Small Ruminants Marking in Ethiopia and the Need to Rethink Getachew Legese ILRI, Ethiopia 30th ESAP Annual Conference September 16, 2022 Hawassa University Introduction ❑ Ethiopia has diverse agro-ecological settings suitable for production of different kinds of livestock ❑Owns the largest livestock population in the region ❑Could not benefit from its resources ❑ There is a paradox of ➢ demand shortage by producers and ➢ supply shortage to consumers (especially export slaughterhouses) and sky rocketing price to domestic consumers Introduction (Cont’d) Number of live animals exported 10 years and income obtained 900 250,000 800 700 200,000 600 150,000 500 400 100,000 300 200 50,000 100 - - Year Number(000) Value Number of animals exported (‘000) Value in '000 USD Introduction (Cont’d) Volume of meat exported in the last 10 years 25,000 20,000 15,000 10,000 5,000 0 Quantity of exported meat in tones Introduction (Cont’d) Income Obtained from Meat Export in the Last 10 Years 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 Income obtained in million USD Objectives • To reveal the results of market failure in small ruminant sub-sector and its implications to livestock producers, the national economy, environment and the whole food system • Suggest interventions to overcome the problem of market failure and its associated results Methodology • Consultation with small ruminant value chain actors including: ✓producers, ✓ traders, ✓export abattoirs and ✓Domestic consumers • Review of: ✓Past value chain studies ✓Customs and CSA data Results The Resource Base ❑According the CSA 2021 sample survey, Ethiopia has: ➢70.3 million cattle ➢42.9 million sheep ➢52.5 million goats ➢8.1 million camels What Can be Supplied to the Market? • At annual off-take rates ➢10% for cattle ➢35% for sheep ➢38% for goats ➢6.5% for camel • The following are expected to be supplied ➢ 7.00 million cattle ➢ 15.00 million sheep ➢ 19.00 million goats ➢ 0.50 million cattle annually supplied to the market and exchanged for different purposes Consumer’s Criteria Export Market ✓ Male, uncastrated animals ✓ Animals with live weight of not more than 15 kg (for Dubai) and 24 kg (for KSA) ✓ Animals with good body condition and younger age (Under a year) ✓ These limit the number of animals that can enter the export VC. Domestic Market ✓ Both male and female animals ✓ Younger animals with relatively higher weight ✓ Weight range depends on buyers need ✓ Fattened animals ✓ Color (seasonal variation) Demand for Sheep and Goats in the Export Sector • 15 export abattoirs • Capacity to process 200K tones/annum • Can process about 20 million small ruminants/annum • But they processed only 20K tones/annum over the last years. • Used only 10% of their installed capacity • Shortage of supply of export quality animals is their major challenge Number of Male Sheep and Goats in Marketable Age Categories Animal type/species Sheep Goats Total Population (million) 42.9 52.5 Number of male animals (million) 12.4 16.01 Number 2.2 2.7 6 months- 1 year Proportion 18% 17% Number 2.4 3.3 Number 1- 2 years Proportion 19% 21% (million) and Number 3.7 5.5 Proportion (%) Above 2 years Proportion 30% 34% of male animals by age Number 8.3 11.5 Total marketable Proportion 67% 72% kept on farm over Number 6.1 8.8 1 year of age Proportion 49% 55% Implications of Delayed Marketing of Male Animals • Over 6 million male sheep and 9 million male goats are kept on the farm for over a year waiting for more price • However, experiences in improved small ruminant fattening in different locations of Ethiopia show these animals can be fattened in 3 months and fetch the price that can be obtained by feeding them for 2 years. • More benefits could be obtained from quick turn over • Resources (land, labor, feed, shelter) used in feeding one animal for more than 2 years can be used to quickly fatten about 6 animals Implications of Delayed Marketing of Male Animals (Cont’d) • Keeping an animal for longer time also promotes producing poor quality meat as the animal gets older • Against the principle of regenerative production practices of food systems • Burden on the environment/more greenhouse gas emission • Less sustainable and against the principle of CRGE Suggested Interventions • Awareness creation on regenerative production and consumption practices • Strong livestock market extension to promote value addition and marketing of animals at younger ages • Scaling out of improved fattening technologies • Scaling out the community based breeding practices • Support innovative marketing initiatives such as digital marketplaces • Market linkages between the producers and consumer cooperatives, export market actors, institutional consumers, and others Thank You! More meat milk and eggs by and for the poor CGIAR Research Program on Livestock The program thanks all donors and organizations which globally support its work through their contributions to the CGIAR system The CGIAR Research Program on Livestock aims to increase the productivity and profitability of livestock agri-food systems in sustainable ways, making meat, milk and eggs more available and affordable across the developing world. livestock.cgiar.org This presentation is licensed for use under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International Licence.