Feasibility of nationwide warehouse receipt system An assessment of the potential for a nationwide warehouse receipt system and recommendation for the requisite legal and regulatory framework Sudha Narayanan, Siraj Hussain, and Shahidur Rashid INTEGRATED FOOD POLICY RESEARCH PROGRAM | WORKING PAPER 015 JULY 2024 CONTENTS Acronyms and abbreviations ......................................................................................................... 1 Executive summary ........................................................................................................................ 5 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 7 2 Concept and typologies............................................................................................................ 8 2.1 Value chain finance and instruments ............................................................................... 8 2.2 Commodity-backed or inventory-based finance ............................................................... 8 2.2.1 Advantages of e-NWRs over physical warehouse receipts ........................................ 9 2.2.2 How Warehouse Receipt Systems (WRS) can help ................................................. 10 3 Global experience with WRS .................................................................................................. 12 3.1 History and evolution ..................................................................................................... 12 3.1.1 Transition countries in Europe and Central Asia ...................................................... 12 3.1.2 Africa ....................................................................................................................... 13 3.1.3 Latin America ........................................................................................................... 15 3.1.4 Asia ......................................................................................................................... 15 3.2 Lessons ......................................................................................................................... 16 3.2.1 Producer benefits..................................................................................................... 16 3.2.2 High cost of WR services ......................................................................................... 17 3.2.3 Targeting only small farmers may make it non-viable .............................................. 17 3.2.4 Price risk and general equilibrium effects ................................................................. 18 3.2.5 What it does not do for smallholders ........................................................................ 18 3.2.6 Need all sizes of participants and scale, for liquidity ................................................ 19 3.2.7 Lack of supportive policy.......................................................................................... 19 3.2.8 Stable policy environment ........................................................................................ 20 4 The Indian experience ............................................................................................................ 21 4.1 Background ................................................................................................................... 21 4.2 WRS: Conceptualization to implementation ................................................................... 23 4.2.1 The beginnings of NWR: Warehousing (Development and Regulation) Act, 2007 ... 24 4.2.2 Amendment of Rules to address emerging situations .............................................. 27 4.2.3 The transition to e-NWR and nurturing its growth..................................................... 28 4.2.4 Setting up of Repositories for managing e-NWRs .................................................... 28 4.3 Current state of WS ....................................................................................................... 29 4.4 Issues and challenges of the Warehouse Receipts Ecosystem ..................................... 33 4.4.1 Warehouses and warehouse operations .................................................................. 33 4.4.2 The e-NWRS ecosystem in India ............................................................................. 36 5 Fundamentals of setting up WRS .......................................................................................... 38 5.1 Market pre-conditions .................................................................................................... 38 5.2 Institutional, regulatory, and legal requirements ............................................................. 38 5.3 Infrastructural requirements ........................................................................................... 40 6 Options for Bangladesh.......................................................................................................... 42 6.1 Context: Does Bangladesh need a WRS? ..................................................................... 42 6.2 The way forward: Creating an ecosystem for financial deepening ................................. 47 6.2.1 Phase 1: Consultations on a legal system for warehouse registration to make them regulatable .......................................................................................................................... 47 6.2.2 Phase 2: Designing a blueprint and a roadmap for implementation.......................... 47 6.2.3 Phase 3: A pilot and an evaluation ........................................................................... 48 6.2.4 Phase 4: Revising approach and rollout ................................................................... 49 Appendix 1: A detailed timeline of Indian warehouse and WRS policies ................................. 50 Appendix 2: Commodities notified for WRS in India .................................................................. 52 Appendix 3: State-wise warehouses registered with WDRA as on March 31, 2022 ................. 54 Appendix 4: Procedure for registration of warehouses with WDRA and relaxations provided to farmer-based organizations ..................................................................................................... 55 Appendix 5: Estimates of farm and post-harvest losses in India .............................................. 56 Appendix 6: Charges for NeRL operations ................................................................................. 57 Appendix 7: The SHOGORIK scheme in Bangladesh ................................................................ 58 About the authors ......................................................................................................................... 66 Acknowledgments ........................................................................................................................ 66 References and resources ........................................................................................................... 66 TABLES Table 1: A summary of select examples from developing and transition countries ................ 16 Table 2: Some examples of state-level initiatives in India in warehousing .............................. 22 Table 3: e-NWR use in India by commodity in 2019-21 .............................................................. 32 Table 4: State-wise use of e-NWR use in India, 2019-21 ............................................................ 33 Table 5: Profile of key commodities for Bangladesh ................................................................. 43 Table 6: Price variation for selected commodities in Bangladesh, July 2018 – June 2021 ..... 44 FIGURES Figure 1: Typologies of agricultural value chain finance products ............................................. 8 Figure 2: Warehouse receipts ...................................................................................................... 10 Figure 3: A coffee buyer’s experience with WRS for coffee ...................................................... 19 Figure 4: Warehouse structure in India ....................................................................................... 23 Figure 5: Timeline of India WRS policies .................................................................................... 24 Figure 6: A stylized representation of the WRS ecosystem in India ......................................... 28 Figure 7: Trends in WDRA-registered warehouses and NWR/e-NWR ....................................... 31 Figure 8: Trends in WDRA-registered warehouses by ownership ............................................ 31 Figure 9: Regional variations in registered warehouse presence in India................................ 34 Figure 10: Monthly prices for selected commodities in Bangladesh, July 2018 – June 2021 . 45 1 ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS ACE Agricultural Commodity Exchange for Africa ADB Agricultural Development Bank ADMARC Agricultural Development and Market Corporation AGMARK Agriculture Marketing AHCX Auction Holdings Commodity Exchange AMI Agricultural Marketing Infrastructure AMIGS Agricultural Marketing Infrastructure, Grading and Standardization BADC Bangladesh Agricultural Development Corporation BASWAP Bangladesh-Swiss Agricultural Project BBS Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics BCD Basic Customs Duty BFSA Bangladesh Food Safety Authority BIDS Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies BKB Bangladesh Krishi Bank BSE Bombay Stock Exchange BSEC Bangladesh Securities and Exchange Commission BSTI Bangladesh Standards and Testing Institution CBO Community-Based Organization CCRL CDSL Commodity Repository Limited CDA/WA Cédula de Depósito Agricola / Warrant Agricola CMA Collateral Management Agreement CMC Collateral Management Companies CSE Chittagong Stock Exchange CV Coefficient of Variation CWC Central Warehousing Corporation DAE Department of Agricultural Extension DAM Department of Agricultural Marketing EACWSE Ethiopian Agricultural Commodities Warehousing Service Enterprise EBRD European Bank for Reconstruction and Development 2 ECA Europe and Central Asia ECX Ethiopian Commodity Exchange e-NAM Electronic National Agriculture Market e-NWR Electronic-based Negotiable Warehouse Receipt e-NNWR Electronic-based Non-Negotiable Warehouse Receipt ESC Electronic Silo Certificate FAO Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations FCB Foreign Commercial Bank FCI Food Corporation of India FPMU Food Planning and Monitoring Unit FPO Farmer Producer Organization FSSAI Food Safety Standards Authority of India FY Fiscal Year FYP Five-Year Plan GBY Grameen Bhandaran Yojana GDP Gross Domestic Product GGC Ghana Grains Council GoB Government of Bangladesh GoI Government of India GoP Government of Pakistan ICEX Indian Commodity Exchange IFC International Finance Corporation IFPRI International Food Policy Research Institute IFPRP Integrated Food Policy Research Program INR Indian Rupee IOSCO International Organization of Securities Commissions IPH Institute of Public Health ISAM Integrated Scheme for Agricultural Marketing JV IFPRI-BIDS-UIUC Joint Venture LGED Local Government Engineering Department LSD Local Supply Depot 3 MCX Multi Commodity Exchange MFSP Modern Food Storage Facilities Project MRA Microcredit Regulatory Authority MSAMB Maharashtra State Agriculture Marketing Board MSP Minimum Support Price MT Metric Ton NBR National Board of Revenue NCDC National Cooperative Development Corporation NCDEX National Commodity and Derivatives Exchange NERL National Electronic Repository Limited NGO Non-Governmental Organization NMCE National Multi Commodity Exchange NWR Negotiable Warehouse Receipt PACS Primary Agricultural Cooperative Credit Society PCB Private Commercial Bank PEG Private Entrepreneur Guarantee Scheme PFDS Public Foodgrain Distribution System PMEX Pakistan Mercantile Exchange Limited PPP Public-Private Partnership PSL Priority Sector Lending RAKUB Rajshahi Krishi Unnayan Bank RBM Reserve Bank of Malawi RCS Registrar of Cooperative Societies RUCAM Registro