Scan to download Policy Brief No. 16 October, 2023 Nying'uro P, Craparo A.C.W, Diji C, Driouech F, Lukorito C, Minoarivelo H.O, Okem, A.E, Thiam M CLIMATE DATA, CLIMATE MODELS AND KEY MESSAGES OBSERVATIONAL 1. Insufficient observational networks, data INFRASTRUCTURE management systems and maintenance of weather observational infrastructure result in deficiency of climate data and information availability for risk management, vulnerability assessment and adaptation in Africa. 2. African climate modeling capabilities and tools need improvement for enhanced understanding of climate variability and change; and improved climate predictions and projections. 3. Africa needs investments in observation Weather station at the Kenya Meteorological Department stations, data management, processing Introduction infrastructure and human resources to support the production, dissemination Climate data plays a crucial role in climate and uptake of context-relevant climate change adaptation and mitigation efforts. Climate information and services. data provides valuable insights into historical climate patterns, long-term trends, and variability in key climate variables. This information helps scientists understand the nature and extent of climate change, including its causes, impacts, Weather observational infrastructure vulnerability, and potential future scenarios. Although Africa covers a fifth of the world’s Moreover, climate data is also used to monitor land mass, it has the lowest number of and verify the effectiveness of climate stations by comparison. Africa’s density of adaptation and mitigation efforts. This helps weather observing stations constitutes only policymakers and stakeholders evaluate the an eighth of the minimum density stipulated success of their initiatives, identify areas for by the World Meteorological Organization improvement, and make informed decisions (WMO) . It is estimated that only 10% of about future actions. the world’s ground-based observation In Africa, where compound extreme events networks are in Africa, and a little more are identified as a key risk from climate change , than half of Africa’s surface weather stations climate data can be crucial for disaster risk cannot capture data accurately. Most African management. It also serves as a fundamental regions are sparsely gauged, even with input in designing climate change impact models. respect to basic climatic and hydrological Reliable climate data is essential in assessing the variables. They often lack regular reporting vulnerabilities of different regions, ecosystems, of quality-controlled data (Figure 1 panel a). and sectors to extreme climate events such as sea- In some countries, the data collection and level rise, heat waves, droughts, or floods; and maintenance of previously installed stations aiding in the development of reliable early have lapsed for an extended period. Since warning systems and in detection and attribution the 1980s, there has been a decline in the studies. A good knowledge of prevailing climatic number of weather stations that are in conditions allows for better planning and decision operation and/or quality-controlled data has making to reduce and manage climatic risks. been declining (Figure 1 panel b). Most Developing and refining global and regional weather stations are in cities, while rural climate models that simulate the current and areas, where people are arguably vulnerable future Earth’s climate system rely on good-quality to climate variability and change, experience climate data. These models are essential for poor coverage. precise climate projections used in developing evidence-based policies and effective climate action. Policy Brief No. 16 Weather observational infrastructure Since the 1980s, there has been a decline in Although Africa covers a fifth of the world’s the number of weather stations that are in land mass, it has the lowest number of stations operation and/or quality-controlled data has by comparison. Africa’s density of weather been declining (Figure 1 panel b). Most observing stations constitutes only an eighth of weather stations are in cities, while rural the minimum density stipulated by the World areas, where people are arguably vulnerable Meteorological Organization (WMO) . to climate variability and change, Most African regions are sparsely gauged, even experience poor coverage. It is estimated that with respect to basic climatic and hydrological only 10% of the world’s ground-based variables. They often lack regular reporting of observation networks are in Africa, and a little quality-controlled data (Figure 1 panel a). In more than half of Africa’s surface weather some countries, the data collection and stations cannot capture data accurately. The maintenance of previously installed stations diversity of Africa’s landscape calls for have lapsed for an extended period. increased investment in the number of observation stations to cater for the wide- ranging climatic zones. Figure 1: Large regions of Africa lack regularly reporting and quality-controlled weather station data. This figure shows stations in Africa with quality-controlled station data used in developing the Rainfall Estimates on a Gridded Network (REGEN) interpolated rainfall product (Harrison et al., 2019). (a) A spatial representation of stations across the continent since 1950 shown as black dots and red crosses, where red crosses represent stations that were still active in 2017. (b) The decline in operational stations or stations with quality-controlled data since circa 1998, which is largely a function of declining networks in a subset of countries. Figure is derived from Carter et al. (2020). Declining investment in climate infrastructure is a The operation, maintenance and upgrading of major impediment to the operation current and future monitoring systems is one and maintenance of weather observation