contribute to the development process. CTA recognises these constraints, as well as the crippling affects that war, civil conflict and political dictatorship can have on the capacity of the media to contrib- ute to development. Lobbying for the rights of journalists to provide factual and critical comment on rural affairs is essential. CTA’s own strategy focuses on encouraging the professional and technical development of ACP media while ensuring that materials essential for ARD reach those policy-makers, trainers and agricultural practitioners who determine the course of development. Legislation and regulatory frameworks supporting an open and public media are needed to ensure all stakeholders contribute to the development debate. This alone is not enough. Media practitioners must be trained in innovative and development-oriented approaches to information collection and dissemination, so they can work with rural communities to generate content and ideas. Listening groups, citizen journalists, farmer video as well as community radio and community press are among the ways in which increasing numbers of rural communities are accessing information and getting their voices heard. Journalists who are concerned with agricultural and environmental issues are often at the forefront of these developments. However, more could be done to enable them to benefit from the experiences of other like-minded media professionals. Contact and exchange through formal associations, as well as websites, blogs and other forms of digital networking, enable journalists and broadcasters concerned with analysing and assessing the impacts of globalisation, climate change and food security to access and verify information. 2 Marilyn Minderhoud first came into contact with the problems of agricultural development when she worked in the History Department of the University of Zambia. Much of the Department’s research and teaching centred on land and livelihood issues, and these have been recurrent themes throughout her career. In particular, the years she spent documenting and publishing the experiences of small-scale farmers as editor of LEISA magazine and the Biotechnology Monitor made it clear that development-oriented journalists and editors face serious problems in trying to reach rural communities and provide farming households with the knowledge they need to improve rural livelihoods. Challenges and opportunities for development-oriented reporting vary from one ACP country to the next. Recent international agreements encouraging the development of independent and pluralistic media and stressing the need for freedom of expression have tried to provide guidelines for media development. However, at the regional and international levels, media development attracts little attention. Critics suggest that past investments in small-scale, ad hoc projects by donor agencies have had little impact. Often unrelated to local needs, they could not be sustained when funding came to an end, and efforts to scale-up potentially promising interventions have been hindered by the lack of collaboration between projects. Can anything be learned from these interventions? Do they provide insights into how new media, for example, can change the way poor rural communities consume information? Are there examples of innovative approaches that facilitate the use of radio, mobile telephony and the internet? Are ICTs facilitating networking and cooperation among farmers? Summary In the Pacific, lack of funding, training and supportive ICTs hinders the flow of critical information between researchers, media practitioners and farmers. In many African countries, poor media access in rural communities, and journalists and broadcasters who do not have the means to reach rural villages, have led to poor coverage of local realities. By linking rural farming and fishing communities, the media can stimulate the flow of information and ideas and create an environment that enables appropriate and effective rural development. ICTs have a strategic role to play in this process, 75 both by empowering the media and by encouraging rural communities to contribute their own news, opinions and knowledge to a digital audience. The approach and judgement of journalists, broadcasters and webmasters was called into question by a contributor from the Caribbean. Training was needed to enable journalists to approach rural development issues in a more holistic way and to ensure they recognised the importance of reporting on agricultural practices that mitigated the impact of ecological and climate change. 2. Media and new technologies Ibbo Daddy Abdoulaye 3 “It is not only a matter of giving fish or teaching someone how to fish, questions also need to be asked about what to do with the catch ...” 76 Useful information, at the right time, for the people who need it most, i.e. the peoples of Africa, Asia, Latin America, the Caribbean, the Pacific and Oceania ... most of them are poor and live in remote or landlocked rural areas, where the traditional channels of communication are scarce. This situation has always been a problem for development officers. Wind, sun, satellites, cell phones, computers, radio, television – there has never been a better time than now, in this era of abundant technologies and resources. Phenomenal results are being obtained from equipment that is becoming increasingly efficient, practical and often less expensive, in other words a “marriage of reason” is occurring in areas vital to underendowed populations, e.g. food and nutritional security, human and animal health, protection of the environment and natural resources, bringing about considerable change in the media landscape. These results can be traced to contents (access to a worldwide information network, speed of data transmission, etc.) as well as to the mode of dissemination (digital chains, satellite, radio, television, online newspapers, archiving, etc.). Judge for yourself: in India, video conferences are used to allow farmers, who do not know each other and who live thousands of miles apart, but suffer the same trials and tribulations, to meet, share their viewpoints and explain their problems to a community of research scientists who, otherwise, would be unable to grasp such a large range of problems. This case goes beyond sight and sound responses, it goes to the farmers’ urgent problems. It illustrates all the possibilities that new technologies can offer to make communications more fluid and improve interactions between agricultural specialists, who are usually based in the cities, and farmers, who are miles apart. This experience is instructive from all angles. It not only offers us better coverage and better impact, it also allows the experts to make their analyses and give the most appropriate advice by closely examining the samples brought in by the farmers. In Niger, a wise “marriage” of community radio and internet enabled the marginalised communities to emerge from their isolation and to download data stored in a common orbital attic and fed by the development community, as well as to produce programmes (especially on AIDS awareness and preventive measures) and provide distance learning (literacy training, agriculture, etc.). In Indonesia and the tsunami zones, a simple cell phone is used for receiving and sending risk and warning messages and all other useful and practical information from everywhere, at all times and under all conditions. Elsewhere, being able to read maps on fodder or resources enables local popula- 3 tions to go straight to the target, or to be able to interpret forthcoming events on the basis of a combination of empirical knowledge, scientific tools and facts. These examples are nothing more than illustrations, of course. Around the world there are interesting and innovative initiatives under way to convey information ever faster, ever further and ever less expensively to the people who need it most. Incredible. Since this wealth of tools is paving the way to media expansion and better circulation of information and ideas, and hence is serving as a catalyst for economic and social development, why is it taking so long to get things going? Why is it so difficult to replicate an Indian subcontinent model in sub-Saharan Africa? Why is poverty growing, instead of shrinking? Some people blame the lack of information, or lack of access to information, on time-tested technologies, but we have to be careful not to throw the baby out with the bathwater. A poor artisan will always complain about his tools. The question is, how many of the final users know how to use and care for tools that are often placed at their disposal free of charge? And what can we say