Único de Certificados, Almacenes y Mercancías SAFEX South African Futures Exchange SBP State Bank of Pakistan SCB State-Owned Commercial Bank SDC Swiss Development Corporation SEBI Securities Exchange Board of India SECP Securities & Exchange Commission of Pakistan SHG Self-Help Group 4 SHOGORIK Shoshyo Gudam Rin Prokalpo (Grain Warehouse Credit Program) SMA Stock Monitoring Agreement SME Small and Medium Enterprises SSL Shree Shubham Logistics SWC State Warehousing Corporation Tk/BDT Bangladeshi Taka UIUC University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign UNCITRAL United Nations Commission on International Trade Law UNO Upazila Nirbahi Officer USAID United States Agency for International Development VCR Value-Cost Ratio VGF Visibility Gap Fund WBG World Bank Group WDRA Warehousing Development and Regulatory Authority WFP World Food Programme WR Warehouse Receipt WRS Warehouse Receipt System WSP Warehouse Service Provider ZAMACE Zambian Commodities Exchange ZIMACE Zimbabwe Agriculture Commodity Exchange 5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Warehouse receipts systems (WRS) have been used to tackle multiple challenges faced by farmers. In the absence of adequate collateral and consequent credit constraints, a WRS enables the use of inventory as collateral for loans, thus removing a key constraint farmers face. With growing digital reach, electronic based Negotiable Warehouse Receipts (e-NWR) that can be swapped, exchanged and traded and can assist in deepening financial markets while maintaining the integrity of the sys- tem. While e-NWRS can potentially address farmer level constraints, they can also be viewed from a larger policy perspective as a system that aids government plans for food security and manage pub- lic procurement operations better and more nimbly; it can also play a key role for enhancing the effi- ciency and food quality and safety along value chains by enabling mid-stream players like traders and importers to manage these chains better. This report seeks to inform the policy process around e-NWRS by focusing on the potential of Ware- house Receipt Financing, more broadly, in the agricultural development of Bangladesh. To do this we review global evidence as well as evidence closer to home, within South Asia, to understand the pre-conditions and prerequisites for a successful system. Globally, e-NWRS have had a checkered history and only a handful of successful examples have emerged from among many attempts. These successes have come in diverse contexts – in some, e-NWRS was led by private players, while in others, the system was donor or government-driven; some have been enabled by dedicated legislation, and in others, not. There is however widespread consensus that certain conditions predispose an e-NWRS towards success. Market size and veloc- ity of transactions matter so that e-NWRS may not be appropriate for commodities whose markets are small and are traded just once. They tend to succeed when there is an incentive to store be- cause of intra-year variation in price but also for commodities where the risk of price declines is not common. Most of the successes have come where market players are diverse and include traders, importers, and processors and where e-NWRS is closely linked to commodity exchanges. Further, farmers can leverage e-NWRS and benefit from them when warehouses are accessible, where credit is still a constraint, and where preexisting relationships with moneylenders and traders are not dominant. Overall, a successful e-NWRS is predicated on the presence of clear legislation, strong trustworthy institutions that track and record receipts, inspect and register warehouses, provide oversight of the inventory and collateral, and enforce contracts. A financial system of guarantees and indemnity funds to safeguard against breach of contract is also an essential precondition. India’s experience with e-NWRS is particularly relevant for Bangladesh, on account of shared socio- economic context and institutional legacy. India’s e-NWRS journey began in 2007 but the establish- ment of the Warehouse Development Regulatory Authority (WDRA) came only in 2010. Since then, the Government of India has taken a series of steps in response to emerging issues aimed at ad- dressing barriers to uptake and operations. Despite impressive growth, India currently faces several factors that impede the growth of e-NWRS. First, registration of warehouses is not mandatory, and this implies that several warehouses remain unregistered, are managed by collateral management agencies, and issue WRs that banks accept as collateral to issue loans. This has resulted in a dual system that has restricted rapid growth of e-NWRS. Second, because of India’s federal structure, state level regulations are not necessarily harmonized leading to a fragmented regulatory structure. In the past 5-6 years, the Indian government has taken several steps to create a supportive ecosys- tem for e-NWRS. This has involved incentivizing registration of warehouses to cooperatives, farmer producer companies, self-help groups, etc. to expand the pool of players and enhance access to registered warehouses for small farmers. Further in 2019 e-NWRS has been mandated for regis- tered warehouses, though registration itself remains voluntary. Similarly, settlement of all derivative 6 contracts was mandated in 2019 to be via e-NWRS. The past two decades have also seen many state-supported programs and schemes to expand modern warehousing infrastructure, while the necessary digital infrastructure has been developed in-house. These steps have had a visible im- pact on the ecosystem. The increasing use of e-NWRS in India underscores the lessons learnt from other experiences globally – that e-NWRs are used disproportionately for a handful of commodities that trade commonly in exchanges, are used mainly by traders and processors, and are used mainly for storage for less than a year. Bangladesh has the advantage, unlike India, of potentially having a unified as opposed to a federal system. Further, Bangladesh currently has no overarching regulatory institution so that it is well placed to institute an architecture that makes processes uniform and registration mandatory. The larger question confronting the Government of Bangladesh is whether the country needs an e- NWRS. While carefully examining the need for and prospects for establishing a warehouse system, we note that although the e-NWRS may only be feasible for a small set of commodities, there is scope to institute and leverage a warehouse ecosystem for larger policy goals. For example, it can serve the Government of Bangladesh well in crafting an appropriate food security policy, in manag- ing strategic reserves, including acquisition, stocking and distribution of food. A digital ecosystem of tracking stocks of various agricultural commodities, including the imported ones, can also provide real-time information to the Government about the stock in the country as well as the availability in various regions. It can bring efficiency to entire value chain by digitizing the process of transfer of stock from one owner to another. From this perspective, the Government could proceed cautiously through a series of graduated steps in designing and implementing an e-NWRS. As a first step, the Government could launch a series of consultations with stakeholders on the potential and prospects for e-NWRS and ware- house regulation more generally. As a second step, based on these consultations and accumulated learnings from multilateral donors and global experience, the Government of Bangladesh can put in place the required legislation and institutions. As a third step, there is much merit in conducting fo- cused and carefully selected pilots for specific commodities and locations to understand better the unique challenges and constraints that need to be addressed. Several possibilities already present themselves. First, under the existing innovations of establishing driers for paddy, it is possible to link smallholders to the public procurement system for stocking paddy in registered warehouses for sale to the government. Second, the impending plans of the Chittagong Stock Exchange (CSE) to de- velop commodity exchanges for cotton, if on track, offers an opportunity for a pilot. Third, harness- ing the interests of importers, traders, and processors of commodities like fertilizers, seeds, oils, etc. offers a third flank for pilots in key locations near ports, for instance. Fourth, rejuvenating, leveraging and deepening preexisting schemes such as the Shoshyo Gudam Rin Prokalpo (SHOGORIK) offers scope for farmer-focused e-NWRS experiments. A rigorous evaluation of each of these models will yield clear actionable inputs. As the fourth step, Bangladesh would be well placed to assess home- grown models and evidence with cumulated learnings from elsewhere to chart of fruitful way for- ward. This report is part of the research undertaken under The Integrated Food Policy Research Program (IFPRP), implemented by the Ministry of Food; it is one of the core programs of the Modern Food Storage Facilities Project (MFSP). The objectives of IFPRP are: (1) to enhance institutional capacity in policy and strategic decision making of DG Food to carry out their mandates linked to wider food market issues and, (2) to address analytical gaps and support the development of an evidence- based policy framework to improve efficiency and performance of the country’s overall food storage system and management of strategic grain reserves. 7 1 INTRODUCTION Farmers throughout the developing world face challenges in accessing credit, a crucial input into farming operations. These constraints can influence their resources allocation decisions. For in- stance, even if there are opportunities for higher profits from retaining produce and wait for higher prices, they are often forced to sell immediately after harvest when prices are typically low because they need the cash to meet their families’ basic needs. Credit constraints also impact the commodity value chain starting from smallholders to the end users. Lack of access to credit limits smallholders’ ability to adopt productivity-enhancing inputs which in turn affect both input dealers and output trad- ers. Constraints faced by downstream actors including larger exporters, processors and retailers can impinge on farmers to the extent that the lack of credit shapes their procurement, financing, and trading practices. Many financial instruments and institutions have emerged to address critical challenges along the value chain, often termed value chain finance, with varying degrees of success. Governments face significant barriers in identifying the appropriate set of policies that are fit for the context and pur- pose so as to deepen financial markets that are inclusive, accessible, and support financially viable institutions. While the scope of agricultural value chain finance is broad, and there is no consensus on classifying the various financial tools, instruments, and products, we focus on a specific class of instruments called commodity-backed finance or inventory-based finance that leverage the possibil- ity of using commodities as collateral. This is especially valuable in contexts where many potential borrowers may lack the necessary collateral to access credit. The Government of Bangladesh faces both opportunities and tradeoffs in identifying appropriate fi- nancial instruments and developing an ecosystem that can ultimately increase efficiency along the value chain and contribute to increasing the welfare of smallholders. A digital ecosystem of tracking stocks of various agricultural commodities, including the imported ones, can also provide real-time information to the Government about the stock in the country as well as the availability in various regions. It can bring efficiency to the entire value chain by digitizing the process of transfer of stock from one owner to another. Agriculture contributes as much as 11.5% to Bangladesh's GDP in 2021-22 and employs approxi- mately 41% of the total workforce. As a country