of the challenges facing the development and networks and related infrastructure for many management of weather observation weather observing stations in Africa. This may infrastructures in the continent. More often than reflect the lack of understanding of the benefits not, inadequate funding of NMHSs in Africa has of climate measurements and observations in been due to the low priority given to its services, socioeconomic development processes. The lack of awareness about the economic value of lack of climate information poses risks to hydro-meteorological data, and limited studies African countries, including a lack of critical demonstrating the importance of hydro- understanding of issues underpinning Loss and meteorological data. Damage. Financial sustainability ensures continuity in the The coordinated exchange of meteorological data delivery of climate services. Limited and products through the Global and unsustained funding for National Telecommunication System (GTS) of the WMO Meteorological and Hydrological Services enables real-time and varied time-scale forecasting (NMHSs) and other stakeholders responsible activities. However, the inadequate observation for collecting, analyzing, and disseminating networks in some countries impede the delivery of climate data and information. Their effort is these functions. This inadequacy contributes to poor representation of weather systems, climate patterns 2 complemented by the private sector and other stakeholders who invest in weather stations, and status of water resources affecting countries, and collect and disseminate data. consequently adversely impacts the quality and range of climate services in Africa. CLIMATE DATA, CLIMATE MODELS AND OBSERVATIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE -OCTOBER 2023 Policy Brief No. 16 In addition, inadequate and often obsolete observational data to validate and support the telecommunication facilities and networks for modeling process, scarcity of dedicated climate exchanging data and products used by NMHSs in modeling centers, and limited funding for requisite Africa hampers the efficient flow of observations research. and products, including multi-hazard early warnings. Africa’s unique climate requires customised models that are suitable for application in the continent. Given the important role of the NMHS in the This inadequacy in African climate models is a national infrastructure for supporting vital crucial missing link in the continent’s adaptation socioeconomic functions such as disaster risk planning and resilience building. In response to reduction, agriculture and food security, water these challenges, the first African Earth system resources, health, energy and transportation, model is currently under development to enable their capacity to provide better early warning more reliable projections of future climate change services to reduce disaster risks, supporting over Africa and the Southern Indian Ocean. A few national development and life-supporting other centers are likewise undertaking works activities that are sensitive to weather, climate including in Morocco (UM6P) for the development and water outcomes needs to be strengthened. and improvement of climate models and related Achieving these goals requires systematically expertise across the continent. observing and collecting data that form the foundation for monitoring and projecting weather, climate, water and related Use of climate models environmental conditions and issuance of Climate models serve as tools for researchers to warnings, alerts and advisories in a timely and analyze historical climate and gain a profound effective manner for planning and decision understanding of past climate variability and lay a making. sound basis for projecting future climate due to Increasingly, satellite based platforms are being climate change. By simulating various components used to augment ground-based observations to of the Earth system, including the atmosphere, contribute to climatological information. The oceans, cryosphere, and land surface, these models usefulness of data derived from these platforms possess the ability to recreate past climate conditions depends on how well they have been validated with precision. They also provide invaluable insights against the ground based observed datasets. into the underlying mechanisms driving climate Generally, the degree of automation of climatic fluctuations, unraveling the complex interplay of and hydrometric networks remains very low, factors that shape the evolution of the earth’s and telemetry is not used in most countries. Sub- climate and its variability. In retrospective analysis, Saharan Africa NMHS lack adequate or modern climate models play a crucial role in identifying the data acquisition and management systems for drivers of climate change. By simulating different receiving, processing, storing, disseminating, and scenarios encompassing natural and human-induced transmitting climate data and water resource forcings, these models facilitate a comprehensive data and information. Therefore, the assessment of the anthropogenic responses on the development of data management systems, climate system. Through quantifying the being one of the highest leverage activities for contributions of greenhouse gas emissions, aerosols, making climate information available for solar radiation, and other relevant variables, climate research and decision making is urgent for models enable scientists to identify the primary African countries. factors responsible for climate change, thus shedding light on the intricate dynamics of our global climate Climate models system. Climate models play a crucial role in fostering Furthermore, climate models are extensively understanding of current and future climate employed for projecting future climate conditions. variability and change. They help identify