about the relevance of the contents, which very often have not been designed for “off-the-rack” use? This does not get the State, the funders or the NGOs off the hook, for they very often are the ones who installed the technological tools without any pre-studies, or capacity-building efforts for the beneficiary populations ... walking off without saying a word about maintenance or spare parts. In the field of technology, just like the field of development, the wise old saying still applies: “It is not only a matter An accomplished professional with over 18 years’ experience in the field of journalism and communications, Ibbo Daddy Abdoulaye has a broad background in strategic communications for development. As Director of a communications agency that produces the magazine Les Echos du Sahel, he leads a small team to increase the sahelian rural communities’ visibility, and to capture and convey stories about their needs and challenges and the importance of agriculture and rural development in the development priorities. An awardwinning and investigative journalist, generally interested in complex stories or those neglected by mainstream media organisations, Ibbo Daddy Abdoulaye is primarily focused on development issues in the Sahel, and is committed to providing the vital information and news that affect people’s lives. of giving fish or teaching someone to fish, questions also need to be asked about what to do with the catch...” Summary A contributor working for a large Kenyan NGO raised a serious question this week when she queried the wisdom of introducing expensive communication technology in areas dominated by small-scale farming communities. She pointed out that the introduction of such technology in places where it was not a priority meant added expense and responsibility, and this could lead to less money and manpower being available for more essential activities. To what extent is this experience true of other ACP regions, and are there positive examples of ICTs being introduced in such sustainable and effective ways that they can provide support to even the poorest rural household? 3. Media impact Catching the imagination – farm programmes that change lives Michael Waigwa 4 During the 1990s, in my primary and high school years, one programme on national radio stood out. “Tembea na Majira” – loosely translated as “Walk with the Seasons”. Tembea na Majira was an interactive Swahili play with hilarious, down-to-earth characters that depicted the happenings in an average village. It had several themes, most of which revolved around best farming practices to boost food production; malaria and HIV Aids control; and retrogressive cultural practices such as wife inheritance and female genital manipulation. It was a programme I couldn’t afford to miss, especially because of its emphasis on farming as a business that rural households could use to escape poverty. The programme excited my interest in agriculture, and we often applied what we heard on our family farm (e.g. use of maize varieties appropriate for our area, crop spacing). This culminated in my studying agriculture in high school through to university. Over time, the programme went off air, and being a public good, it meant that only the government was keen to fund it. The collapse of the public agricultural extension programmes in the 1990s spelled doom for our ability to produce competitively, as new skills were not being imparted to farmers. Using the media as a distribution channel for agricultural information removes the high administrative costs associated with conventional extension programmes. Radio remains the most accessible medium for the majority of farmers as it is affordable and does not require the extensive electrical network needed to support TV. Radios are also portable and programmes can now be accessed via mobile phones. The Kenyan Government – through the national broadcaster KBC – has started radio programmes to educate farmers using vernacular languages. These are targeting the production of staple foods, mainly maize, necessary to attain food security. Farmers in different regions are advised on when, how and what varieties of crop to plant. This effort is an attempt by government to avert recurring food and water crises. Fortunately, the proliferation of vernacular FM stations in recent years has brought great opportunities within the reach of farmers at all levels, even uneducated rural folk. These stations have come up with very effective programmes that speak directly to farmers. The programmes are very popular and have increased radio listenership. An example of such a programme is “Mugambo wa Murimi” which loosely translates as the “Voice of the Farmer”. This morning programme engages agricultural specialists who are interviewed on air by listeners through phone calls. I wouldn’t miss catching up on developments in my field while fighting the traffic to get to work. Experts are invited in response to callers’ requests for information. These specialists are mainly drawn from leading agroinput companies, who in turn sponsor such programmes. This type of sponsorship is motivated by the desire to drive sales, and thus may not be geared to sharing the much broader range of agricultural information needed by the majority of rural folks. Overall, the media have not come out well in 4 Michael Waigwa (28) was born in Laikipia, a village in one of the driest parts of Kenya, and grew up among families for whom life was a continual struggle. As the weather became increasingly unreliable and rivers dried out, he saw livelihood opportunities decline and came to realise that these environmental changes had wider implications. Determined to understand and alleviate these conditions, he decided to study agriculture at the University of Nairobi. There – as Chairman of the Agricultural Students Association – he established an outreach and extension programme so students could share their knowledge with farmers. He also became involved in several national and international forums that aimed to stimulate the interest of youth in agriculture. Today he works as an agricultural underwriter for the Co-operative Insurance Company of Kenya Ltd. 77 championing agricultural entrepreneurship. However, there is a strong case for the media to contribute towards the realisation of food security and the growth of incomes in rural areas. Sponsors are needed to increase the number of quality programmes on radio and TV. The government alone is not able to address all segments of the market, so there is an urgent need for private–public participation. Summary What is the role of the media in extension? This was the question raised by a contributor from Nigeria, who pointed out that low pay and lack of training were hampering the effectiveness of agricultural extension in his country. It would be interesting to hear from others involved in ACP extension services what they think the role of the media should be in supporting ARD activities. On another note, the positive impact that well packaged and targeted agricultural radio programmes can have in encouraging young people to enter the agricultural sector was confirmed by a contributor from Niger. His experience was similar to that of Michael Waigwa, and suggests that those concerned with agricultural development should intensify their efforts to use the media to reach young listeners and viewers. 4. Political and corporate interests The struggle for media professionalisation in Kenya is a rural development issue Aghan Daniel 5 Poor pay makes journalists, editors and media house directors vulnerable to bribes and biased reporting that favours (potential) sponsors, advertisers and investors more interested in the urban economy than rural development. Meanwhile, in the rural areas crime and politics continue to dominate the headlines. A leading Kenyan newspaper pays Ksh1500 (€12) for a one-page feature. Some journalists earn just Ksh6000 (€50) a month, with no provision for pension or sickness. Worse still, “well paying” media houses still use a ruler to measure stories, and news stories often earn as little as Ksh300 (€2.50). This makes it difficult for journalists to be impartial and balanced in their reporting and refuse the Ksh2000 (€18) offered by politicians wanting favourable press coverage. Such journalists have little incentive to report on rural poverty. After all, poor farmers have little extra to offer. City-based manufacturers and industrialists control the media, and although much of their profit is based on the labour of the rural poor, it is business not rural development that pays. The media and media publicity have become essential for the continued prosperity of the