of small farmers, with an estimated size of opera- tional holding at 1.29 acres, small farmers are constrained to sell produce immediately after harvest and depend on expensive loans for both farm production and household consumption. Much has been written on the need to build resilient and efficient value chains in agriculture. Our broad goal is to examine the prospects of inventory-based or commodity-backed financing for agriculture in Bang- ladesh. The main purpose of this study is two-fold: (a) systematically assess whether the key pre- conditions exist in Bangladesh to make WRS feasible; and (b) analyze potential policy options for making WRS or similar institutions work. In assessing the pre-conditions, as well as alternative pol- icy options, lessons are drawn from international best practices with an in-depth look at the Indian experiences. This report is organized into six sections. It begins with a brief background on the types of inventory- based instruments and the rationale for warehouse receipts. We then present a brief historical over- view and global experience. Section 3 focusses on the Indian experience. Section 4 takes an in- depth look at the Indian experiences in implementing commodity-backed financing. Given India’s long history in policy making for agricultural credit, and many shared contextual factors, the premise is that India can offer specific lessons for Bangladesh, both emanating from its successes as well as its failures. Section 5 summarizes the lessons learnt and outlines the essential ingredients of a suc- cessful e-NWRS. The report concludes by discussing the options for Bangladesh with respect to e- NWRS. 8 2 CONCEPT AND TYPOLOGIES 2.1 Value chain finance and instruments Value chains are generally defined as the full range of activities required to bring a product or ser- vice from conception through the different phases of production (involving a combination of physical transformation and the input of various producer services), delivery to final consumers and final dis- posal after use (Kaplinsky and Morris, 2000). Agricultural value chain finance thus refers to “any or all of the financial services, products and support services flowing to and/or through a value chain to address the needs and constraints of those involved in that chain, be it a need to access finance, secure sales, procure products, reduce risk or improve efficiency within the chain” (Miller and Jones, 2010, page 2). Figure 1 provides a typology of various agricultural value chain finance products. As mentioned, for the purpose of this report we focus on warehouse receipts, which is just one form of commodity-backed or inventory-based financing. Figure 1: Typologies of agricultural value chain finance products Source: Adapted from Miller and Jones (2010). 2.2 Commodity-backed or inventory-based finance Commodity-backed or inventory-based finance leverages the use of stocks of commodities as col- lateral and can refer to both the pledge of existing stocks (known as post-harvest finance) and/or pledge of future production (as pre-harvest finance). Whereas some regard both as commodity- backed finance (Varangis and Saint-Geours, 2017, for example), others treat pre-harvest finance as receivables-based finance (Figure 1) since the inventory is not already secured. This distinction matters since the institutional arrangements and policy framework for post-harvest finance involve a system for managing physical stocks. We discuss three main types of commodity-backed finance instruments that leverage existing inventories as collateral: warehouse receipt systems, collateral management agreements, and stock monitoring agreements. 9 The warehouse receipt system (WRS) is a system that enables warehouse operators to issue re- ceipts against inventory stored in the warehouse. Coulter and Onumah (2002) define warehouse receipts (WR) as “documents issued by warehouse operators as evidence that specified commodi- ties (of stated quantity and quality) have been deposited at locations by named depositors. The de- positor may be a producer, farmer group, trader, or other individual or corporate body, and the warehouse receipt represents ownership of the stored commodity until it is sold out of the ware- house. The warehouse operator (or warehouseman) holds the stored commodity in safe custody. These warehouse receipts can be used by the depositor as collateral and be pledged for loans from financial institutions (Hollinger, Rutten and Kiriakov, 2009) In general, lenders use the value of the warehouse receipt and provide loans that cover a fraction of this value, ranging from 50-80%, fac- toring in storage and financing costs, price volatility of the commodity and the trust they have in the warehouse operator and the enforcement system more broadly.1 A variety of warehouse receipt systems (WRS) are built on this base. Figure 2 depicts the types of Warehouse receipts that a WRS can support. A WR can be non-negotiable, implying that the receipt is proof of inventory but cannot be used formally for financial purposes. These typically specify the party who has the right to these inventories and transfers of such receipts require endorsement upon such transfer. A negotiable warehouse receipt (NWR) in contrast can be exchanged, swapped, or traded. A transfer of the receipt represents the transfer of ownership of the goods that are backed. When the depositor sells the receipt and therefore the underlying crop in storage, the bank must be paid by the buyer before it releases the receipt; once released, the receipt must be presented to the warehouse alongside payment of storage and handling costs and fees in order to have the inventories delivered to their new owner. In general, these can be physical or electronic. In recent times, electronic receipts have acquired importance for their many advantages, discussed below. 2.2.1 Advantages of e-NWRs over physical warehouse receipts Traditionally the warehouses were issuing warehouse receipts in physical format and the same were accepted by the banks for extending pledge loans against the stock. Electronic Warehousing Receipts (e-WRs and e-NWRs) has several advantages over physical receipts. Some of these are mentioned below:  Physical receipts issued on paper did not have uniformity and the warehouses followed different formats. They are prone to loss, mutilation, tampering, fudging of information etc.  Physical WR treated the inventory as a unit, so that cannot be split, implying that the entire quantity is pledged to a bank against the WR. The e-NWRs on the other hand can be split with obligation to transfer only a part of the commodity.  Issuance of WRs is harder to regulate. Asset registries and the use of blockchain technologies enable easier monitoring for regulation.  Physical NWRs are associated with problems in transferability of goods in case of transfer/en- dorsements as they are not negotiable instruments. The e-NWRs are electronic receipts for which multiple transfers are easy in an online mode.  In case of physical WR, fraudulent overstatement of the value of goods is possible. With a ro- bust collateral registry and verifiability, the e-NWR is more amenable to verification at low cost 1 In general, banks and other lenders may prefer to deal with some but not all warehouse companies that issue warehouse receipts and there is no obligation on the lenders to not do so. 10 by a third party. E-NWRs can verify the market prices of commodities from publicly available sources. Figure 2: Warehouse receipts 2.2.2 How Warehouse Receipt Systems (WRS) can help WRS can potentially address many problems in developing country contexts (Coulter and Norvell, 1998; Dorward et al., 2006; Hollinger and Ruttan, 2009, Onumah, 2003).  The use of stored commodities as collateral is one way of overcoming ubiquitous collateral constraints and therefore for enhancing agricultural lending.  By reducing the pressure on farmers and small traders to sell quickly when prices are low, ware- house receipt systems also allow them to realize better prices for their products later in the crop season. They provide liquidity to farmers and traders, by allowing them to access credit or sell a better-priced forward contract rather than sell produce when prices are low, but they need cash (for example, farmers often need to sell crops immediately after harvest, when prices are low, and small, cash-constrained traders need to turn produce over quickly in small lots).  Improved storage and grading of produce is one fallout of using warehouses that prescribe quality standards, resulting in lower post-harvest losses and better produce grading and trading standards (by promoting greater use of formal warehouse storage).  A general thickening of rural financial markets and opportunities for farmers and traders to build up a formal record of good performance in these systems. Furthermore, an estab- lished system reduces transaction costs in commercial lending because management and screening of this collateral is concentrated around a relatively small number of formal ware- house operators.  Reduced intra-seasonal variation in prices. This is a wider benefit to producers and consum- ers even though they may not be directly engaged with warehouse receipt systems themselves.  Warehouse receipt systems can also complement and promote the development of com- modity exchanges. To what extent these are borne out in practice is however a separate question that we address in a subsequent section. 11 Apart from WRS, there are other commonly used inventory-backed systems, two of which are de- scribed below (Varangis and Saint-Goures, 2017). Collateral management agreements (CMAs) are tripartite arrangements involving the depositor, a collateral manager, and a financial institution. The collateral management company issues a certifi- cate of deposit (like a warehouse receipt) that the depositor can use as collateral to obtain a loan. If/When the inventory is sold, the lender is repaid the loan first and then authorizes the collateral manager to release the inventories to the new owner. Occasionally a fourth party, the buyer is also added. As is apparent, the collateral manager is the keystone. It is typically a professional firm that man- ages inventories and is trusted by the bank. Many collateral management firms offer performance guarantees, or have sufficient skills and capital, to ensure that banks are compensated even in cases of fraud. In general, the certificate of deposit issued by the collateral management agency can be registered at a collateral registry. Sometimes, these CMAs are roped in to manage e-NWRs. A stock monitoring agreement (SMA) is another form of inventory-based arrangement. Here the lenders enter into an agreement with an inspection company that periodically monitors inventory levels (and sometimes the quality) of commodities stored or shipped to a location, with the aim of ensuring traceability. These inventories can often be held on the owner’s premises and hence the inspection agency serves as a third-party monitor. CMAs can be used in countries that do not have a formal WRS, but they can also coexist with a WRS. SMAs are a much less secure form of collateral compared to WRS and CMA for the banks unless the lenders have a lot of control over monitoring (see Varangis and Sait-Goures, 2017, for example). On the lenders’ side, SMAs are used for longer-term partners whom they trust; borrowers prefer SMAs when they value the convenience of accessing inventories on their own premises to keep their production line moving. CMAs and SMAs tend to rely on general contract laws of a coun- try. The operation of a WRS typically requires a legal and regulatory framework and a warehouse licensing and inspection authority – this is often a dedicated framework exclusively for WRS, located within a broader regulatory system for secured transactions. Such a framework establishes rules for who can own and operate warehouses, who can store inventory and on what terms, and the terms on which WR can be traded and exchanged or used as collateral. An enforcement mechanism and consistent grades and quality standards are required to ensure that WRs can be used for financial purposes. The additional cost and effort required to set up and operate a WRS can be justified by its increased reach and inclusiveness. CMAs and SMAs are often accessible only to more established players already having a track record with banks, and they tend to be concentrated in the country’s main city or port. By contrast, a WRS can in theory offer access to commodity-backed financing to a wider range of market players, such as producers or smaller traders and processors. In later sections we discuss the real-world experience with many of these issues and focus now on the potential gains from establishing an e-WRS. 12 3 GLOBAL EXPERIENCE WITH WRS 3.1 History and evolution Warehouse receipts have a long but checkered history in the developing world and other emerging economies, encompassing very diverse institutional and economic contexts. This section offers a summary of experiences drawing on existing research and case studies and commentaries by ex- perts who have been involved in warehouse receipt development activities or have studied them (EBRD, 2004; Hollinger, Rutten and Kiriakov, 2009; IFC, 2013). For expository ease, we discuss these by region. 