drivers By incorporating data on greenhouse gas emissions, of climate patterns and provide valuable land-use changes, and other influential factors, these projections for decision-making processes. Africa models can simulate a range of future scenarios. As a lags behind the rest of the world in developing result, they provide valuable estimates of crucial climate models customised for the continent, climate variables, such as temperature, precipitation, despite the critical need for climate model wind, and sea level rise. These projections are of outputs to address its inherent and deepening immense significance to policymakers and planners, vulnerability to the adverse effects of climate because they assist in anticipating and preparing for change. potential impacts of climate change. Climate models None of the current generation of general are critical in generating tailored information and circulation models (GCMs) was built in Africa. assessments for specific sectors and regions. Through The few models that are run in the continent a process known as downscaling, these models can have been downscaled by a few national or refine global climate projections, offering localized regional climate centers including IGAD Climate insights into the potential climate impacts on diverse Prediction and Applications Centre (ICPAC) in areas. This localized information provides an eastern Africa, the University of Cape Town in invaluable understanding of changes in water Southern Africa, The University of Mohammed resources, agriculture, coastal regions, ecosystems, VI Polytechnic (UM6P, Morocco) and the and other critical domains. Stakeholders and General Meteorological Directorate of Morocco. decision-makers can then leverage this information 3 Several reasons could account for this to develop adaptive strategies and policies that shortcoming, including limited climate expertise, address the unique challenges climate change poses. lack of computing resources, scarcity of weather CLIMATE DATA, CLIMATE MODELS AND OBSERVATIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE -OCTOBER 2023 Policy Brief No.16 A shortage of observational networks is one of countries, is quite limited and often attracts a fee the main obstacles to climate modeling in Africa. when available. This contrasts with the mandate of It is challenging to calibrate and evaluate climate NMHSs to freely share data through the WMO’s models in Africa due to the continent's Global Telecommunication System (GTS). Data comparatively small observational network. This available from Africa is typically only a small subset of is a result of insufficient and/or lack of weather the total number of stations (less than 50% of what is stations, ocean buoys, and other sensors to expected by WMO) and data types managed by the gather the data required to run climate models. NMHS8. Climate data and observation networks While data sparsity is prevalent globally, it is Climate data, comprising variables such particularly common in Africa, especially over remote as temperature, precipitation, humidity, geographies, and conflict zones. For instance, wind speed and direction, and atmospheric amongst the climate data reports received by WMO pressure at both current and future climates, during 2004-2010, Africa’s contribution was the least, constitute a fundamental basis for anchoring with less than 50% of expected data . The challenge climate action in a changing climate. Climate of data accessibility in the continent is driven by data presents enormous value in presenting several factors, including legal restrictions, low and framing climate change, assessing climate- financial investment, lack of dissemination capacity related baseline risks, understanding the and tools, and high access costs. In some cases, nature of climate variability and trends, historical climate records are available on paper and/ understanding the impacts of climate variability or magnetic tapes that have not been digitised, thus and change on different socioeconomic reducing their accessibility. Other impediments are activities, and developing and validating linked to issues of lack of trust by the NMHS of how climate predictions/projections. Data capture the meteorological data might be used (or misused) and management are equally important without their consent, especially through wanton because long term observational datasets of high sharing of their data with third parties and the risk of quality are the basis for climate risk undermining demand for their products, which may assessments, which provide the foundation for potentially lead to private profiteering at their low emissions climate resilient development expenses. In addition, data restrictions may also stem pathways for Africa. The various facets of from the need to charge fees to cover the cost of climate data management such as governance preparing and sharing data services. The lack of data of climate data management systems, data sharing slows down the development of climate sharing and availability, data analysis, data services for risk reduction and adaptation across the presentation and ICT infrastructure in continent. several cases require enhanced capacity to Challenges of data gaps can be addressed through implement, especially in vulnerable regions data rescue approaches and digitisation. This requires such as Africa. investment by African countries to fill the missing data Satellite-based data, which provide several gaps. Approaches for overcoming the challenge of benefits, including improved spatial and data availability would require both short- and long- temporal resolution, are provided freely from term solutions. Short-term solutions are approaches different global climate satellite monitoring used to overcome the scarcity of historical data centres such as the National Aeronautics needed for research and different