urban elite. nored in the newsroom? Many media houses are no longer concerned with the business of informing and educating their audience. Rather, they have become cash cows whose main objective is to make profit for their owners. Journalists working under such conditions find it increasingly difficult to maintain their objectivity and – knowing that it is income from urban sponsors and advertisers that keeps them in business – do not push stories dealing with the problems of the impoverished rural sector unless a bribe is involved. The proliferation of media houses, poor supervision by the formal watchdogs, and a lack of interest in building a career in journalism, together with greed and materialism, have made it difficult for journalists to maintain standards and ethics in their profession. Many journalists are on the payroll of business, government and political interest groups who want to get news syndicated and planted in the media. Little wonder, then, that journalists have become cash-for-story agents. Some journalists are simply unaware of what constitutes minimum standards of conduct and professionalism, and have little understanding of rural development issues. Increased emoluments for journalists will make them less susceptible to bribes, but this will not necessarily improve the coverage of rural issues. The media are largely profit driven and focused on the interests of a predominantly urban audience. More rural development stories are unlikely to increase readership or listener demand. Can journalists be expected to maintain ethics if these are ig- 78 5 Aghan Daniel possesses a wealth of experience as a contributor to major local and international media specialising in agriculture, health, environment and development reporting. He is a regular contributor to newspapers based in Tanzania and Kenya on agriculture and development issues. He began writing on science issues 12 years ago by contributing to local newspapers in Kenya as a correspondent. His career spans spells at the regional weekly The East African (a Nation Media Group publication) and The Daily Nation. Before helping to found Media for Environment Science Health and Agriculture (MESHA), which is an association of science journalists in Kenya, he worked for 5 years at the Biotechnology Trust Africa – a regional NGO – as Information Officer. For the past 3 years he has been coordinating MESHA activities, where he writes and edits the organisation’s website on agricultural issues. He also trains journalists on documenting and writing about agricultural issues. How can this situation be rectified? First, we have to look at the calibre and background of those who call themselves journalists. In Kenya, we often make cynical jokes about the fact that few citybased journalists ever think about the crucial role of rural journalism because they have no experience of rural life, and have been trained exclusively in urban institutes and media houses. We need programmes to sensitise journalists on rural development and the effective reporting of agricultural issues. But to be successful, journalists need to publish or broadcast their stories. It is therefore essential that specialised media outlets are established in the rural areas to deal with agricultural and development issues. Such services would ensure the timely collection and appropriate packaging of relevant information. Efficiently disseminated, this information would help strengthen networks of information exchange and involve rural communities more closely in identifying local concerns. As commercial sources are unlikely to fund such development, financial support will be needed from development-oriented organisations and other public institutions. Summary 5. Sourcing information In his article, Aghan Daniel makes a strong case for the further professionalisation of the media in his home country Kenya. He argues that poor pay and conditions undermine the motivation of many journalists and broadcasters and prevent them from investigating stories relevant to rural development. These factors also make some media practitioners vulnerable to handouts and bribes. Getting information from government on rural issues is like trying to break into State secrets Contributors to the blog largely supported this analysis. They suggested that the impoverished working environment of many journalists created a barrier to their reporting on agricultural issues – especially issues that affected small-scale farming communities. In the Pacific, however, it was claimed that journalists are not so susceptible to bribes. But low salaries remain a problem and continue to undermine the quality of development-oriented reporting. One possible way out of this impasse was suggested by Huub Ruijgrok. He proposed that research institutes should make a specific allocation for communication and working with the media in their annual budget. In this way, a sustainable link could be established between research findings relevant to agricultural households, journalists and farmers themselves. What options exist for making the most of the limited amount of money available for agricultural reporting – especially stories that focus on the local information needs of the “peasant” farmer? We welcome your ideas. Ruci Mafi 6 When I was asked to write this article, I wondered just how many of my mainstream media colleagues would feel strongly enough about the topic to answer the two questions posed. “What has been your experience as a journalist or broadcaster in gathering information from the field and from official and scientific sources in the Pacific? And what resources do you regularly use for agricultural and development information?” I sent out a note to two networks of journalists as well as individual reporters, seeking their views on the challenges they face sourcing information on agriculture. After 1 week I had only received five responses but – as my deadline was approaching – I had to start writing. I had been taken aback by the observation of one senior journalist who had spent over 35 years in the Pacific media. “Journalists are lazy”, he wrote “They lack the skills to cultivate and nurture TRUST. They rely almost entirely on press releases from government, the private sector and individuals.” His observation was, however, vigorously denied by another veteran journalist. “I beg to differ” he wrote “and shoot me if I ever become as cynical as you. I find your comments insulting and perhaps after 35 years in the profession, it’s time you got out.” My training as a journalist forced me to give my colleagues the benefit of the doubt. Maybe journalists are far too busy with the daily dissemination of news to worry about agriculture and rural development. One thing is certain, journalists face many challenges when gathering information to report in a balanced, fair and accurate way on agriculture and rural development. Netani Rika is editor-in-chief of the largest newspaper in the South Pa- 79 cific. He finds obtaining information from officials and scientific sources problematic. “Most people do not want to give information, and extracting information from government is extremely difficult”, he said. Scientific sources are freer with dissemination. “Here the problem is jargon and the technical terms used” says Rika. “Scientists often refuse to simplify information, and this is a problem for journalists faced with deadlines but who have to interpret scientific or technical information for their readers.” Samisoni Pareti is a Pacific media trainer and foreign correspondent who shares Rika’s sentiments. “Agricultural departments want me to follow their official communication channels, which amounts to being given the run around and usually ends in nothing.” Like Pareti, journalists in many Pacific island countries say getting information on rural and agricultural development from the agriculture department is almost as difficult as getting hold of State secrets. “I wanted to get a comment from the head of dredging at the agriculture department for a story that a town would disappear in 20 years time because of rising sea levels”, Partei explained. “I called his office and was told to put my questions through the department’s information department. I did, and faxed them as requested. For 3 days they told me that the official could not speak to me. A sheer waste of time and resources. As for scientists, they can be pedantic. They usually ask to see my copy before publication, but I always refuse. I never ask to see their scientific reports before publication, so why should they see mine?” 80 Increasing media coverage of rural development issues depends on mutual understanding, trust and respect. Effective