3.1.1 Transition countries in Europe and Central Asia In the former Soviet Union, forms of WRS were operating for cooperatives and the collapse of the Soviet Union, Russia and many of the eastern bloc nations who often grow excess grain, imple- mented public warehouse receipt systems (IFC, 2013). If one were to examine the Warehouse Re- ceipt Systems in European and Central Asian (ECA) countries, experiences in Bulgaria and Ka- zakhstan have demonstrated that a well-structured and efficient government regulatory agency can make significant contributions to building and maintaining trust in the system (IFC, 2013). An FAO report (Höllinger, Rutten, and Kiriakov, 2009) showed that in the 2000s 12 countries sought to develop WR systems, although such a system is most fully developed in only 3: Bulgaria, Hun- gary, and Kazakhstan. These three countries have special WR laws for grains rather than broad legislation encompassing various commodities and different commercial practices. The Hungarian system consists of three very large and well-capitalized warehousing companies carrying out exten- sive field warehousing. Bulgaria and Kazakhstan are closer to U.S. practice; both have established well-structured and efficient government regulatory agencies and indemnity funds. In Bulgaria, the WRS program started around the beginning of the millennium, with the complex tasks of drafting proper primary and secondary legislation, starting a government regulatory agency, and creating awareness of the benefits of using the system among grain producers, processors, and bankers. The concept of developing a warehouse receipt system in Bulgaria was formalized on 29 July 1998, when Parliament passed a new law for the marketing and storage of grain. The grain law regulates two types of business entities involved in the storage of grain: public warehouses and grain storage facilities. Licensed grain storage facilities do not participate in the indemnity fund and are not allowed to issue warehouse receipts. They can only provide storage services for third par- ties and the performance risk is accepted by the depositor. According to the Bulgarian legislation, a public warehouse licensed for the storage of grain is a sole proprietor (trader) whose main business activity is the storage of deposited grain and issuing of warehouse receipts. These companies should be joint stock or limited liability companies registered under commercial law. As of 2009, the system was fully operational, with 47 licensed public warehouses and more than 500,000 tons of licensed capacity, and there have been no defaults related to the activities of licensed public ware- houses (Höllinger, Rutten, and Kiriakov, 2009; IFC, 2013). A popular view is that attempts to build private warehouse receipts systems based on the contrac- tual obligations (i.e., Russia, Turkey, and Kazakhstan) by the banks and commodity exchanges are less effective compared to the legally established public warehouse systems. Yet, the Serbian expe- rience offers a cautionary tale, that poor inspection and enforcement can undermine public systems as well. Serbia introduced the system of public warehouses in 2009 backed by a well-established legal framework. The Ministry of Agriculture established a system of licensing and supervision, and an indemnity fund. However, the lack of an inspection service for public warehouses in practice has 13 led to issues, including two large-scale frauds in 2014 and 2015. Thus, despite expansion between 2010 and 2014 in public warehouse capacities and number of licensed warehouses, the system has deteriorated since then. In some countries including Poland and Slovakia, government intervention was maintained at a high level, resulting in farmers not being interested in storage using WRs. In Ukraine, there have been inconsistencies in legislation and weaknesses in the licensing process, leading to a lack of trust. 3.1.2 Africa In recent times, many African nations have begun using the warehouse receipt systems with mixed success. In Africa, most of the WRS have emerged in the context of commodity exchanges. Of the 23 exchanges in Africa, over half were still in their planning or inception stages in the mid-2010s and, with the notable exception of the agricultural futures and options traded on the Johannesburg Stock Exchange, most of the remaining are thinly traded and receive financial support from govern- ment and/or donors. On the one hand, in countries such as South Africa, the emergence of WRS was somewhat organi- cally spearheaded by large private sector players. This contract-based warehouse receipt financing without a dedicated national Act continues to stand out as something of an exception. With the es- tablishment of future and options contracts on the South African Futures Exchange (SAFEX) and the development of electronic silo certificates (ESC) in the mid-1990s, farmers were able to use these to raise collateral financing from banks. In 2004, two large silo operators established an e- system that serves as an online registry as well as a platform for NWRs. There is consensus that among African e-NWRS the success of the South African experience is something of an outlier. The existence of exchange trading is attributed to a strong presence of commercially-oriented farming as well-developed financial systems. A pioneer in establishing WRS was Ethiopia, piloting one in 2003 with little success. With the estab- lishment of the Ethiopian Commodity Exchange (ECX) in 2008, it absorbed the warehousing over- sight responsibilities from the government. A later 2015 attempt to establish the Ethiopian Agricul- tural Commodities Warehousing Service Enterprise (EACWSE) to provide warehouse management services failed on account of dissatisfaction from potential users on the quality of services. The EACWSE was then merged back to the ECX. Despite the reputation for pioneering innovation, a failed attempt to expand into the coffee sector and inability to attract volumes have resulted in thin trading of WRs. ZAMACE in Zambia and ZIMACE in Zimbabwe are two other exchanges that emerged around the same time that the Ethiopian ECX emerged. ZAMACE exists with minimal trade, and WRS were of- fers since its inception in 2007 enabled by 2010 when an Agricultural Credits Act forbade it. It was resumed in 2014, followed by Electronic Silo Certificates (ESC) using the same software as the Jo- hannesburg Software Exchange. In February 2020, ZAMACE’s ESC became tradeable on an agri- cultural commodity platform run by ZAMACE and Lusaka Securities Exchange. The ZAMACE has, however, attracted very thin volumes. The Zimbabwe Agricultural Commodity Exchange (ZIMACE) did not last long and was closed down by the Government, leading to the suspension of its silo cer- tificates program. Malawi has often been touted as a success (Baulch et al., 2018a, 2018b) and is unusual in having two, not just one, commodity exchanges: Agricultural Commodity Exchange for Africa (ACE) and Auction Holdings Commodity Exchange (AHCX) Ltd. ACE, which was established in 2006, followed the traditional model for establishing a commodity exchange by gradually diversifying from physical spot auctions to an electronic bulletin board, to a WRS with certified warehouses, to forward con- tracts. ACE consists of ACE Ltd., a limited liability commercial company, and ACE Trust, a non- 14 profit organization that has implemented various development projects. ACE has received substan- tial donor support since its inception and is now arguably the second longest running commodity ex- change in Africa after SAFEX. Established in 2013, AHCX followed an alternative model. AHCX in- vested heavily in e-trading infrastructure and exchange-owned warehouses. AHCX is described as a fully commercial platform owned by Auction Holdings Ltd., which is itself partly owned by the Agri- cultural Development and Market Corporation (ADMARC), Malawi’s main agricultural marketing and processing parastatal. AHCX enjoys considerable government support. Interestingly, Malawi had no legal framework to govern their operations beyond general contract law when both ACE and AHCX were established. However, the recent Warehouse Receipt Act and the Commodity Exchange Di- rective have fundamentally changed this situation. The Warehouse Receipt Act was approved by parliament in late 2017 and defines the legal status of warehouse receipts as documents of title. It clarifies the rights and obligations of warehouse operators and holders of warehouse receipts in ac- cordance with international best practices. The Commodity Exchange Directive was approved by the Reserve Bank of Malawi (RBM) on April 3, 2018. The Directive includes provisions for the RBM to license and regulate the exchange. Malawi’s exchanges have weathered many storms and are considered as robust institutions with a healthy trade in e-NWRS, although the predominant use of the warehouses is to store and sell, rather than for inventory-based finance. The Government of Tanzania sought to implement warehouse receipts as part of a strategy to en- sure the mainstreaming of the system for eight crops such as cotton, coffee, cashew nuts, paddy, sunflower, sesame, maize, and pigeon peas to facilitate agricultural productivity and financing for smallholder farmers. These policies include Tanzania vision 2025, National Strategy for Growth and Reduction of Poverty, National Microfinance Policy 2000, Cooperative Policy 2002, Tanzania Agri- culture Policy 1997, and Agricultural Marketing Policy 2008. The government has also put in place regulation tools, including Cooperative Societies Act 2003 (currently Tanzania Cooperative Socie- ties Act 2013) and Cooperative Societies Rules 2004, Warehouse Receipt Act 2005, Warehouse Regulations 2006, and Tanzania Warehouse Licensing Board (Coulter and Onumah, 2012). These efforts have resulted towards the creation of an enabling environment, the provision of proactive support to private operators, farmers’ organizations, NGOs, and community-based organizations (CBOs) who supply inputs and credit to smallholder farmers as well as ensuring a strong regulatory mechanism. Therefore, due to these efforts, the WRS has emerged as a way of getting around this financing problem by linking small holder farmers with financial institutions. As of the mid 2010s, re- ports suggest that the WRS enabled improvements in the quality of cashews stored, and higher prices. The use of warehouses by indigenous traders also purportedly augmented production. In 2008, backed by the Government of Ghana and supported by the US Agency for International Development (USAID), a body of Ghanaian producer groups, traders, processors, and financial in- stitutions involved in the grain trade formed the Ghana Grains Council (GGC). One of GGC’s articu- lated missions is to facilitate the integration of smallholders into more competitive markets