applications, while and Space Administration (NASA) or the long-term solutions aim at addressing the challenges European Space Agency (ESA). Similarly, of data availability in future by strengthening the the IPCC Interactive Atlas provides capacities of NMHS, and also through direct efforts information on past and future climate changes by various actors to expand collection and for regions. Although satellite-based data has dissemination of weather and climate data. been increasingly used to complement climate In addition, NMHSs can leverage the efforts and data from ground-based weather stations in databases of numerous climate research institutions Africa, data gaps still exist in the continent’s across Africa, including the trans-African hydro- climatic databases. Central and eastern Africa meteorological observatory, the West African Science particularly suffer from insufficient long-term in Service Centre on Climate Change and Adaptive Land situ measurements, making climate projections Management (WASCAL) , the Southern African less accurate . Even where data exists, Science Service Centre for Climate Change, Adaptive accessing it from NMHS in Africa remains a Land Management (SASSCAL) and the AMMA- major challenge. The gaps in the data records CATCH National Observation Service and Critical make the data unsuitable for analysis to generate Zone Exploration Network as a start to bridge the information for many purposes. Many sensors climate data gaps in advance of further investment. are out of order, and real-time data is largely unavailable. Other major challenges In Africa, the low data quality of climate data is also related to climatic databases in Africa include principally due to low accuracy and/or precision. questionable data quality and limited access Weather observations and measurements are prone and use of the available datasets. Gaps in to human, instrumental, station siting and data entry spatial coverage and in time series result in errors into computers. This challenge is further incomplete understanding and knowledge of compounded by a lack of tools to perform quality control coupled with inadequate capacity to use 4 physical conditions, setbacks in climate change impact assessment, development existing tools. Where climate database management of early warning systems, and delays in systems with tools for basic quality control exist, lack planning and communication of disaster of capacity to utilise the tools is also a major cause of risks. low quality climate data. crucial for long-term resilience. CLIMATE DATA, CLIMATE MODELS AND OBSERVATIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE -OCTOBER 2023 Policy Brief No. 16 Weather station coverage is very sparse and has regional experiments such as CORDEX. They can be even been declining . Most weather stations are used for providing more detailed climate model in cities, while rural areas where people are information and then better support adaptation and arguably the most vulnerable to climate decision making in the continent. Experts indicate variability experience poor coverage. that CORDEX-Africa represents a unique initiative Additionally, a notable amount of weather with tremendous potential to change the information station data has not yet been digitized in Africa, availability on regional climate change for the African reducing their accessibility and usefulness for continent. This is expected to support more regionally climate research. Even when data exists, it is and nationally appropriate adaptation strategies. often of poor quality with inaccuracy and missing observations. To address these issues, In conclusion, further to climate models, the preliminary efforts have been made to support infrastructure supporting climate data, such as observation climate networks across Africa, computing resources and observational infrastructure, especially through different initiatives within is essential for supporting climate change policy regional climate centres and research development in Africa. institutions. However significant gaps still Conclusion remain. Robust climate data is critical to understanding trends Climate data infrastructure and changes in the climate system and assessing/ Infrastructure for climate data is essential for understanding how the climate will change in the solving climate change concerns and guiding future under different socioeconomic conditions. This policy decisions. In addition to the creation and information is critical for policy and planning in use of climate models and observational responding to climate risks. However, Africa suffers infrastructure, it also includes the gathering, from insufficient observational networks, data management, and transmission of climate data . management systems and maintenance. Investments The Coupled Model Intercomparison Projects in ground-based observation stations, data (CMIP) have been important tools in management systems, computing power and enabling strengthening climate data collection and use. access to climate data in Africa will enable the By creating cutting-edge multimodel datasets, production and dissemination of context-specific CMIP seeks to improve our understanding of climate information to support risk management, climate variability and change. This dataset adaptation planning and decision making contains climate simulations for the twentieth century as well as predictions for the twenty- Recommendation first century and beyond. It is, however, crucial • A hydro-meteorological station master plan, to note that the resolution is coarse. including Earth observatory system for Africa Various initiatives to offer regionally would go a long way to address many of the downscaled data provide improved resolution challenges facing African countries in data issues. information for better regional context Development of this masterplan would ideally