cooperation can be achieved only if the cloud of suspicion overshadowing journalists and the media is dispelled. The media must be able to access information easily, and their sources should feel confident in the results. Agriculture plays a major role in driving the economy of the Pacific, and rural people need easy access to relevant information in simple English or – better still – in the vernacular. Summary Reactions to Ruci Mafi’s article from Africa and the Pacific confirmed much of what she described. An agricultural journalist from Tanzania gave practical examples of how his attempts to source information from government officials were often thwarted by a combination of fear – “Ask my superiors” – and an inexplicable refusal to respond to direct questions even when – as in one terrible instance – these had to do with issues that directly affected the health of local farming communities. From the Pacific, Jason Brown strongly denied the accusation that agricultural issues were being ignored because journalists were too lazy to deal with them. He pointed to the way in which the rapid privatisation and corporatisation of the media has directly and negatively affected the flow and content of information. Drawing attention to the fact that the media are increasingly dominated by interests that want to ensure messages entering the public domain are controlled and sanitised, he reflected on the consequences for journalists who interface directly with local communities, and do not have the resources to combat this trend. We have not heard from colleagues in the Caribbean, and we would welcome your reactions. 6. Training Training is the key to getting agricultural issues into the media Johnson Johnrose 7 I was born and grew up on a small Caribbean island where the colour of gold was green and the gold miners wore rubber boots and were armed with pitch forks, picks, hoes and cutlasses. In this small Caribbean island called Dominica, back then bananas – and, by extension, agriculture – were king and there were no princes or princesses waiting to take over the throne; and discussions about extension had nothing to do with male enhancement and everything to do with field (extension) officers on the farms, helping farmers develop their skills and improve their yield. It was agriculture and very little else. However, the thousands of farmers who made their living from agriculture (green gold) did all they could to stop their children from becoming “gold miners”. They wanted their children to become medical doctors and lawyers or anything glamorous. Agriculture was for the uneducated and unambitious. So the inevitable happened and agricultural production declined. At the same time, several other Caribbean countries were seeking “gold” elsewhere, particularly in tourism. I can’t help thinking that, in retrospect, the media also let down the sector. I vaguely recall one programme named “Green Gold” on the radio, in which the characters used humour to discuss issues affecting the banana industry, but not much else. Of course, the challenges were many. Most of the Caribbean countries had Ruci Mafi was born in Lautoka City in the Republic of Fiji. The second eldest child in a family of six, she did not know what she wanted to become until she landed herself a job as a cadet reporter in a newspaper company. After over 10 years working as a journalist covering politics and many other issues, she joined the Secretariat of the Pacific Community (SPC). She is currently a media trainer and television journalist keen on assisting her colleagues and young journalists to realise their full potential and make changes. She is part of a team that produces a weekly Pacific magazine-style television show that is shown in 19 Pacific island countries and territories. She loves to write and takes a keen interest in the environment. government-controlled radio stations and few had their own television channel. The radio stations were all things to all people and had to satisfy everyone’s desires, leaving little time to focus on key matters. Over the years, we have seen a proliferation of media – particularly FM radio stations – but this has not meant greater attention to less sexy issues like agriculture. This proliferation of media has instead taxed the already scant talent pool. And to compound the problem, media owners are prepared to spend less and less on quality professionals, so they hire people off the streets who don’t understand the first thing about media. These media owners are also unwilling to spend on “developmental” programmes. Today’s media practitioner also seems lost when it comes to understanding his/her role and, because it’s not a high-paying profession, there is a high turnover rate. Sadly, few people become part of the media with the intention of becoming real professionals. Many use it as a stepping stone to a job in public relations, where the financial rewards are greater. And for those who remain, the owners provide few training opportunities or training facilities. I’m not sure if they understand that journalism is a profession and its people ought to consider themselves professionals. You can’t have professionals without training and codes of ethics and behaviour. These are the problems the media face and that therefore have a negative impact on the media’s abilities to influence and shape the debate on agriculture and rural development. But all is not lost. As citizens of the Caribbean, our media practitioners are passionate about their region and want to play a role in its development. They want to be responsible and progressive. My organisation, the Caribbean Tourism Organization (CTO), has recognised this. We know that the same issues confronting agriculture as far as the media are concerned, also confront tourism. Therefore we have begun offering training opportunities to young media practitioners. It is by training and mobilising the media, including owners, that we will encourage and influence them to play a greater role in agriculture and rural development. From my dealings with Caribbean journalists and broadcasters, it is clear that they need training in basic media and journalism practices. However, in order to strengthen their contribution to agriculture and rural development, they need to understand the complexities of global food systems and how to simplify and effectively communicate information about agricultural issues to the public. Also lacking is the ability to research and discuss agricultural topics effectively, as well as the ability to write in clear, concise, organised language. Study programmes in agricultural journalism and communications, including programmes on use of the internet, particularly blogs like this one, would most certainly make a massive difference. 7 Johnson Johnrose is a BBC- trained journalist, broadcaster and media trainer who also holds certificates in media management from the College of Audio and Visual Arts in Caracas, and in news and business reporting from Reuters. He has been a practising journalist for over 25 years, with vast experience in reporting on a wide range of Caribbean subjects including politics, economics, tourism and financial services issues. He has also covered international events relevant to the Caribbean including Commonwealth Heads of Government meetings, the Summit of the Americas and meetings of OAS and CARICOM. Johnson Johnrose has won several awards for his work, which has been published and broadcast within and outside the Caribbean. He has also been a frequent contributor to BBC London Live. He began his career as a reporter in Dominica and subsequently worked as news editor and programme director for the state-owned DBS Radio. He also worked for the Caribbean News Agency (CANA), where he was the producer and presenter of its flagship programme “The Caribbean Today”, before becoming radio and television news editor at the Caribbean Media Corporation (CMC). Currently Johnson Johnrose is communications officer at the Caribbean Tourism Organization (CTO) but he continues to practice journalism as a freelancer. Summary Johnson Johnrose in his article stresses the many factors that contribute to the way agricultural issues tend to be sidelined in the Caribbean media, including the low status of agriculture and the limited number of trained and experienced journalists. Responses from the farm community in southern Tanzania interviewed by Felix Mwakyembe show perhaps how this trend can be reversed. When asked “What do farmers need from the media?”, respondents made it clear that they understood their concerns and issues were often systematically ignored by journalists in favour of the statements and activities of politicians and government officials. But they also provided examples of how a few journalists in their area were turning this situation around by taking up issues of serious local concern and bringing them to national attention. As a result, farmers were playing a more active role in providing information to journalists and the media were increasingly seen as a source of educative information. 