by estab- lishing a regulated warehouse receipt system in Ghana, with the GGC itself acting as the certifica- tion and regulatory agency. As of April 2017, the GGC had certified twelve commercial warehouses with a combined storage capacity of 54,600 metric tons to issue warehouse receipts. Another model used in Ghana serves as a good example of a WR financing system designed specifically for small farmers. The basic structure of WR financing in Ghana is the formation of NGO-assisted farmers’ cooperatives that own and operate the warehouses so that they are community warehouses (Gio- vannucci). Since 1989, TechnoServe has worked closely with the Department of Cooperatives and the Agricultural Development Bank (ADB) in Ghana to encourage small scale farmers to form coop- eratives and use warehouse receipts to store their crops for sale in the lean season. ADB provided loans against the farmers’ grain, at 75-80% of current market value, and the grain is stored in coop- eratively owned warehouses. The scheme is concentrated in the Brong-Ahafo “maize triangle” of Ghana – the major area of agricultural surplus, where annual price fluctuations are high. 15 3.1.3 Latin America Latin America has seen a few successes as well. In 2014, Mexico reformed its WRS legal frame- work to provide for a centralized warehouse receipts (and pledge bonds) registry known as RUCAM administered by the Ministry of Economy. RUCAM’s objective is to provide increased legal certainty to lenders when securing obligations with pledge bonds. In contrast, the Brazilian warehousing structure is mainly controlled by private parties. Large farmers, cooperatives, trading companies (lo- cal and international) as well as millers and processors hold very large warehouse capacities. The law obliges each Warehouse manager to issue a receipt to the holder of the grain. This receipt makes the Warehouse manager fully responsible for the product quantity and quality. Warehouse receipts are not directly tradable or negotiable. However, Sellers may issue CDA/WA (Cédula de Depósito Agricola / Warrant Agricola) that can be traded on the Brazilian commodity exchange. The issuance is done through the contracting of a supervision company / WH Manager that holds the physical guarantee against the document. Financing is also possible on CDA/WA. These docu- ments are directly traded in the local commodity exchange board from seller to buyer without any intervention from the Brazilian Government. Both the issuance and trading are the responsibility of the Board that holds control on the emitting body. This possibility has been a strong developer of the Brazilian agriculture and the main string to harness private investment and private financing. 3.1.4 Asia Asia has seen varying degrees of successes and failures (IFC, 2013). For instance, both India and Thailand have developed successful regional commodity-based models. The case of India is dis- cussed in the following section. Correspondingly, Indonesia has recently seen a boost with support from the International Finance Corporation (IFC) for implementation of a broader warehouse receipt system (Höllinger, Rutten, and Kiriakov, 2009). Within South Asia, Sri Lanka, and Pakistan present contrasting experiences. In Sri Lanka, donor supported pilots for e-NWRS have largely failed. These were initiated by leveraging the Inland Trust Receipts Act of 1990. For the warehouse receipts to be converted into tradable financial instruments, a new law or amendments to the existing Securities Exchange Commission Act were needed to protect all parties involved. The Pakistan Mercantile Exchange Limited (PMEX) was established in 2007 to support trading of locally produced agricultural commodities. Under an initiative of the Government of Pakistan (GoP) led by the Securities & Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP), PMEX is working to integrate its system with Pakistan’s first Collateral Management Company (CMC) to offer an end-to-end trading facility for Pakistan’s farmers using EWRs. As part of efforts to improve institutional financing to the agricultural sector and rural population, particularly small farmers, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) announced, in October 2019, that it had amended its Prudential Regulations of Agriculture Financ- ing, SME Financing, and Corporate & Commercial Banking to allow banks to accept EWRs as col- lateral for financing. Pakistan’s Financial Institutions (Secured Transactions) Act, 2016 includes warehouse receipts in its definition of documents of title, which however does not include the elec- tronic variety. Under the new Prudential Regulations for Agriculture Financing, EWRs may be used as proof of title to pledged or hypothecated agricultural produce, which is defined as a form of secu- rity. This follows changes on 31 July 2019 by the Securities & Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) to the Collateral Management Companies (CMC) Regulations 2019, under the Companies Act 2017 to promote warehouse receipt financing and electronic trading of agricultural commodities. Amendments to the Secured Transactions Act (2016) and the 2002 Electronic Transactions Ordi- nance have been proposed to ensure that they enabled the issuance and transfers of warehouse receipts in electronic form. 16 Table 1: A summary of select examples from developing and transition countries Sources: Thunde and Baulch (2020) Their compilation is based on information from African Development Bank (2017), Miranda et al. (2019), IAPRI (2019); ACE (www.aceafrica.org/), AHCX (www.ahcxmalawi.com/), ECX (www.exc.com.et), G-Soko (http://g-soko.com/), SAFEX (www.jse.co.za/redirects/safex) accessed March 30, 2020. For Tanzania, the figures are from https://wrms.wrrb.go.tz/ware- house/data for auctioned and available cashew, accessed Oct 14, 2023. Note: GGC = Ghana Grains Council; ACE = Agricultural Commodity Exchange for Africa; AHCX Auction Holdings Commodity Exchange; ECX = Ethiopian Commodity Exchange 3.2 Lessons Existing research suggests that WRS can generate benefits along many dimensions. Yet there is consensus that the benefits of WRs must not be overstated. Some note that it is likely that small farmers are not benefitted directly but may benefit indirectly (Miranda et al, 2019). In general, the performance of WR systems has been variable and there is not much work on the precise nature of impacts. 3.2.1 Producer benefits One of the primary impacts is generated on account of the increased ability of producers to hold produce and to be able sell when prices are higher. In Zambia, producer prices were found to be almost 82% more than the alternative of selling outside of the WR system, by being able to time the Country Scheme Estab- lished Volume (MT) (latest year) Commodity Exchange Operator Comments Ethiopia Warehouse Receipt Fi- nance Initiative 2009 Minimal ECX (IFC Backed) IFC supported Warehouse Receipt Fi- nancing system launched at the Ethi- opia Commodity Exchange in partnership with Com- mercial Bank of Ethiopia on Decem- ber 26, 2019. For maize Ghana GGC Warehouse Re- ceipt System 2008 47,000 (2015) Ghana Grains Council Functional; no publicly available infor- mation on e-NWRS/WRS. Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda G-Soko 2014 1,200 (2017) East African Grains Council No publicly available information on how the project is faring Malawi ACE Warehouse Re- ceipt System 2011 28,000 ACE Despite setbacks, is functional Malawi ACHX Warehouse Re- ceipt System 2014 ACE Despite setbacks, is functional South Africa Electronic Silo Certifi- cates System 2004 3.00 million (2019- 20) SAFEX/JSH Is active and works well Tanzania Warehouse Licensing Scheme 2005 798,763 MT of cashew was auc- tioned or available (2023) Warehouse Li- censing Board Warehouse Receipts Regulatory Board is the Government Institution under the Ministry of Industry and Trade. This institution was estab- lished under the Warehouse Receipts Act No. 10 of year 2005 and Act No 3 of 2015 as amended and Regulations 2016. Continues to work well Zambia Electronic Silo Certifi- cates System 2014 Negligible ZAMACE ZAMACE is the Authorized Agency for implementation of the warehouse receipt system under the Zambia Ag- ricultural Credits Act 35 of 2010. Bulgaria 1998 In 2009, 47 opera- tors, 500,000 MT licensed capacity One of the few operational indemnity funds outside the United States. http://www.aceafrica.org/ http://www.ahcxmalawi.com/ http://www.exc.com.et/ http://g-soko.com/ http://www.jse.co.za/redirects/safex https://wrms.wrrb.go.tz/warehouse/data https://wrms.wrrb.go.tz/warehouse/data 17 sale of part of the produce (Onumah, 2003). Thunde and Baulch (2020), use ACE transactional data between 2011 and 2018, for each of 710 warehouse receipts for nine commodities. Using the exam- ple of the most important commodities maize, soya bean and pigeon pea in terms of number of e- NWRs and quantities deposited they find that there exists an inverse relationship exists between the duration of storage, the cost of financing and the returns that ACE warehouse receipt depositors make. “Storing maize and soybeans for less than 180 days generally resulted in a depositor making a profit, while storing pigeon peas for less than 270 days, also generally resulted in profits to storers. However, 73 percent of warehouse receipts issued for pigeon peas made losses compared to 48 percent for maize and 53 percent for soybeans. Wide variations in profits to storers were linked to the collapse of pigeon pea exports and a fourfold decline in maize prices in 2016-17. Gross (2023) finds similar that for maize, smallholder farmers stand to benefit substantially by using WRs and for soyabean, the gains are more consistently positive than for maize. He also finds that in the analysis of over 5 years, the potential for losses due to price declines would not have pushed farm- ers into debt on account of WRs.In the case of Ghana’s community warehouses, studies suggest that from 1992 to 1996, participating farmers in this region were able to increase their profits on grain sales by an average of 94% per year, despite the high interest rate of 42% on the short-term loans. By 1997/98, more than 130 farmer groups were being assisted and for over eight years, loan repayments were an impressive 100%. Although this system relied on NGO support in terms of its uptake and repayment record, it contrasts with grain storage that is still under parastatal control and not as vibrant. Some of the benefits resulting from the scheme include: increased food production; better food security for farming families previously forced to accept low prices when selling at the same time (harvest); reduced post-harvest losses and higher rural investment (Onumah et al, 2011). Apart from returns to storage, an unintended consequence of use of WR for loans is that farmers are more likely to use productivity enhancing inputs if they can be assured of more remunerative producer prices, rather than through subsidized distribution programs (Onumah, 2003). Value-cost ratios (VCR) – the incremental income from use of fertilizer divided by the cost of fertilizer applied is 1.81 where the crop is marketed without using the WR system and 3.86 when the system is used.2 3.2.2 High cost of WR services The absence of scale implies that WR services can be relatively expensive (Coulter et al., 2000). In Ghana and Zambia, at the turn of the century, the charges were $3.50 /ton/mth vis-à-vis $2.50/ton/mth, to ensure long term viability. Storage rates in Africa tend to be high relative to inter- national standards. Perhaps on account of that it has been pointed out that WRs are used predomi- nantly as a component in financing import and export transactions, but rarely used for commodities not traded internationally, except where the depositor is a large processor or major trading com- pany. In most African countries, this has greatly limited the benefits of the WR system in the domes- tic agricultural trade. 