planning. One such one is CORDEX, take a co-production approach, where users Coordinated Regional Climate Downscaling would highlight their weather and climate Experiment. CORDEX aims to provide climate requirements for informed decision making and projections with much greater detail and a the impacts of fulfilling those requirements. more accurate representation of localized • Funding Africa’s weather observation stations extreme events. Experts indicate that and processing infrastructure remains a critical CORDEX-Africa represents a unique initiative and urgent challenge. Developing with tremendous potential to change the communication capacity at lead institutions for information availability on regional climate meteorological and hydrological services to change for the African continent. strengthen and conduct awareness and Through an integrated but distributed data communication programs targeted at decision archive, the complete experiment design of makers, data users, and observers is essential for CMIP and CORDEX makes a variety of model securing sustainable funding. outputs openly available to researchers. This • Africa needs to build the local capacity needed accessibility encourages teamwork and makes it to manage, process and disseminate context- possible for researchers to evaluate and relevant climate information. This can be validate the performance of the models . achieved by tapping into and maximising Policymakers and stakeholders can consider the existing institutions and structures that support outcomes of such experiments and other climate services on the continent. climate data infrastructure programs when • A vast amount of historical data in Africa creating successful policies for coping with and remains undigitised. Rescuing these data through adapting to climate change. It is, however, data mining and digitisation will provide critical to note that these datasets are at a valuable historical data, thus filling gaps that resolution that may not be effectively used for currently exist in ground-based observation data local context adaptation planning as it is still on the continent. coarse. 5 • Enhancing and improving data sharing processes It is worth noting that we now have new will help progressing climate related research, interesting computing capacities (in some few model development and climate services African countries) that may serve for model diversity and quality. runs including in the context of international or CLIMATE DATA, CLIMATE MODELS AND OBSERVATIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE -OCTOBER 2023 Policy Brief No. 16 Further Reading Dinku, T., 2019: Challenges with Availability and Quality of Climate Data in Africa. Extreme Hydrology and Climate Variability, Elsevier, pp. 71-80, doi: 10.1016/B978-0-12-815998-9.00007-5 Engelbrecht, F. (n.d). The First African-Based Earth System Model. Natural Environment. https://journals.co.za/doi/pdf/10.10520/EJC179979 Galle, S. et al., 2018: AMMA-CATCH, a Critical Zone Observatory in West Africa Monitoring a Region in Transition. Vadose Zone Journal, 17(1), 180062, doi: https://doi.org/10.2136/vzj2018.03.0062. Gutiérrez, J.M., R.G. Jones, G.T. Narisma, L.M. Alves, M. Amjad, I.V. Gorodetskaya, M. Grose, N.A.B. Klutse, S. Krakovska, J. Li, D. Martínez-Castro, L.O. Mearns, S.H. Mernild, T. Ngo-Duc, B. van den Hurk, and J.-H. Yoon, 2021: Atlas. In Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis. Contribution of Working Group I to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change[Masson-Delmotte, V., P. Zhai, A. Pirani, S.L. Connors, C. Péan, S. Berger, N. Caud, Y. Chen, L. Goldfarb, M.I. Gomis, M. Huang, K. Leitzell, E. Lonnoy, J.B.R. Matthews, T.K. Maycock, T. Waterfield, O. Yelekçi, R. Yu, and B. Zhou (eds.)]. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA, pp. 1927–2058, doi: 10.1017/9781009157896.021. Kaspar, F. et al., 2015: The SASSCAL contribution to climate observation, climate data management and data rescue in Southern Africa. Advances In Science and Research, 12, 171–177, doi:https://doi.org/10.5194/asr-12-171-2015. Kaspar F., Andersson A., Ziese M., Hollmann R. (2022). Contributions to the Improvement of Climate Data Availability and Quality for Sub-Saharan Africa. Frontiers in Climate. Vol. 3 DOI=10.3389/fclim.2021.815043 James, R., et al. (2018). Evaluating Climate Models with an African Lens. Bull. Amer. Meteor. Soc., 99, 313–336, https://doi.org/10.1175/BAMS-D-16-0090.1 Trisos, C.H. et al. (2022) Africa. In: Climate Change 2022: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Contribution of Working Group II to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, UK and New York, NY, USA, pp. 1285-1455, doi:10.1017/9781009325844.011. Salack, S. et al., 2019: Designing Transnational Hydroclimatological Observation Networks and Data Sharing Policies in West Africa. Data Science Journal (DSJ), 18(1), doi: http://doi.org/10.5334/dsj-2019-033. World Meteorological Organization. State of the Climate in Africa 2019. WMO-No. 1253., 2020. ISBN 978-92-63-11253- 8. https://library.wmo.int/doc_num.php?explnum_id=10421 Taylor, K. E., Stouffer, R. J., & Meehl, G. A. (2012). An overview of CMIP5 and the experiment design. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, 93(4), 485-498. https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/bams/93/4/bams- d-11-00094.1.xml 6 CLIMATE DATA, CLIMATE MODELS AND OBSERVATIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE -OCTOBER 2023 Scan to download CONTACTS ICIPE Duduvile Campus, Kasarani P.O.Box 45801 - 00100 Nairobi, Kenya +254 759 402 260 info@agnesafrica.org www.agnesafrica.org This policy brief was prepared with technical and financial support of the following partners: 7 © Africa Group of Negotiators Experts Support - 2023 CLIMATE DATA, CLIMATE MODELS AND OBSERVATIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE -OCTOBER 2023