81 7. Financing the media Closer cooperation – is this the answer to the financial problems of ACP media houses? Hans Determeyer 8 Financial insecurity is a feature of the media sector in emerging economies, especially in rural areas. Many media organisations depend on donor funds or commercial sponsorship for their operations. Experience suggests that short-term funding and uncoordinated projects – often driven by external agendas rather than local needs – have a negative effect on the establishment of sound media companies. Subsidies may help to establish media initiatives, but they also create dependency and insecurity when they dry up. Commercial interests may provide the funds for investment in equipment or for covering part of the running cost. However, such financial supports from commercial businesses often come with specific conditions. To ensure the capacity of journalists and broadcasters to provide full and critical coverage of ARD issues, freedom of programming needs to be guaranteed. However, the financial aspect poses challenges to such independence, certainly in low-income communities. It takes entrepreneurial spirit and management skills to overcome such hurdles without losing ownership of programme content. The point is, journalists’ drive to set up a station or create a newspaper does not always come with the necessary entrepreneurial spirit. 82 We see there are challenges in professional areas such as business development, financial management and marketing where small and medium-sized media houses are concerned. There are institutional challenges, such as active engagement in networking, programme exchanges, liaising with new ICT initiatives and joint marketing. And when working with commercial investment to cover the cost, ownership of programming and content will depend on negotiating skills and how well rooted the media house is in its audience or readership. After all, commercial investment in a media house is more likely to prosper when it has strong roots in the local community: a potential win– win situation. What will trigger media houses to meet these challenges and thus bolster their performance? Certainly not subsidies alone, as they only allow the organisation to continue trudging on a bit longer on the same survivalist path. In other sectors, one major trigger for the average company to grow and prosper is access to capital for investments, via banks or microfinance institutions. Mind you, the relationship with a bank demands a business plan and sound financial management. The pressure of interest due on loans should keep the entrepreneur sharp and inventive. Would this work in the media sector? Well, banks and media houses are notoriously and historically not very close as far as their relations with each other are concerned. Media have difficulty with the collateral demanded by banks and other investors. Media house – in popular perception – are generally seen as not particularly well organised, and also as being politically vulnerable. No, the generally high interest rates banks charge in emerging economies (often >30%) is unlikely to result in happy and lasting marriages. The Netherlands-based organisation Free Voice intends to break this vicious circle. With a mix of guarantees for investors (those interested in high impact rather than high interest), networking with the financial sector and subsidised business development services for media houses, it targets (networks of) small and medium-sized media houses in emerging economies. Together with the Media Development Loan Fund and other partners, access to credit has thus been created in Indonesia, the Southern Africa SADC region and Peru. Currently the establishment of similar initiatives is under way in South America and West Africa. The market is enormous and growing, thanks to the flow of mobile networks. The potential – also for the agricultural sector – is more than promising. The challenge will be to bring financial institutions and (small) media houses together and to find ways of simplifying the cost of loan management – not an easy matter, given that small media house are often geographically widely dispersed. A possible solution, maybe, is closer networking among media houses where financial arrangements are concerned. Summary Contributors confirmed that financial sustainability was a problem for media houses and initiatives. Even in periods of relative financial security, worries about how to finance the next stage were present. While donor funding is important, a business-like approach was seen as delivering more security in the long run. The experience of some community radio stations suggests that so long as the targeted rural audience feels that the information being provided is relevant and contributes to livelihood improvement, people are prepared to pay to help support and take part in the activities of their local community radio station. 8 Since 2008, Hans Determeyer has led the Media Finance Programme for Free Voice – the Dutch-based media support organisation. The programme aims to create access to financial services for (networks of) media houses in emerging economies and young democracies. Hans has been able to bring many years of practical field experience to managing the Media Finance Programme. In Africa, he was involved in promoting civic engagement in good governance and transparent policy processes. In Ghana, his team established an innovative multi-donor fund for think tanks and advocacy networks. With a team of Cameroonian specialists he established a funding and capacity development mechanism for communities living in the dense tropical forest zone, while in Chad he led a multi-sectoral programme focusing on conflict management and human rights at a time when tensions were rising around the planned exploitation of local oil reserves. He has also worked with Medecins sans Frontieres and Amnesty International. 8. Legislation and political constraints Bad laws are an affront to media growth Parkie Mbozi 9 Media freedom in any democratic dispensation is essential if urban as well as rural communities are to make informed contributions to development. The media’s role in relating to and accommodating peoples’ voices – especially those in disadvantaged, impoverished and marginalised communities – is critical to the democratisation and development of our societies. A major prerequisite to attaining media freedom is a favourable regulatory and legal environment. Favourable laws are like good soil to a seed. A positive legislative environment will ensure a flourishing media. A bad one inhibits all aspects of media growth – establishment (registration), programming and further diversification. Unfortunately, not many ACP countries have regulatory and legal environments that encourage media establishment and growth. Problems begin with registration. In many countries, registration is a lengthy, tedious and frustratingly bureaucratic process involving many different government offices and tasks. From our experience in Southern Africa, the process can take up to 24 months to complete. A number of prospective radio stations give up mid-way or even fail to register at all. These difficulties apply not only to Africa’s most common medium of agricultural communication – radio – but to print media as well. Besides the lengthy registration process, the law in many ACP countries allows governments to decide who should be granted a permit or licence. In some countries, statutory media regulations allow governments to deregister “erring” media or journalists and require all journalists be accredited to – and licensed by – a government-appointed Media Commission. In Zimbabwe, for instance, the introduction of this form of regulation resulted in the de-registration of the Daily News, the most vibrant privately owned newspaper Zimbabwe has ever had, and which was regarded as the true voice of the people. In Zambia, some community radio stations have been threatened with having their licences revoked for airing phone-in radio programmes considered to be inciting the masses against the government. In Angola, no new radio stations have been registered for nearly 10 years. Although there have been some positive developments on the media front in some ACP countries – particularly where media diversity