3.2.3 Targeting only small farmers may make it non-viable One of the major causes of lack of significant success seems to be the selection of smallholder farmers as the major target beneficiary group. This focus was justified and understandable as larger market players, say those needing more than US$50 000 of financing, already had access to fi- nance through field warehousing arrangements). Yet, there are specific difficulties facing small- holder farmers and small-scale traders with regard to costs of accessing warehouse receipt sys- tems, as they may operate at some distance from certified warehouses, they have problems bulking up stored quantities to fulfill minimum lot sizes needed to reduce storage and management costs 2 The rule of thumb is a ratio of 2 indicates fertilizer use is profitable. 18 and fees, and there are substantial costs and difficulties in organizing and managing producer and trader organizations needed to reduce these problems. Onumah (2003) emphasizes that the main users tend to be large operators, who own or can rent entire warehouses or silos, and can afford high fees (usually in thousands of dollars (US) per month). Their services are not available to farmer groups or traders who wish to deposit relatively small volumes of a commodity (e.g., 50 – 100 MTs). In Zambia, USAID sought a way of supporting the development of a warehouse receipt program that would involve smallholders and allow them to participate in the market. When an initial intervention through the Zambia Agricultural Commodity Agency was unable to establish an effective warehouse receipt system, USAID used the Produc- tion, Finance and Improved Technology project to work with the private sector and establish a new entity, the Zambia Agricultural Commodity Exchange, with a stronger commercial focus and links to a regional commodity exchange. Again, this report identifies the major focus on small farmers as one of the reasons for only limited success. 3.2.4 Price risk and general equilibrium effects Doward et al. (2006) cite Gabre-Madhin (2005) as noting that warehouse receipt systems bear risks as prices may fall during the storage period, or may not rise as much as expected, so that gains in value do not cover administration and storage costs and losses. Furthermore, price gains may themselves be reduced by widespread adoption of warehouse receipt systems. Risk prone and risk averse small farmers should not be expected to take on the risks of holding inventory, and systems therefore need to be developed for small and/or larger traders to have incentives to bear these risks. These risks will, however, be particularly high in poorly developed market systems (for exam- ple, Ethiopian grain markets) where such market innovations are most needed, leading to a ‘chicken and egg’ problem affecting wider market system development. 3.2.5 What it does not do for smallholders Höllinger and L Rutten (2009) state that the ability of a warehouse receipt system to overcome the credit access problems faced by small and poor farmers is limited due to limited marketable sur- pluses. Experiences with well-functioning warehouse receipt systems around the globe show that warehouse receipts are initially used by larger and more financially viable entities.3 Doward et al. (2006) point out too that inventory credit and other warehouse receipt systems do not directly ad- dress smallholder farmers’ critical problem of financing seasonal capital (beyond their potential to increase income from previous season sales) as these systems only allow farmers to raise credit using existing production as collateral, they do not provide a mechanism for obtaining credit to fi- nance production (unless production seasons overlap). In theory the WRS permits smallholders to store their surplus safely in a modern warehouse, allow- ing them to use the stored commodity as collateral to secure a loan to finance household consump- tion and investment needs. However, in practice, it involves significant transaction costs and com- plex risk transfers that undermines its value to the smallholder. During recent decades, there have been many initiatives to develop markets from the bottom up, with results varying from success to abject failures. 3 A mid-term evaluation report on implementation of warehouse receipt systems in Southern and Eastern Africa, funded by CFC and con- ducted by the Natural Resources Institute, provides information about Coffee Market Development and Trade Promotion in Eastern and Southern Africa (CFC/ICO/03FA) and Improvement of Cotton Marketing and Trade Systems in Eastern and Southern Africa (CFC/ICA/12FA). Uganda, the United Republic of Tanzania and Zimbabwe are the participating countries. As well as the project design and implementation weaknesses described in detail in the report, 19 Consequently, it would be logical to state that despite the promise of a significant success, the warehouse receipt system for the coffee industry in Eastern Africa, is considered generally ineffi- cient by Mr. Schluter due to lack of suitable storage infrastructure; legal and regulatory issues; lack of requisite skills; missing or weak complementary market institutions; difficulty in attracting key stakeholders especially bankers; problems encountered in ensuring smallholder participation and disabling elements in the policy environment. Figure 3: A coffee buyer’s experience with WRS for coffee 3.2.6 Need all sizes of participants and scale, for liquidity As with commodity exchanges, these difficulties may be reduced where a financially viable system can be developed for large scale farmers and traders, exploiting economies of scale for large vol- umes, and then special mechanisms developed to enable smallholder farmers to use the system (this may need some form of financial or organizational subsidy). WR systems involve major scale economies, both in terms of managing warehouses and providing regulatory oversight or certifica- tion. Indeed, the management and regulatory costs associated with 2,000 and 20,000 MT ware- housing sites are not very different. In Zambia, this challenge is being addressed by: (a) making the system open to all players including large millers and commercial farmers who should be encour- aged to participate from the outset, and; (b) starting with large warehouses in major places of con- centration. Coulter et al. (2009) notes that as the system expands, the effects gradually spread over to smaller producers and operators. The major driving forces behind a sustainable warehouse receipt system are traders, large producers, and processors. Even when smallholders do not actively participate in WRs they benefit indirectly from price smooth- ing and better information (Onumah, 2003). To date however, there is not much rigorous evidence of this. 3.2.7 Lack of supportive policy Doward et al. (2006) suggest that major systemic problems inhibiting development of warehouse receipt systems include lack of supportive policies and legal frameworks. The absence of a regula- tory regime is a critical factor. Coulter and Onumah (2002) argue that, as a consequence, ware- house service providers in Africa do not come close to fulfilling the industry’s development potential, 20 except in the atypical cases of South Africa and Zimbabwe. Weak institutions governing the ar- rangements and undermining conflict resolution and investor confidence (in this case regulatory oversight of warehouse management). 3.2.8 Stable policy environment Further, actual, or potential ad hoc government interventions in agricultural markets can be a formi- dable obstacle. For example, Coulter and Onumah (2001) noted that Governments often resort to ad hoc interventions, which can potentially undermine inventory credit programs. During the 1990s, there were two pilot inventory credit initiatives in Ghana, one of them involving small farmer co-oper- atives, and the other involving relatively larger traders storing in state-owned storage facilities. In 1997, both projects were adversely affected by an ad hoc Government decision to grant selected businesses exemption of import duties on white maize in reaction to crop forecast suggesting there would be a major food shortage. The forecast turned out to be incorrect, and the maize import seri- ously depressed market prices for two years, causing losses to those storing the domestic crop with inventory credit. Development professionals have been advocating for the WRS in many developing countries, but while they have met with some success in emerging large economies, these institutions have not quite taken root in developing countries unless heavily supported by the governments or donors (Rashid, 2015). WR systems can only deal with the limited issue of post-harvest price variation and are not in general a solution to the overarching problem of the lack of financing for long-cycle agri- cultural investment during planting time. First, WR systems have proven quite complex to build and maintain. They require credible registra- tion of the collateralized grain. Second, warehouse operators need to have deep liquidity and can extend a large amount of credit. Commercial banks such as the Yes Bank in India and Quedancor in the Philippines have worked to establish WR systems (Miller 2008), In general, lack of understanding of the system among smallholder farmers has often been a reason for the reluctance of farmers to participate directly in WRS (Shalendra, Haque, and Anu Peter 2016; McIntosh and Mansini, 2018). While on the one hand, intra year price variation and the prospect of hedging is a key motivation for depositors, WR systems can expose intermediaries to substantial commodity price risk and sudden price declines can deter users and undermine the sustainability of systems (Miranda, Mulangu, and Kemeze 2017; McIntosh and Mansini, 2018). 21 4 THE INDIAN EXPERIENCE 4.1 Background India has had a long history of policy making focused on warehousing, dating back to the Ware- housing Corporations Act of 1962 (See Appendix 1 for a longer historical view). This Act established a framework for warehousing of agricultural and other commodities and envisaged two levels of au- thorities: the federal or central level and at the state level (Government of India, 2018). The Central and State Warehousing Corporations (CWC and SWC, respectively) were established towards this end. The CWC is empowered to acquire and build godowns and warehouses in locations deemed to be appropriate, across the country. It can also run warehouses for the storage of agricultural pro- duce, seeds, manures, fertilizers, agricultural implements and notified commodities offered by indi- viduals, co-operative societies and other institutions. The SWC may do so within the State with the previous approval of the CWC. In addition to this, the CWC and SWC may arrange facilities for the transport of agricultural produce, seeds, manures, fertilizers, agricultural implements and notified commodities to and from warehouses. The CWC may also act as agent of the Government for the purposes of the purchase, sale, storage and distribution of agricultural produce, seeds, manures, fertilizers, agricultural implements and notified commodities. The SWC may act as an agent of the CWC for these purposes. In addition to these, both the SWC and CWC have been granted power to make regulations at the State and Central level, respectively. Warehousing was thus largely regu- lated by state governments and most states have warehousing laws under which they license ware- houses. Until the 2000s the thrust was on the creation of warehousing infrastructure, which was deemed to be vastly inadequate, specifically to accommodate the expansion of public procurement of food- grains in the country. Until the 1990s the focus was largely on public and cooperative sector ware- houses. The year 2000 marked a crucial turning point when the recognition that private sector role might be crucial in expanding and upgrading warehousing infrastructure. Several innovative schemes that offered capital subsidies and tax breaks provided impetus and incentives to private players to build own and operate warehouses and cold storages. Under the Income Tax Act (1961) the Government of India was already provided deduction of up to 150% for