Evaluating the 2014 Nagoya Protocol: Effects of international exchanges of plant genetic resources

Citation

Takeshima, Hiroyuki; Mekonnen, Dawit; Spielman, David J.; and Nehring, Ryan. 2026.Evaluating the 2014 Nagoya Protocol: Effects of international exchanges of plant genetic resources. IFPRI Discussion Paper 2456. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute. https://hdl.handle.net/10568/186149

Abstract/Description

The international rules governing the conservation, exchange, and use of plant genetic resources for food and agriculture (PGRFA) have evolved through agreements including the 1993 Convention on Biological Diversity, the 2004 International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture (ITPGRFA), and the 2014 Nagoya Protocol (NP), which seeks fair and equitable benefit sharing from the use of PGRFA. Yet limited evidence on how these rules affect the international movement of PGRFA used by genebanks and breeding programs remains. This study assesses the NP’s effects using cross-country panel data from the GENESYS database. Leveraging countries’ staggered entry into the NP, we apply the difference-in-differences method developed by Callaway and Sant’Anna (2021) and gravity-model analyses that account for NP membership and general regulatory capacity in provider and recipient countries. Results indicate that joining the NP has often reduced the number of PGRFA accessions exchanged internationally, particularly for pearl millet and wheat, with negative effects persisting in multiple years after 2014. Adverse effects are also observed for other crops during substantial portions of the study period. These effects are more pronounced for countries with limited regulatory capacity to formulate and implement sound policies and regulations, proxied by the World Bank’s regulatory quality index. The findings are consistent with the hypothesis and emerging anecdotal evidence that complex access and benefit-sharing requirements discourage PGRFA exchanges because of legal uncertainty, administrative costs, and limited institutional capacity, although more formal empirical analysis is needed to test the hypothesis. Policy priorities include reviewing and streamlining NP implementation and its coordination with other exchange frameworks for certain subgroups of PGRFA, such as the ITPGRFA, that are supposed to operate separately from the NP, especially where procedures are unclear or duplicative, while investing in the legal, administrative, and genebank capacity needed to facilitate compliant PGRFA exchanges. These measures can help protect equitable benefit sharing without unnecessarily restricting access to crop diversity needed for food security, crop improvement, and climate adaptation.

Permanent link to cite or share this item

External link to download this item

DOI

Author ORCID identifiers

Contributes to SDGs

SDG 1 - No povertySDG 2 - Zero hungerSDG 3 - Good health and well-beingSDG 9 - Industry, innovation and infrastructureSDG 10 - Reduced inequalities

Investors/sponsors

CGIAR Programs and Accelerators

Share

Review Status

Internal Review

Language

en

Access Rights

Open Access Open Access

Attention