has been strengthened by the proliferation of community and commercial broadcasting stations – more needs to be done. You may ask why we should worry about media laws and regulatory frameworks when discussing the role of the media in rural and agricultural development? We should be concerned because media plurality ensures that more diverse and relevant information reaches our people living in the rural areas, where most of our agriculture takes place. Until recently, many media institutions tended to be concentrated in urban areas. Radio and TV signals and hard copies of newspapers and other forms of communications hardly reached the rural areas at all. When they did, the content was predominantly urban-oriented, and if there was “rural content” it had been prepared by elite, urban-based media practitioners and “experts” and designed for consumption by a passive, “voiceless” rural audience. Miscommunication was therefore inevitable, and could explain why small-scale agriculture remains undeveloped in many ACP countries despite years of massive investment. This is why we must support the growing interest in community media. We must do so by identifying and fighting bad laws and regulatory frameworks through our numerous media associations. We must instigate media reforms and ensure that favourable media laws are enshrined in our constitutions. In all our struggles the local people – the “voiceless” – must be the centre and the “end”. We – as journalists – are merely the “means”. In this way we will win many hearts and turn our battle for press freedom into a people’s battle. Summary Media freedom is essential for democracy and development. It is also ensures that rural households get the information they need to play an active and informed role in the development of their communities. Contributors from other parts of Africa stressed that the press has always to be alert and react strongly when governments try to curtail press freedom in whatever form. Contributors emphasised that pro-media legislation was needed to ensure a diverse and strong media capable of providing neglected rural communities with a voice. 9 Parkie Mbozi is a specialist in communication and media for development, having studied and worked in this field in numerous capacities for national, regional and international organisations in Southern Africa. Some of the notable organisations include Participatory Ecological Land-Use Management (PELUM) Association for East and Southern Africa, World Agroforestry Centre (ICRAF), Southern African Development Community (SADC) Food, Agriculture and NR Directorate, University of Zambia Department of Mass Communication, Ministry of Agriculture, and others. He is holder of a BA and MA in Mass Communication, specialising in Development Support Communication. Parkie is currently Executive Director for Panos Southern Africa based in Lusaka, at the regional office for southern Africa. 83 9. Technology and the media New media technologies alone cannot break the rural–urban digital divide Kevin Waldie 10 A few months ago, I was having a meeting with the director of a well established NGO in Southern Africa as his mobile phone rang. There was nothing unusual in this. The director always travelled with two mobile phones and held sim cards for at least 10 African countries the last time I checked. I had become used to the fact that our conversations were invariably punctuated with interruptions, which frequently entailed his moving out of the office in an effort to locate a stronger signal. On this occasion, after the call had finished, the director offered his usual apology and added that it was his mother, now over 80 years of age, phoning from his home village, a few hundred miles away. She had called to request him to bring a bag of fertiliser next time he came to visit. “She likes to keep active”, the director explained, “… and to check up on me”, he added with a smile. I clearly recall seeing my very first mobile phones. This was during the mid 1990s, when I was living and working in rural West Africa. At that time the phones were so large, they seemed well suited to the oversized 4x4 vehicles in which their wealthy owners drove around. “They are just playthings for the rich”, I thought, “They’ll never catch on.” How wrong I was! 84 As a result of the rapid spread of digital technologies and new media, the world today appears a very different and perhaps more democratic place. For years the BBC, Voice of America and Radio Moscow dominated the spread of news to distant lands. Today, they share the airwaves with FM radio stations, which provide local news for local people and in local languages. Computers have long escaped from the offices of the corporate world, and internet cafés provide an increasing number of people with access to a wide range of information. And consider the many hundreds of thousands of vendors found selling airtime for mobile phones on every other street corner in the major towns and cities around the world. Doesn’t this indicate that we now live in a world that is engaged in a deep and prolonged conversation with itself? A firm belief in the north–south basis of a “digital divide” framed earlier discussions of the role of ICT within the development process. Technology transfer was promoted as the obvious remedy to the “problem”. To a large extent, this simplistic way of framing the digital divide persists. Today, however, it is an “urban–rural” divide. Despite the rhetorical commitment to participatory development, a “We know best” attitude seems to persist in programmes concerned with development and the information needs of farmers. And this is reflected in the excuses for ineffective service delivery which, by drawing attention to factors such as illiteracy and poor education, put the blame for inadequate information transfer on the rural community. Despite the undeniable potential of ICTs to bring about radical change, there is a distinct danger that persistence of “top-down” ways of thinking will undermine the relevance and effectiveness of ICT policy targeting in rural areas. rural tele-centres are frequently promoted on the basis of the need to introduce new technologies to raise productivity and to expose farmers to new markets. However, they seldom yield these results. Evidence suggests that social rather than economic benefits are usually uppermost in most people’s minds when they initially consider the benefits that ICTs may have to offer. Initiatives that take wider social interests into account and recognise their importance to rural people are much more likely to succeed. Fortunately new, more sensitive media interventions are challenging digital exclusion. For example, the use of citizen journalists and community radios explicitly draws attention to the fundamental importance of empowering people by giving them a “voice” that plays in the development process. We should be very cautious of attempting to bridge the digital divide on the basis of technical expert-led, service-driven approaches of the kind that have proven ineffective in the past. For example, government concerns over the declining contribution of the agriculture sector to the national GDP may be genuine. However, this does not mean that a farmer’s primary interest in owing a mobile phone will be to access the latest market prices. Similarly, Kevin Waldie studied social anthropology and undertook his doctoral research in Sierra Leone (1983–85). He then joined the UK Department for International Development as a Social Development Adviser, and over a period of 10 years lived and worked in Kenya, Nepal and Ghana on a series of rural development projects. He was a lecturer at the University of Reading (1997–2008) before leaving to pursue his interests as freelance consultant. His personal website is at www.waldie.info. 10 Summary The current “top-down” approaches to development fail to take field realities into account, especially where the introduction of new technologies is concerned. Decision-makers need to take into closer consideration the practical day-to-day realities of farm households. To do this, they need to hear from the rural communities themselves. The purposive use of ICTs, as one contributor suggested, can support the media and encourage this information exchange, but experience showed that technologies alone cannot shape and reshape development. Examples were provided from community radio stations and radio listening clubs where media intervention had helped communities articulate their concerns until they received a positive response from government. It was suggested that such experiences can lead to other communities seeing the value of the media as a support in influencing agricultural and development policy. 