setting up warehouses with an exemption of taxes on profits for first 5 years, and a 25-30% rebate on taxes for the next five; Warehouses were also exempt from service tax and excise duty. BCD and Excise on refriger- ated containers reduced to 5 and 6% from 10 and 12.5% in 2016-17. Cold chains included in Prior- ity Sector Lending (PSL) list and given infrastructure status since 2011-12 (Naik et al., 2022). These were collectively meant to incentivize private investment in warehouses and cold storages. Several Indian states have developed creative models for Public-Private Partnerships (PPP). Raja- sthan for example privatized the running of warehouses and this resulted in an expansion in capac- ity utilization and upgradation (Naik et al., 2022). The Madhya Pradesh government, which ex- panded public procurement of wheat leveraged private warehouse construction offering guarantees of use. The Private Entrepreneur Guarantee (PEG) scheme of the Government of India (2008) for example, has enabled a rapid spread of warehousing. Under this scheme, storage gap was identi- fied in all the districts and the construction of warehouses was done largely by private investors, without any investment by the Government. FCI provided guarantee of paying storage charges /rent for ten years even if no stock was stored in these warehouses. In many cases the private entrepre- neur also took the responsibility of preservation and maintenance of stocks. As of August 2024, a capacity of 14.6 million MTs was created for storage of central pool stock of food grains by the FCI and the state agencies involved in procurement and storage of food grains under the PDS. 22 See Table 2 for more examples. However not all PPP are successful and these need to be carefully designed and executed. Table 2: Some examples of state-level initiatives in India in warehousing Source: Compiled from various government websites and WDRA (2022). Note: This is a selective list to illustrate the types of programs implemented to expand infrastructure and registration of warehouses, and should not be regarded as a complete list of all relevant programs. Based on type of ownership and use, warehouses in India, maybe classified under five heads set out below:  Public warehouses: These warehouses are set up at transportation points of highways, railways, and waterways. They are used to store goods for the public and are generally licensed by the government to private entities and co-operative societies.  Private warehouses: Private warehouses are owned by private entities for the storage of goods.  Bonded warehouses: Bonded warehouses, as a concept were introduced to facilitate deferred payment of customs duty by the importers and exporters. These warehouses are used to store imported goods under an undertaking or ’bond’, which does not allow the release of goods until Who? Year Scheme Remarks Madhya Pradesh 2012 Warehousing and Logis- tics Policy, 2012. A capital subsidy of 15 percent of the project cost or Rs 3000/MT (which- ever is lower) and an interest subsidy of 5 percent of the loan amount was introduced. Applicants were required to construct a warehouse of a mini- mum capacity of 3334 MTs and Rs 1 crore investment with the prescribed specifications of warehouses. Rajasthan 2010 Privatization The Rajasthan government awarded 38 of its 90 warehouses to Shree Shubham Logistics (SSL), a private firm, through a Swiss Challenge bid process. Maharashtra 1990 Pledge Loan Scheme of MSAMB Maharashtra For producers only. Produce is valued at market price of the day at the government regulated mandi or the Minimum Support Price announced by the government, whichever is less. Loan attracts interest of 6% (up to 180 days), 8% (180-365 days) 12% beyond. Market Committee which makes repayment of loan within the prescribed period of 6 months (180 days) are applicable for 3% interest subsidies on loan amount from MSAMB. The market committee takes responsibility for storage, monitoring, and secu- rity of the mortgaged goods free of cost. And the responsibility of the con- cerned market committee to insure mortgage of the goods. The schemes extend to warehouse receipts of State or Central Warehousing Corpora- tion. https://www.msamb.com/Schemes/PledgeFinance Gujarat 2020-21 Mukhyamantri Pak Sangrah Yojna (Gujarat) Scheme for farmers for construction of warehouse at least 20 square feet area as per specification. 50% of cost or Rs. 30,000 (thirty thousand) whichever is less; paid out in two installments, plinth and upon comple- tion); application is online India 2008 Private Entrepreneurs Guarantee Scheme (PEG) Private entrepreneurs invested in building warehouses and in many cases took responsibility for maintenance of stock. FCI provided guarantee of paying storage charges /rent for ten years even if no stock was stored in these warehouses. India 2014 Agricultural Marketing In- frastructure (AMI) under Integrated Scheme for Ag- ricultural Marketing (ISAM) Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare offers a capital investment sub- sidy sub-scheme with new guidelines from 22.10.2018. It is a credit linked capital subsidy scheme in which subsidy @25% and 33.33% (depending on beneficiary) on the capital cost of the project, subject to a capital cost norm. Tamil Nadu 2021 Special PACS registration drive Registrar of Cooperative Societies (RCS), Government of Tamil Nadu, or- ganized a drive to encourage “net worth positive PACSs” registered their warehouses in WDRA. In 2021-22, 77 warehouses with an aggregate ca- pacity of 1.53 lakh MT were registered. https://www.msamb.com/Schemes/PledgeFinance 23 the custom duties are paid. Government and private parties together manage bonded ware- houses. The Central Warehousing Corporation operated 39 custom-bonded warehouses in 20214 located at Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Bhopal, Chandigarh, Chennai, Delhi, Hyderabad, Jai- pur, J N Port, Kolkata, Kochi, Lucknow, and Mumbai.  Government owned warehouses: These warehouses are owned, managed, and controlled by central or state governments, public corporations, or local authorities.  Co-operative warehouses: These warehouses are owned, managed, and controlled by co-oper- ative societies. Members of the co-operative societies are generally offered warehousing facili- ties at lower costs than non-members.  Cold storage involves control of temperature, humidity, air composition such that agricultural produce maintains full integrity. Cold storages in India are used mainly for potatoes, chilies and increasingly for a range of spices. A diagrammatic representation of the structure of warehouse system (excluding cold storages) in India is depicted in Figure 4. Figure 4: Warehouse structure in India Source: Authors, based on review of policies. 4.2 WRS: Conceptualization to implementation Since the Sale of Goods Act (1930), receipts from warehouse keepers were always recognized as a document of title to the goods in the warehouse. Yet, there was no specific framework for WRS as such. The 1962 Act too was limited in scope, and focused on the public sector and on infrastructure, without offering a systematic framework for either regulation of private warehouses or for the estab- lishment of (e-)NWR. The first major effort to formalize the operations of warehouses came in 2007 when the Union Government enacted the Warehousing (Development & Regulation) Act. The Act came into force on October 25, 2010. It provided for a Warehousing Development and Regulatory Authority (WDRA) that was finally set up on 26 October 2010. The primary objective of the Authority 4 Farmers, cooperatives, and ag startups receive a concession of 30, 10 and 10% respectively on warehouse tariffs as of March 2023. 24 was to make provisions for the development and regulation of warehouses and create an ecosys- tem of negotiability of warehouse receipts (WR). The idea was to enable farmers to store their agri- cultural produce in warehouses which are not only scientifically constructed but which are also pro- fessionally managed so that there is an assurance of maintenance of its quality and quantity. This ecosystem was also expected to provide an efficient and transparent system of registration of ware- houses and promotion of scientific warehousing of agricultural produce. It was to improve the fiduci- ary trust of depositors of the produce so that they can raise credit from banks against the stock kept in such registered warehouses. It would bring liquidity to such stocks. Ultimately, this would promote the development of efficient supply chains of various items of agricultural produce. The WDRA thus became a central regulator for Negotiable Warehouse Receipts (NWRs). Figure 5 presents the tra- jectory of policies in India, marking key milestones. We discuss below these developments at length. Figure 5: Timeline of India WRS policies Source: Authors, based on review of policies. For a richer account of policies and milestones, see Appendix 1 based on Naik et al. (2022). 4.2.1 The beginnings of NWR: Warehousing (Development and Regulation) Act, 2007 As introduced already, the Warehousing (Development and Regulation) Act, 2007 (WDRA), was pri- marily enacted to promote warehouse receipt financing in India. “…to make provisions for the development and regulation of warehouses, negotiability of ware- house receipts, establishment of a Warehousing Development and Regulatory Authority and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.” The Act thus provided for the establishment of the WDRA as an independent regulator functioning under the overall superintendence of the Central Government. Some of the functions of the WDRA include to register all warehouses that issue NWRs, monitor and supervise them, regulate the NWRs, decide the charges that warehouses can apply for commodity, define the process to ap- prove agencies for grading commodities, regulate rates of warehousing contracts and develop and 25 use an electronic database of goods deposited in the warehouses. The salient features of the WDRA include the following:  Regulation of warehousing activities;  Liabilities of warehousemen;  Format of warehouse receipts;  A framework for settlement of disputes and appeals; and  Offences and penalties. WDR Act 2007 thus provides an elaborate system of issue of warehousing receipts. The Act men- tions that the receipt could be either in writing or in electronic form. It would be a document of title to goods in writing if it contained all the following particulars (Section 11 of WDR Act): (a) Receipt number; (b) Warehouse registration number and date up to which it is valid; Name of the warehouse and its complete postal address; (d) Name and address of the person by whom or on whose behalf the goods are deposited; (e) Date of issue of the warehouse receipt; (f) Statement that the goods received shall be delivered to the holder thereof, or that the goods shall be delivered to the order of a named person; (g) Rates of storage charges and handling charges. (h) Description of the goods or of the packages containing them with particulars of quantity and quality or grade; (I) market value of the goods at the time of deposit; (j) Private marks of depositor on the goods or packages, if any, except in the case of fungible goods; (k) Name of the insurance company indemnifying for fire, flood, theft, burglary, misappropriation, ri- ots, strikes or terrorism; (l) Whether the warehouse receipt is negotiable or non-negotiable; (m) Statement of the amount of any advance made and of any liability incurred for which the ware- houseman claims his lien; (n) Date and signature of the warehouseman or his authorized agent; (o) Declared shelf-life of goods; (p) The fact that the warehouseman holds the lien on the goods deposited for his storage and han- dling charges; and (q) That the receipt would be valid only till the date of expiry of declared shelf- life of the goods for which it is issued. The most important provision of the WDR Act is to make the electronic receipt a negotiable instrument. The Act describes a negotiable receipt as one under which the goods represented 26 therein are deliverable to the depositor or order, the endorsement of which has the effect of transfer of goods represented thereby and the endorsee for which takes a good title”. (Section 2(m) of W (D&R) Act 2007) Establishing rules for registration and inspection: Warehousing (Development and Regulation) Reg- istration of Warehouses Rules 2010 and 2017 Following the promulgation of the 2007 Act, the Union Government notified the Warehousing (De- velopment and Regulation) Registration of Warehouses Rules in 2010. They were superseded on 23rd February 2017 when the revised Warehousing (Development and Regulation) Registration of Warehouses Rules, 2017 were notified. The amended rules provide details of the process un- dertaken by the WDRA for registration of warehouse. Eligibility for registration of a warehouse requires the fulfilment of following conditions: 1. Every application shall be accompanied by necessary documents to establish the identity of the applicant. 