10. Strategies for strengthening media involvement Growing journalists from agriculturalists – towards restoring culture in agriculture Kris Rampersad 11 In Trinidad and Tobago, not unlike many other parts of the Caribbean and the developing world, agriculture and development are inherently contradictory terms. Deeply rooted in the region’s labour history of slavery and forced indentured labour, children are educated away from agriculture; their ambitions nurtured to aspire to life in industry or professional services that are as far away from the land as is possible, in the belief that agriculture offers only limited life chances. This attitude to agriculture – as a peripheral activity – translates into the policies and practices of the adult world. In Trinidad and Tobago, where there are an abundance of alternatives to agriculture in the country’s energy resources, policy planning ensures that there are sufficient incentives for the private sector to invest in the exploitation of more oil and gas reserves. At the same time, the private sector is berated for not investing in agriculture, although it is offered little inducement to do so. Support for farmers and agricultural interests is not viewed as a viable and economically sound investment. There is no real link between the products of agriculture as core to personal survival, as there is with the oft-reiterated links between energy as core to economic survival. The quantity of food on one’s table from the outside world is believed to signify the level of development. Import labels imply that the household is on its way, like the national policy agenda, to developed status. The household with mainly local products on its table is considered to be on the lower rungs of the social and economic ladder. National media replicate and perpetuate these perceptions of and attitudes towards agriculture with – perhaps not deliberate – inadvertent, negative imaging of the sector. It is not unusual to see or hear feature and news stories in print and electronic media that tell of “the once sleepy agricultural village that is now awakening to development (read: non-agro-based industries). In effect, there is no culture of agriculture in Trinidad and Tobago. The media are one of the most powerful modern engines for creating, nurturing and sustaining tastes, perceptions, habits and beliefs. As a creative catalyst, an agent of culture, and a stimulant of public opinion, the media are recognisably best positioned to reverse such attitudes and approaches that have worked against the sector. But the limitations on media as an institution in the region are not much different from those of the agriculture sector. It, too, views itself as disempowered and functioning with limited capacity, resources and investments in its professional development. Perhaps we need to turn the spotlight not just on what journalists can I was born a farmer’s daughter; later, I grew into something else. Like most around me, I was cultivated into becoming something else, anything else. Years later, walking away from journalism as it was being practised, a disenchanted editor of a city newspaper which was more preoccupied with sales, deadlines and profit margins rather than guarding or growing democracy, I dreamed of the opportunities offered by agriculture. I have since worked with international development organisations such as the Commonwealth Foundation, The Organization of American States Active Democracy Network, CIVICUS – World Alliance for Citizen Participation, the Inter-American Institute for Cooperation in Agriculture (IICA), and the Caribbean Agricultural Research and Development Institute (CARDI) to forge such bridges, including coordinating the Agriculture Round Table for IICA/CARDI/CTA/CARICOM in 2008. Along with this, I function as International Relations Director of the Network of NGOs of Trinidad and Tobago for the Advancement of Women; and am founder of the Trinidad Theatre Workshop Fund for Literature, Drama and Film, and an author, film producer, editor, and lecturer in literature and journalism. 11 85 do – which has already received considerable attention – but what agriculturalists can do to empower themselves by increasing their capacities to use media in their outreach. It is a fact that the media are attracted to power and success like insects to a source of light. Empowering the agriculture sector to utilise the wide array of media tools and opportunities is key to attracting media attention to agriculture. The agriculture sector has to develop and establish strong bonds with conventional mass media as well as explore the potential of expanding outreach and impact through new (e.g. internet) and alternative (performance arts) media. Agriculture must reach out to create understanding and awareness and then a one-to-one approach – reporter to agriculturalist – rather than trying to convert the entire media. The sector will also benefit if it develops its own expertise in journalism: packaging products, feeding articles and stories to media outlets and filtering its expertise through the system as editors, producers, reporters and opinion leaders, for example. In addition, it should draw on the opportunities for citizen journalism and the kind of target community the online social and professional networking channels provide. 86 Such a proactive approach will help project an image of an empowered sector and counter negative imaging. Support by new technology with the objective of gaining fuller control over content and message will enable the sector to target its audiences and readership in a more systematic way and emerge from the niche into which it has been squeezed by the conventional media. One particularly effective mechanism for stimulating media interest and awareness is the outdoor outing, taking journalists away from the daily grind of the office to field projects. At the same time, there is enormous potential in training and using the sector’s ready cadre of extension officers – already experts in transferring technical scientific information accessible to lay farmers/communities – to be effective conduits of information, potential media liaisons, and agricultural stringers and journalists. In an ideal world, the media may train or seek out journalists with expertise in agricultural reporting, but given its own resource limitations, and the reality that media managers have not yet seen this as a necessity, the agricultural sector can well capitalise on and create its own opportunities for public outreach by growing its own journalists. 11. Public journalists Communication and agricultural development in Senegal Abdoulaye Barry 12 In Senegal, like many other African countries, oral communication dominates. As a form of communication it has limitations of scope, and distortions regularly creep in. Oral communication, however, is cracking under the battering it has received from the new technologies that are spreading their tentacles to all parts of the African continent, and transforming the perceptions and reactions of everyone, including those who live in the rural areas, who still constitute the majority of the population. Radio and television are common, as well as mobile phones and internet. This change of communication modes has had a considerable impact on agriculture, which remains the main activity, involving 60% of the population and providing over two-thirds of employment. Previously marginalised and ignored by media professionals, the agricultural sector is now seen as an economic activity that deserves more attention. In Senegal, this trend has accelerated over the past 10 years. Indeed, alongside politics and sports – which continue to capture attention – agriculture has entered the headlines and it has become commonplace to see issues related to agriculture in the news. Alongside the technological evolution that has facilitated the introduction of new media, other factors have influenced this process. The main one is the reorganisation of the rural world, characterised by the emergence of strong organisations such as CNCCR (Conseil national de concertation et de coopération des ruraux). A powerful lobby, the CNCCR has encouraged the press to denounce the difficulties regularly faced by its members and to try and influence government policy. Every year it organises widely publicised tours of the countryside. Radio, TV and newspapers transform the event into a real media hype that lasts for several days. Even if the Government often accuses CNCCR of manipulating public opinion through these types of activity, there is an undeniably beneficial aspect as they have helped bring rural issues into the heart of the national debate. The collapse of the groundnut sector, the main source of income for rural Senegal, and the global food crisis have had a severe impact on Senegal. This, together with the ambitious programme launched by the Government (Grande Offensive pour la Nourriture et l’Abondance – le Plan Retour Vers l’Agriculture) are among the factors that have triggered media interest in agricultural issues. The competition fostered by the liberalisation of radio and television broadcasting has also had an impact. National television has played a pioneering role in addressing agricultural issues, and in early 2004 created a 5-minute For the last 17 years I have worked as a television journalist in Senegal. I coordinate the environment and agriculture desk with nearly a dozen journalists. I started a weekly column entitled « Plein Champ « since 2004. I have also produced several documentaries that evoke the problems of rural areas and am also Chairman of an environmental group, GREP, and PRO and Secretary General of the Agricultural Journalists Network of West Africa. 12 television news programme named “Full Field” (Plein Champ), which aired every Friday evening and was re-broadcast on Saturday afternoon. It provided early warnings to farmers, such as in the case of the fruit fly infestation in southern Senegal, and devoted time to success stories – because there are many in our country – giving a voice to farmers and field technicians. This programme broke with old ways of covering rural issues. There are some difficulties, but it has deliberately opted for regular rather than occasional coverage. In doing so the programme has built on years of practical experience and involves close collaboration between producers and government. The experience of this programme, for our country, is just a small spark, a tremor. To maintain the flame, it will be essential to make agricultural information available, provide opportunities for journalists to further their training, and strengthen the capacity of the press in general. 87 VII – 7.1 Acronyms and abbreviations 88 ACP African, Caribbean and Pacific AFRRI Africa Farm Radio Research Initiative AIDA Agricultural Innovation in Dryland Africa (EU-INCO project) AMARC World Association of Community Radio Broadcasters (l’Association mondiale des radiodiffuseurs communautaires) ARCOM Alliance des radios communautaires du Mali ARD agricultural and rural development CAADP Comprehensive Africa Agriculture Development Programme of NEPAD CANA Caribbean News Agency CARIMAC Caribbean Institute for Media and Communication, Jamaica CIRAD French Agricultural Research Centre for International Development (Centre de coopération internationale en recherche agronomique pour le développement) CMC Caribbean Media Corporation CNCCR Conseil national de concertation et de coopération des ruraux, Senegal CSDI Communication for Sustainable Development Initiative (FAO and the Italian Ministry of the Environment and Territory) CTA (ACP–EU) Technical Centre for Agricultural and Rural Cooperation CTO Caribbean Tourism Organization DSAP (SPC/EU) Development of Sustainable Agriculture in the Pacific FAO Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations FARA Forum for Agricultural Research in Africa FEPPASI Fédération des professionnels agricoles de la Sissili, Burkina Faso GAINS Ghana Agricultural Information Network System GENARDIS Gender, Agriculture and Rural Development in the Information Society programme ICRAF World Agroforestry Centre ICTs information and communication technologies IDRC International Development Research Centre IFAD International Fund for Agricultural Development IFPRI International Food Policy Research Institute IICA Inter-American Institute for Cooperation on Agriculture JADE African Journalists for Development Network K&G Knowing and Growing network (Caribbean region) KAIPPG Kenya Aids Intervention Prevention Project Group M&E monitoring and evaluation MESHA Media for Environment, Science, Health and Agriculture, Kenya MMRK Multi Media Resource Kit (Cameroon) NEPAD New Partnership for Africa’s Development NGO non-governmental organisation PELUM Participatory Ecological Land-Use Management Association for East and Southern Africa RAILS Regional Agricultural Information & Learning System (FARA) RKS Radio Kaloum stéréo, Guinea RTG Radio Télévision Guinéenne (Guinea) SADC Southern African Development Community SATNET Sustainable Agriculture Trainers Network, Uganda SIST Scientific and Technical Information System SPC Secretariat of the Pacific Community TOF The Organic Farmer (Magazine and Radio Program in Kenya) UCRC Ugunja Community Resource Centre, Kenya UNDP/COMREC United Nations Development Programme’s Unit for Community Recovery UNESCO United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization WOUGNET Women of Uganda Network 7.2 Order reports from previous seminars Implications of climate change for sustainable agricultural production systems in ACP countries Compilation document, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso, 2008 CTA, 108 pp. ISBN 978 9081 416 0 Understanding and confronting climate change: What can be done? Executive summary, Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso, 2008 ISBN 978 92 9081 417 7 Climate change in ACP nations / Changements climatiques dans les pays ACP Initiatives Africa no. 137 & 138 Bilingual DVD in English and French By A Lemoël & F Baudry (producers) CTA, People TV, 2008 Role of information and communication in the development of small and medium-sized foodprocessing enterprises in Africa Seminar report, Cotonou, Benin, 2006 CTA, 84pp, ISBN 978 92 9081 358 3 Challenges and opportunities for the ACP herbal industry Seminar highlights, South Africa, Vanuatu, Jamaica, 2000–2002 CTA, 2006, 94pp, ISBN 978 92 9081 308 8 Giving youth a voice Observatory highlights, Wageningen, The Netherlands, 2004 CTA, 2006, 98pp, ISBN 978 92 9081 335 4 Information support for sustainable soil fertility management (CD-ROM) Seminar Summary report, Arnhem, The Netherlands, 2003 CTA, 2005 Meeting the challenge of effective ACP participation in agricultural trade negotiations: the role of information and communication Seminar summary report, Brussels, Belgium, 2002 CTA, 2003, 82pp, ISBN 92 9081 277 X Meeting the challenge of effective ACP participation in agricultural trade negotiations: the role of ICM (CD-ROM) CTA seminar proceedings, Brussels, Belgium, 2002 CTA, Solagral, 2003 The economic role of women in agricultural and rural development: revisiting the legal environment Seminar summary report, Kampala, Uganda, 2001 CTA, 2002, 80pp, ISBN 92 9081 2621 Information and communication management strategies in federations of farmers’ organisations Seminar summary report, Douala, Cameroon, 2001 CTA, 2002, 48pp, ISBN 92 9081 259 1 Information and communication management strategies in federations of farmers’ organisations Seminar proceedings, Douala, Cameroon, 2001 CTA. 2002, 222pp, ISBN 92 9081 261 3 Information for agricultural and rural development in ACP countries: emerging stakeholders, new media, and priority themes Seminar proceedings, Paris, France, 2000 CTA, 2001, 322pp, ISBN 92 9081 248 6 Information for agricultural and rural development in ACP countries: emerging stakeholders, new media, and priority themes (only available in French) Seminar summary report, Paris (France), 2000 CTA, 2001, 26pp, ISBN 92 9081 250 8 89 For more information on CTA publications, or to receive CTA publications, visit the CTA website at See also CTA’s digital library, www.cta.int http://anancy.cta.int and the e-catalogue at http://cta.esmarthosting.net/ Anancy at 6700 AJ Wageningen The Netherlands www.cta.int T he Technical Centre for Agricultural and Rural Cooperation (CTA) was established in 1983 under the Lomé Convention between the ACP (African, Caribbean and Pacific) Group of States and the European Union Member States. Since 2000, it has operated within the framework of the ACP–EU Cotonou Agreement. CTA’s tasks are to develop and provide products and services that improve access to information for ARD, and to strengthen the capacity of ACP countries to acquire, process, produce and disseminate information in this area. in the Agricultural and Rural Development of ACP Countries CTA annual seminar Brussels, Belgium 12 - 16 October 2009 http://annualseminar2009.cta.int COMPILATION DOCUMENT Postbus 380 the role of media in the agricultural and rural development of ACP countries — cta annual seminar - brussels, belgium COMPILATION DOCUMENT CTA the role of MeDIA Organised by CTA in collaboration with: CTA is financed by the European Union Centre Ivoirien de Recherches Economiques et Sociales IntoPrint