2. The applicant has to provide documentary proof of ownership of the warehouse and effective control of the warehouse. 3. The applicant should be a fit and proper person for which he has to declare that he or his key managerial persons, has not been convicted by any court for any offence at any time in the pre- ceding five years and they have not been declared insolvent by any court. The applicant, or any of its key managerial persons, should not have been declared to be of unsound mind by any court. There are some other conditions which include that the applicant has complied with all lo- cal laws applicable for carrying out the business of warehousing. 4. The rules also mandate that the applicant or warehouseman shall have insurance coverage for the risks specified under the rules. The insurance coverage must be taken against at least fire, floods, burglary, misappropriation and riots and strikes. 5. The applicant is also required to satisfy WDRA that he meets the minimum net worth require- ments on the basis of the sum total of the capacity of the warehouses concerned and all regis- tered warehouses belonging to the applicant. In addition, he is required to maintain the minimum net worth requirements at all times during the period of registration of the warehouses. In fact, the evidence of compliance with net worth requirements must be periodically submitted to the Authority. 6. The applicant is also required to furnish a security deposit which has to be maintained with the WDRA during the period of registration of the warehouse. 7. The rules also mandate that with effect a date notified by the WDRA, no warehouseman shall issue any negotiable warehouse receipts in physical form and shall register with one or more re- positories registered with the WDRA for issuing negotiable warehouse receipts in electronic form. The WDRA conducts physical inspection of a warehouse before it is given registration. The ware- houses already registered are also periodically inspected. Since WDRA is a thinly staffed organiza- tion, it has empaneled nine professional organizations to conduct these inspections. 27 4.2.2 Amendment of Rules to address emerging situations Since their formulation, the Rules have been amended seven times, to address emerging chal- lenges, to facilitate registration of warehouses and to streamline procedures. Key amendments are discussed below. In the first few years, only 1,222 were successfully registered. In 2017, the Union Government therefore announced a transformation plan so that the WDRA activities are streamlined, and the registered warehouses are effectively monitored. The WDRA set up an online portal for registra- tion of warehouses and the entire process from receipt of applications to final approval was digitized and made online. Furthermore, to extend the reach and accessibility of WDRA registered ware- houses to farmers, the Government devised a host of measures to enable concessionary registra- tion terms to farmers-based organizations. Among these amendments of the rules, the significant ones are as follows: 1. On 20th March 2018, the rules were amended by WDRA and the amount of minimum net worth of warehousemen were notified.5 2. On 21st December 2020, the rules were further modified to provide a structure for application fees for registration and renewal of registration of warehouse with the WDRA. For a Farmer Pro- ducer Organization (FPO) or a Primary Agricultural Cooperative Credit Society (PACS), the fee was fixed at a nominal amount of Rs. 5,000 per warehouse. For example, to attract PACS to register their warehouses, WDRA is giving a number of incentives. These are: a. Registration fee is only Rs. 500 as compared to Rs 20,000 to Rs. 30,000 for others. This is applicable to self-help groups (SHGs) also. b. Net worth is required to be only positive irrespective of the capacity, while for other catego- ries, it is specified with respect to the capacity of warehouse. SHGs also enjoy this conces- sion. c. Security deposit is Rs. 50,000 per warehouse in the form of a bank guarantee or bank fixed deposit irrespective of the value of e-NWRs/e-NNWRs issued by it), while for others it is Rs.50,000 (for warehouses up to 2,000 MT capacity) and Rs 1 Lakh (for warehouses of over 2,000 MT capacity). In addition, they have to provide a percentage of value of e-NWRs is- sued as security deposit. These are significant steps to expand the reach of players. For example, as of 31 March 2022 there were as many as 67,251 functioning PACS across India. (https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1907177). 3. On 3rd November, 2021 the rules were modified to provide concessional rate of registration and renewal fee for (SHGs) too. 4. The rules were further revised on 5th April, 2022 and the rates for registration were reduced for warehouses which stored only agricultural commodities. These provided conditions that expanded the portfolio of warehouse owners that registered with the WDRA and took the institution one step closer to farmers. 5 https://wdra.gov.in/documents/32110/35427/20180321+2-3+Warehousing+%28Development+and+Regulation%29+Registra- tion+of+Warehouses+%28Amendment%29+Rules%2C+2018+-+English.pdf/77443ecf-170b-4735-5809-7e84da4e3db4 https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1907177 https://wdra.gov.in/documents/32110/35427/20180321+2-3+Warehousing+%28Development+and+Regulation%29+Registration+of+Warehouses+%28Amendment%29+Rules%2C+2018+-+English.pdf/77443ecf-170b-4735-5809-7e84da4e3db4 https://wdra.gov.in/documents/32110/35427/20180321+2-3+Warehousing+%28Development+and+Regulation%29+Registration+of+Warehouses+%28Amendment%29+Rules%2C+2018+-+English.pdf/77443ecf-170b-4735-5809-7e84da4e3db4 28 Figure 6: A stylized representation of the WRS ecosystem in India Source: Authors. 4.2.3 The transition to e-NWR and nurturing its growth After gaining experience of registration of warehouses and issuance of paper-based NWRs, the WDRA realized the challenges associated with the physical NWRs including the risk of mutilation, fudging, overwriting, damage, loss, issuance of an NWR without receiving goods, issuance of dupli- cate NWRs without following procedure, issuance of multiple NWRs for the same stock, possible delivery of stocks without surrendering the warehouse receipt and fraudulent overstatement of stock value in the warehouse receipt etc.6 To overcome these risks, the electronic Negotiable Warehouse Receipt (eNWR) were introduced by the WDRA. eNWR was made mandatory for all the registered warehouses from 1st August 2019 onwards, ensuring a distinct break from the past. In the initial years of operation of WDRA Act 2007, the registered warehouses were also issuing physical receipts. From 2017-18, the warehouses started issuing eNWRs. On August 1, 2019, the WDRA made it mandatory for registered warehouses to issue eNWRs. In 2018, Securities Ex- change Board of India (SEBI) instructed the Clearing Corporation to use eNWR only as settlement instrument for delivery of future contracts of agricultural produce. It was implemented from Septem- ber 2019 and now all future contracts are delivered only through eNWRs. These two decisions made the ecosystem acceptable to various participants in agricultural trade. 4.2.4 Setting up of Repositories for managing e-NWRs WDRA set up two repositories National Electronic Repository Limited (NERL) and CDSL Commod- ity Repository Limited (CCRL). They were responsible for creation and management of electronic Negotiable Warehouse Receipts (e-NWRs). They were mandated to provide the required access and support to warehouses, commodity exchanges and the banks. The two repositories and the 6 The introduction of e-NWR had previously been recommended by the Guru Committee (2001) and the Working Group on Warehouse Receipts and Commodity Futures of the Reserve Bank of India 2005. 29 online portal of WDRA became functional from 26th September 2017. They are responsible for accu- rate creation and maintenance of eNWRs and eNNWRs. They work to ensure confidentiality and integrity of the electronic receipts. The repositories are also responsible for enabling the transfer, pledge or removal of the pledge, e- auction of e-NWRs. They also ensure the delivery of goods in part or full, underlying the e-NWR / e- NNWR, through the warehousemen. Since their incorporation under the Companies Act, the reposi- tories have invested large amounts of money in digitization of their operations and now their opera- tions are completely online. The repositories signed legal agreement with the banks for giving them access to their platform. The banks then have direct access to platform of repositories. This digitization of repositories has ena- bled the banks to block the eNWRs so that they are not transferred before the pledge is created. This has made it easy for depositors of an agricultural commodity stored in a registered warehouse to get pledge loan sanctioned by a bank which has signed an agreement with the repository. India’s futures and commodity exchanges, National Commodity and Derivatives Exchange (NCDEX), Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX), Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE), National Multi Com- modity Exchange (NMCE/ICEX) have permitted the use of e-NWRs for settlement of derivative con- tracts of the agriculture commodities in which future trading is allowed at a given time. The e-NWR has also been integrated with electronic National Agriculture Market (e-NAM) platform of the Government of India. An interface has been enabled between e-NAM and repositories but trading of agricultural produce through eNWRs on the e-NAM platform has not taken off as yet.  eNWRs are issued in electronic form and they are uniform across India.  eNWRs can pick up the value of goods from the Agmarknet portal operated by the Union Minis- try of Agriculture. The portal picks up data from over 2600 mandis or spot markets across India.  eNWRs are regulated by WDRA and there is a seamless, digital system of issuing eNWRs. There is regular monitoring and surveillance of eNWRs.  They are backed up by W(D&R) Act 2007. It is therefore likely to result in lower litigation in courts about the ownership of stock. A new warehouse-based trading module has been introduced in the ambitious electronic National Agriculture Market (e-NAM) platform to facilitate trading from the premises of warehouses using ne- gotiable electronic warehouse receipts (e-NWR), while another module will allow farmers to get ac- cess to the e-NAM platform from collection centers set up by farmer producer organizations (FPOs). On the one hand, policy levers have been used to expand the potential users of e-NWRs and for- malizing credit. Private moneylenders, for example, used to give loans against physical WRs. But their lien was not registered but they used to take the receipt and keep it till loan was repaid. Now in the electronic system, private unlicensed money lenders do not give loans as they cannot take any receipt as there is no physical receipt. They cannot be pledgee in the repository system. 4.3 Current state of WS As is evident from this narrative account, the present ecosystem o